Menu
‹ Chapter 39 of 258 ›

Dr. Candlish on Baptism — By W. Page, B.A., Of Hammersmith

11 min read · Chapter 39 of 258

MANY of our readers may have met with a series of "Handbooks for Bible Classes" now being published by Messrs. T. and T. Clark, of Edinburgh. Many of them are expositions of certain books of Scripture, and when we mention that the work is done by such men as Dr. Marcus Dods, Dr. Macgregor, and others equally well known in the north of Britain, our readers will readily believe that the work is well done, and that the handbooks produced are trustworthy so far as scholarship is concerned.

Among the volumes of this series is a treatise on the Sacraments, by Professor Candlish, D.D. In a book of one hundred and twenty pages the doctor has managed to put a good deal of sound exposition in a concise and readable form. His style is clear, and those whose doctrinal standpoint coincides with the doctor's will find this an excellent book for guiding their young people in Bible classes. Nor is this unimportant. By the evangelical section of the Christian church we often feel that correct teaching about the so-called sacraments is too much neglected. These things have been expounded and illustrated by the Ritualists, and we feel certain that to some extent the success of these false teachers is due to the general ignorance of young people in our schools and Bible classes about the truth of the matter. We feel pretty sure that very seldom has such a thorough exposition of ordinances that are daily practised amongst us been put into the hands of the neophyte, except by those from whom we differ entirely as to their meaning and use.

Dr. Candlish divides his subject into three parts. The first is on a sacrament in general; the next on baptism; and the last on the Lord's supper. There are two observations we wish to make at once; one is, we heartily record our deep appreciation of very much that this volume contains, and the other is that we readily recognise the fair treatment which he deals out to us as Baptists, so fair as to disarm criticism, were it not that our convictions where we differ from the doctor are both clear and pronounced, and the points are of great importance even in his estimation. As an instance of the doctor's fairness we may refer to his note on page 65. In the text he has mentioned what we all admit—that while many Christians have held the view peculiar to the Baptists, the largest number of Christians hold the Predobaptist view. His note is:—

"This is mentioned simply as a fact, not as affording by itself any evidence of the correctness of the opinion and practice; for the majority of professing Christians can be appealed to as holding many things which we believe to be utterly erroneous."

Of the general view of sacraments which the doctor sets forth we shall say but little. He holds that they are ordered by Christ, and that no other authority has any right to order any; that they are means of grace, "not performances by which we do something to obtain God's blessing, or render to him a payment, or accomplish a work of our own, but rather exercises in which we receive what he freely gives." He treats of these sacraments as signs and as seals; but not seals to the individual, "they seal and confirm to us God's promises and Christ's love": but they do not seal us. "In the New Testament whenever Christians are said to be sealed it is not by any outward rite, but by God himself through his Spirit:" 2 Cor. i. 22; Eph. i. 13, iv. 30.

We pass over other points to notice what he has to say on the subject of baptism. He frankly admits many things about which there ought to be no question; that the meaning of the word is to bathe, and "that it corresponds to the word in the Old Testament which is generally rendered 'dip.'" As an illustration of this Old Testament word he refers to the healing of Naaman, who "dipped himself seven times in Jordan." He also says, "It is thought by most of those who have investigated the subject that immersion was the earliest form of Christian baptism, on the ground of Paul's allusions to the going down and rising up out of the water as a figure of burial and rising with Christ"

(Rom. vi. 4; Col. ii. 12): "and also of the statements of early Christian writers." Even now he admits immersion to be lawful, and that it "presents a more vivid picture of the entire cleansing of the soul from sin by the Spirit of God;" so much so that when the rite is performed by sprinkling or pouring, "we are to remember, that what is here set before us as a symbol of the grace of Christ is the entire washing of the whole person when one plunges into a pure and cleansing stream or pool of water. That is the way the rite was anciently performed; and that is its ideal which we should keep in our mind's eye."

In the same way we thankfully record our agreement with Dr. Candlish in much that he says about the things signified by baptism, its efficacy and practical use. Briefly, he says baptism signifies our need of cleansing, that Christ cleanses by the Spirit, through our fellowship with his death. He sums up the chapter in these words: "These are the principal things signified by the rite of baptism; and it will be observed that they are just the great fundamental truths of the gospel, and that a certain ceremony which so naturally and simply suggests them is a most appropriate appendage to the Word, as it proclaims to sinners the Saviour, and offers to them in him pardon, purity, and peace through his atoning sacrifice and the renewing work of the Spirit. It is a gospel in miniature, as it were, in outward act visibly presented to the eye." It will be noticed in this extract the place in which he puts the rite,—an "appendage to the Word." The expression occurs more than once as the proper place both for baptism and the Lord's supper. We are thankful for that appropriate expression. Not less clear is the doctor on the pledge given in baptism. "It is a token given by God of the actual accomplishment of that complete deliverance from sin, which it represents, i.e., regeneration and new life through the death and resurrection of Christ, and on the part of the person baptized." "It is also a token of our being the Lord's, as bought with his blood, and of our consequent obligation to love, loyalty, and service to him." That it is a means of grace when rightly used by the believer our author firmly holds. We have space for one short extract, but it is so fully justified by the experience of Baptists that we could almost believe the doctor had been a close observer of our order and of the effect of the service. "There is no great difficulty in believing, that when one who has just come to faith in Christ receives an ordinance so full of meaning and tenderness as Christian baptism, his faith is strengthened, and he is enabled by it to enter into closer fellowship with Christ."

It will perhaps be a matter of curiosity to our readers to know how the worthy doctor, after these statements and expositions, supports infant baptism as a practice, and shows the meaning, use, and efficacy of it. He has a chapter on "The persons to whom baptism is to be administered." Here he starts so cordially on the side of the Baptists that our wonder grows. His words are—"What is expressly commanded by Christ in regard to baptism is, that those who are made disciples by the preaching of the gospel should be baptized; i.e., those who had been heathens, or unbelieving Jews, but had come to believe in Jesus." Then, to meet the modern practice of his church, he conjures up a difficulty which he attempts to solve. His difficulty is,—"What are we to do with the children of the parents?" To answer this he can find no light in the statements of Scripture. Practically, there are two answers; that given by the Baptist, and that given by the Pædobaptist. His objection to the Baptist practice is that "it teaches that all who are brought up in the faith of Christ still need when they come to years of intelligence that great and entire change of heart and life that is symbolized in baptism"; whereas a child may be filled with the Holy Ghost from its mother's womb, and there are cases where the heart opens to Christ with the earliest dawnings of intelligence. Further, he thinks that the Baptists' view teaches that there can be no regeneration where there is no conscious and intelligent faith; and as there is no salvation without regeneration, infants cannot be saved. It is fair to our author that he admits that Baptists do not hold this monstrous dogma; but this, he says, is what

81

their position logically comes to; and, therefore, as an escape from his difficulty he takes refuge in Pædobaptism.

We do not know whether his fellow Pædobaptists will admire this way of stating their position as a sort of refuge for the destitute. By us there are two things to be said: first, the difficulties of the practice of the Baptists are quite imaginary; and, secondly, the position of the Pædobaptist, according to Dr. Candlish's own showing, is quite untenable.

With regard to the difficulties of the Baptist position, it is an interpolation of the doctor's to assert that Christ's command refers only to unbelieving Jews and heathens, who might afterwards believe, and who were then to be baptized. Were there not thousands of children among the unbelieving Jews and heathen when Christ spoke? And Christ, we may be sure, did not forget the children. Yet we have the doctor's own declaration that Christ commanded expressly the preaching of the gospel and the baptizing of those who believed. With all godly training it is true that in the majority of cases there is an entire change of heart and life when the children of Christian parents come to years of intelligence, and those who are filled with the Holy Ghost from the womb are a very small number, and exceptions to the rule, and any Christian rite would surely be made for the rule and not for the exception. Our Lord himself was an exception to the ordinary child, so as to be unique; but he came to John's baptism, though the remark of the Baptist was true, "I have need to be baptized of thee." Thus he fulfilled all righteousness. With regard to the matter of infant salvation, there might be some force in it if baptism were a saving ordinance, or a regenerating ordinance, or a sealing ordinance, to the individual; but both Dr. Candlish and ourselves hold that it is neither of these. It is a witness to the world, which loses much of its divine power by the practice of baptizing unconscious infants. A profession of faith cannot be made except voluntarily, and a means of grace cannot operate when the subject is not yet intelligent. We have no doubt of the salvation of those who die in infancy from Christ's own word: "Of such are the kingdom of heaven." They are quite safe without baptism, and without the word which should always go before baptism, for it is an appendage to the word.

Nor is the Pædobaptist position tenable. It confessedly does not come from the command of Christ, but is a refuge devised to meet an imaginary difficulty. One passage with which Dr. Candlish seeks to support it is 1 Cor. vii. 14, which, if he will look into Dean Stanley's Commentary, he will find tells the other way. Another is in Mark, where Christ blesses little children, in which one of our ministers has truly said there is not the shadow of a shade of support for infant baptism.

But the most awkward dilemma is when he comes to the efficacy of baptism. While he is talking about the meaning of baptism, and the pledges given in baptism, he almost entirely ignores the infants, and when he speaks of the efficacy in the case of believers' baptism, he is so true and faithful, that had he passed over the infants, it would have been a lesson fatal to his practice. He admits there is peculiar difficulty in explaining the efficacy of baptism in the case of infants, "and the Scriptural requirement of faith for the right and proper reception of the sacrament is the strongest objection against the practice of infant baptism." The doctor is a bold man, and yet strangely infatuated if he thinks he can overturn a true statement like this by the best he can bring on the other side. What can he oppose to this? First, the Westminster Confession of Faith: "The efficacy of baptism is not tied to that moment of time wherein it is administered; yet, notwithstanding, by the right use of this ordinance, the grace promised is not only offered, but really exhibited and conferred by the Holy Ghost to such (whether of age or infants) as that grace belongeth unto, according to the counsel of God's own will, in his appointed time." But this does not show the efficacy of baptism in the case of infants; for it is evident that if, according to this statement, infants, not of the elect, are baptized, it is of no efficacy to them because they are not elect! And infants of the elect baptized find it of no efficacy

6

because all their privileges and mercies they get by their election; and yet again, children of the elect who are not baptized—and there are such—lose nothing, because all privilege and blessing is assured to them in their election; so baptism has to them no efficacy. Moreover, if this dogma be true, our Presbyterian brethren wrongly classify the infants with regard to baptism. According to this, the infants to be baptized are the elect, and those not to be baptized the non-elect. Do they hold that the children of believers are all elect? or that the children of non-believers are non-elect? This would be to make the gifts of grace follow on natural birth, contrary to all Scripture and experience.

Not more satisfactory are other views of the efficacy of the baptism of infants held by our author. They are briefly that, in after life, when the child witnesses a baptism, it may be told that so in infancy it was brought to the Lord's house. Any Christian parent can see that such would be the occasion for very powerful appeals to some natures, but not more powerful than any Christian parent may address who tells his little one of his agonizing prayers and earnest hopes for his early consecration to God. A sight of the baptism of a youthful believer may by the Christian parent be used as a means of grace to his child, and it often is so used, because he has not done that which the Lord has not commanded, and by his presumption prevented the youth from the joy of personal profession of the Lord, whom his heart has learned to love and trust with all the enthusiasm of his early years and all the joy of a new affection. Dr. Candlish has so admirably described the efficacy of baptism when the believer is baptized, and the description of its efficacy in the case of infant baptism is so illogical, feeble, and remote, that we wonder his own words have not convinced him that infant baptism is a figment of mediæval Christianity, and it would have been well if the fathers of Scottish Presbyterianism, whom we all venerate and love, had laid it aside when they discarded many other fragments of Romanism that defiled the church and obscured the gospel.

Everything we make is available for free because of a generous community of supporters.

Donate