The Lost Ministry
"Some evangelists."—Eph. iv. 11.
THE Catholic Presbyterian amply justifies its claim to be the classic representative of Presbyterianism in all countries; and when we find in its August number an article on "The Evangelist and his Work," by David C. Marquis, D.D., St. Louis, it shows beyond dispute that the subject of Evangelism is occupying the thoughts of some of the leading men in that church. It is quite time that the subject should be thoroughly discussed, and the church brought to a clear understanding with reference to this, which, by its rarity in connection with church work, we have ventured to call "The Lost Ministry."
We must admit that the article in question is, on the whole, one of the fairest and most faithful we have yet seen on the subject, and we heartily sympathise with the writer when he pleads that the office of the evangelist should be recognized as supplementary to that of the pastor; that the one should be complementary to the other instead of, as too often the case, complimentary. But while making this admission, we cannot lose sight of the clerical tone which pervades the article, and must take decided exception, if not to any direct statement, at least to a good many inferences.
There can be no doubt but that, in the early church, the two offices of evangelist and pastor were separate and distinct; but many of our brethren, while admitting this, attempt to show that the former has now ceased, as has that of apostles and prophets. Why this should be so we cannot imagine, for the need for it is as great as ever, and while the necessity continues, the office must remain. A few weeks ago a leader amongst the Irish Presbyterians was heard expounding the passage at the top of this paper in the following way:—"'Some evangelists and some pastors and teachers.' We have now," said he, "our pastors who have the oversight of the work at home and our evangelists who are missionaries to the heathen." If by the heathen he means the heathen abroad, the interpretation is, at a glance, forced and unallowable, and cannot, certainly, be entertained for a moment. We also remember hearing a leader in one of our colleges declare that the church has had four Evangelists, and now those who preach the gospel are only called so by courtesy. Surely this statement must have been made in entire forgetfulness of many passages in God's word to exactly the contrary effect.
But returning to our article: the writer is severe upon those who, in the midst of the enthusiasm and excitement occasioned by the visit of the itinerant evangelist, underrate the slower and more prosaic work of the regular pastor. There are minds which can only think and act in extremes, and while we have many—too many, alas!—who support the purely pastoral office to the jealous exclusion of that of the evangelist, we have others, the more emotional and enthusiastic class, who are equally vehement and exclusive in their advocacy of the evangelistic office. There are many who are so concerned about feeding the sheep, that they complacently look on while the church only keeps up its numbers, or even gradually declines in membership and power because no fresh blood is introduced. It is well said that the existence of the
House of Lords is secured by the amount of plebeian blood which is periodically poured into its aristocratic veins; and we are quite sure that no church is safe, nay, is in imminent peril of extinction, which has not at times the fresh zeal and energy of young converts thrown into it. There are, on the other hand, certain persons who form an almost contemptuous estimate of the plodding effort necessary to the building up of a Christian church and character, and applaud the initiatory stop as the only one worthy of attention. This is folly, for converts need training as well as saving. It is wise on the part of our government to add yearly many recruits to its various regiments; but it would be superlative madness to compose whole regiments of them. Gambetta in 1870, with all his organization, found that such soldiers cut but a sorry figure before the well-disciplined troops of Germany, against whom they were arrayed.
Extremes meet in error; and it becomes an important enquiry if there is not a middle stand-point. For this Dr. Marquis pleads, and in his pleadings we uphold him. Both these extremists must consent to change their ground: on the one hand, the advocates of purely pastoral effort must see the necessity for an evangelistic agency to co-operate with it, and on the other, the adherents of purely evangelistic effort must admit the necessity of pastoral oversight as well. In this way we shall each that "happy medium" where the work of the church shall be safe.
One great fault we have to find with the writer under review is the place he assigns to evangelists. Such expressions as "mere evangelists," are found in his article, and he asks the question if there is "not a place among the official appointments of the church for this narrower ministry." The italics are ours. Now, to our mind, there is no reason either in the office itself, or in its scope, object, or institution, to warrant such an expression concerning it, and we are very much mistaken if this is not the very error which has drawn so many good men and true to that happy-go-lucky, hit-or-miss, care-for-nothing-or-nobody kind of ministry. True, the qualifications of an evangelist are not necessarily those of a pastor; but is it not as true that the qualifications for the pastorate are not those suited to the work of evangelism? The very nature of both works determines the point, in the one case unfitting the evangelist for those regular habits of study and thought so necessary to a sustained pastorate, and on the other incapacitating the pastor for that quick and intuitive action so necessary to the success of an evangelist. But, because there is a difference, shall we say there is an inferiority? It is not required that the infantry in our army should display the agility and dexterity necessary to an artilleryman in the limbering and loading of his gun; but for purposes of warfare is the infantry therefore inferior to the artillery, or vice versa? If there is to be a union of forces, and we earnestly hope the day is not far distant, it can only take place by each allowing the other perfect equality. The pastor must not lord it over the evangelist, nor the evangelist esteem himself more highly than he ought. Shall those acting on the offensive not be counted as worthy of honour as those guarding the fort? and shall not those on the defensive be as highly esteemed as the most active brethren engaged in the skirmish? The answer is clear.
17
Indeed, the work of each office so acts and reacts on the other that it is impossible to exalt one at the expense of the other, and it is a matter of supreme difficulty to determine where one ends and the other begins. We agree with our writer, that "every pastor must of necessity be an evangelist"; but we go further, and declare that every evangelist must of necessity, in some measure, be a pastor. It is impossible for a man to exercise the functions of the one office without trespassing upon those of the other; he who feeds the flock must also, in his search for pasture, find some wandering sheep; and he who, like the Master, leaves the ninety and nine to go after that which is lost, must feed those he has found while they are on their journey home. To speak plainly, if an evangelist goes to a town for, say, two months, he must, by the very nature of the case, become a pastor to many during his stay: to deny this is simply to deny a matter of experience.
Another statement to which we must take exception is, that the evangelist has "nothing to do with organization"; in other words, that he is to be turned into a mere machine, propelled by others. Now, we affirm again, having experience to confirm us in our statement, that the organizing faculty is one which must be in an evangelist to a very large degree if he is to be successful. Such a man comes to a place having, in the shortest possible time, to do the greatest possible amount of work; and to accomplish this every line must be laid properly, and every possible means used. No stone must be left unturned; but if the man has no organizing power, instead of turning the stones over, he sits down on them, and fixes them all the more firmly in their place.
Let the church lay down two principles to guide her, and we think the matter will soon be simple. First, let us admit that the office of the evangelist must be maintained; and secondly, that it must stand upon an equal footing with that of the pastorate. These two principles being acted out, the difficulty vanishes.
To prove the first proposition were an easy matter; but when so many abler men have already done so, we will let it go as said, and said, too, with all the weight of authority and scholarship at its back. We have been too long fighting with only one hand, and instead of, like the children of Benjamin, using the left, we have left it out of our reckoning. Neither office needs fear the introduction of the other, for each will be mutually helpful. As the wise man says, "Two are better than one." The office of pastor is not to the church both eyes and spectacles. In the past it has been the eye, and sometimes a capital I, too; but since it is not perfect, the spectacles are required. Two pairs of eyes will see better than one; and if the church is wise it will take the advice of the most eminent oculists, and preserve the sight it has by at once donning the spectacles of the evangelistic office. There is work enough for both, and it is a matter patent to all who have engaged in evangelistic labour, that the most of those influenced by the evangelists are those who in previous years have come under the teaching of either the pastor or Sunday-school teacher, who is the pastor's auxiliary. The evangelist cannot, therefore, on his own showing, dispense with the pastor; nor can the pastor dispense with him; for let him be as good and faithful a man as he may, his people will naturally, from long
2
usage in one particular direction, get into a rut, and out of that groove they will never be brought but by a fresh voice and varied methods of work; besides which, if the pastor does not possess that power which we lately heard described as "the art of precipitating decision," he will be glad of the help of a man who possesses that art in a more than ordinary degree. When we hear of any fears entertained on either side, we are reminded of that old Irish story, which says that the authorities of a village once met in solemn assembly and debated as to which windmill should be removed from the parish, seeing there was not wind enough to drive them loth.
We are far from defending all those who come before the public under the title of "Evangelist," ancient and noble though it be; indeed, we emphatically dissent from the practice of converted men parading their past vices as a catch cry to gain the popular ear. We can well imagine that the last state of places visited by some such is worse than the first; or as the doctor facetiously remarks, "The place which once knew them, knows them no more for ever." Yet even here we think if the matter were fairly examined the church would find herself mainly responsible. The preaching in most of our churches has become over-refined, and the natural tendency is, for those who derive no benefit from the orator's artistic feats, from a recoil of feeling, to run into wild plainness of speech. It is a matter of history as well as of experience that these unbridled agencies have always co-existed with hyper-culture, yea, have been caused by it; and many men who would have been otherwise useful have cut out their own lines, and while professedly bound for the same terminus have run their organisations (save the mark!) in opposition to the churches.
We plead that the church should recognise this office; but if the recognition is to place us on a lower footing (I speak as an evangelist) than that occupied by the now-existing ministry, then we decline to be thus recognised. To admit such a distinction would place us in the position of an erratic costermonger at Bradford, who when he took his barrow to be repaired found that the obliging blacksmith had taken off one wheel and put on a smaller one in its place. With a large wheel and a small one he pushes the barrow along the streets daily to the intense amusement of the bystanders, and at a great risk to his stock-in-trade. Such, we think, would be the position of the church with two offices unequally yoked together. The outside world would laugh at our well-meant efforts, while deploring that we had not more common sense, and the blessing which we seek would probably be lost through the inequality and its consequences. Let us have both wheels of the same size, and we shall thus run sweetly along.
It has often been thrown as a taunt in the face of missionary enterprise that when a man fails at home he is sent abroad; and no doubt there is some truth in the statement. Do not let the error be repeated when we are on the look-out for those to be set aside for evangelistic work. It is an effort which might well employ the talents of a Gabriel, and broken-down pastors are not as a rule most suitable for the work. Our best scientists do not think it beneath them to teach the elements of their science to the young, and it is a lovely sight to see hundreds of children gathered in the Royal Institution listening with perfect
19
delight to one of our leading thinkers, who esteems it his highest privilege to expound simply to them the wonders of nature. How different the principle which has hitherto been applied to Sunday-school work. If the young mind is to be trained, and impressions made which shall be more permanent than any others, we leave the rawest and least experienced of our church members to do the work. What profound ignorance and shortsightedness this policy reveals! Shall it not be reversed? and for our evangelists and Sunday-school teachers shall we not have the very best? It was a matter of delight to us some time ago to observe personally an effort in one of our large towns to reach and teach the "masses" of irreligious men, who form such a vast proportion of the population. Over two thousand men and one thousand women, if we remember aright, are thus laid hold of. But how is it done? Not by the work being left to the inexperienced and undisciplined portion of the church, but by ladies and gentlemen of position and intellect and culture taking such an intense interest in the work as to come regularly every Sunday morning, between six and seven o'clock, to teach them personally.
Never let it be said that this work can be left to anybody, which generally means nobody; but let the best men be chosen for such a glorious enterprise: there is plenty of work elsewhere for the "awkward squad." The office of an evangelist is not to gabble over the A B C of the gospel again and again without leading his hearers to an appreciation of the fulness and beauty of it. "Come to Jesus" is very good as the soul of the gospel, but it is right to give the body of the gospel as well sometimes. Epitomes are good in their place, but their place is not in the evangelistic service. A true evangelist must be prepared to meet all the difficulties of the soul, and to enter into the details of the gospel, thus leading men, not only to an emotional, but to an intelligent knowledge of the truth.
We speak as one of the representatives of "The Pastors' College Society of Evangelists," and claim for it much of what should be the true nature of such a work. We magnify our office; not, we trust, above what it deserves, but above what it is generally supposed to include. Indeed, it is amusing sometimes to notice the suspicion and prejudice and hostility with which the name, so full of sweet meaning, is greeted. "He is an evangelist!" Let us avoid him, and hamper him, and hinder him! Oh, if he were only a minister! Just as if he were not!
The idea of starting such a society was a happy one, and the title chosen is as happy as the idea itself. We are given to preaching. Let us see if we cannot preach a practical sermon upon it.
Text.—"The Pastors' College Society of Evangelists."
I. Evangelists should be trained.
This we glean from the word "college" united with the word evangelist. An evangelist should be one, knowing what he preaches, and being able to give a reason for the hope that is in him; trained to think for himself, and therefore able to influence other thinkers. He will require training as much as any pastor; and, indeed, an evangelist in a large town will require a much greater store of knowledge than a pastor in a small village. In neither case, however, is there a premium on ignorance.
II. Evangelists should be organised.
This the word "society" plainly teaches. They should be banded together for purposes of counsel and co-operation, and recognised as much as pastors are now amongst us. If they formed a society of themselves in particular, they might cease to be thorns in the side of society in general.
III. Evangelists should be united with the pastors, and work from and for and with the churches.
The two words are joined in our title, and so it should ever be. It is not necessary, we think, to disguise the denomination to which you belong; nor is it necessary to refuse all sympathy, except such as comes from that denomination. Let both offices be joined in the "Hand-in-Hand Society" until the church shall sing,—
"Evangelist and pastor just gone along!
Just gone along, just gone along!
Pastor and evangelist just gone along
To ring those charming bells!"
We proclaim the banns. Is there any just cause or impediment why those two, the pastor and the evangelist, should not be joined in holy service? Experience has none. Scripture has none. Let the marriage proceed.
Evangelist.—Will you have the pastor to be your co-worker, and take charge of the work after you are gone? I will.
Pastor.—Will you welcome the evangelist as your helper in bringing to decision those who have been impressed under your ministry, and in leading wanderers back to the fold? I will.
We proclaim them one to-day. Let both see that they reverence and love each other, and what God hath joined together let no man put asunder.
W. Y. FULLERTON, Evangelist.
