Saw Mill Science — By Stur Pen — An Evolutionist Comes Along
YESTERDAY a book agent stopped at Jimmy Riggs's hotel. Of course, Jimmy invited him after supper to go to the saw-mill to meet the neighbours. Everybody wanted to hear whether the traveller had any news. He gossiped away for some time, and finally got on the subject of evolution. This is a subject the lumbermen mostly were ignorant of. They were glad to have a chance to learn something about it from one who was a real evolutionist. With one consent they begged him to proceed.
"Well, gentlemen, it certainly is wonderful what science has discovered. Every living creature is made wholly out of one single substance. That substance is called protoplasm, or bioplasm, as some prefer to call it. And they have all developed one out of the other in regular order, just as a chicken develops out of an egg. It is strange, gentlemen, but it is true. Creation began with but a small microscopic nomad. That nomad developed into something higher, and that again into something higher still. And as it continued to develop it ramified off in all directions. That dividing off, in scientific language, is called differentiation. The protoplasm differentiates itself into limbs and members and organs and varieties and species and genera. But—to avoid scientific nomenclature, which some of you may not understand—matter is the father of the insect; the insect is the father of the worm; and the worm is the father of the eel; and the eel is the father of the fish; and the fish is the father of the bird; and the bird is the father of the four-footed beast; and the four-footed beast is the father of the ape; and the ape is the father of the man. This is the genealogy of man according to science. To be sure, this may be a little humiliating, at first sight, as compared with the genealogy of man in the commonly-received Scripture. But then such is science. And it is truly wonderful, gentlemen, what science has discovered. The rectification of the genealogy of man is the scientific event of the century. The long procession of animal life, from the mollusk and the tadpole, along the line of invertebrates and vertebrates and mammals, up to the imperial man, who crowns the apex and shows how far the tadpole has got up to the present era, is a discovery of which science may well be proud."
In this way the book agent rattled on for half an hour. The deacon and Stimpson and the schoolmaster appeared to enjoy the thing hugely. Others of the company were dazed by the number of hard words that had been used. There was a silence for some time. The book agent needed to recover his breath, and the lumbermen their wits.
At length, Stimpson asked—
"Do you recognise any creative agency in all this procession of yours?"
"Well, as to that," the man replied, "we are not all quite agreed yet. Some of us concede some sort of creative agency at the beginning; others cannot see their way to acknowledge even that much."
"And why not?" asked Stimpson again.
"Well, because it is considered unscientific," was the response. "We know nothing of any Creator. We deal merely with what we see and handle, and can measure with our calipers and weigh with our scales. It is the proud beast of science that she deals only with things that she can handle."
"Do any of you ever have any suspicion that there can be anything in this universe outside of what you get hold of with your calipers?"
"Well, no," said the man; "we feel confident we are on the right track. We take nothing on tick or trust—or on faith, as the theologians call it."
* This article from the pen of Dr. Wayland struck us as so telling that we reprint it here. We beg our readers to give it their special attention.—C. H. S.
533
"Are there any breaks or gaps in the line of development from the tadpole up to the philosopher?" asked Stimpson with increasing dryness.
"Well, as for that," returned the other, "there are a few links wanting; but only a few. A few ditches are yet to be bridged over—only a few, a very few, I assure you, sir. Take my word of honour as a gentleman for that. We are now busy seeking for the lost links, and are sure we shall find them some time or other."
"Meanwhile, you want me to take your conclusions on faith—or, rather, on tick, as the merchants would call it? You rather object to my putting faith in a God or his word on the subject, but think I ought, by all means, to put faith in you and your word? Now, if I must take things 'on tick,' I think I shall stick to the testimony of the old Book."
"But," said the book agent, "science must presuppose some things."
"No, no," said Stimpson; "you must neither presuppose nor assume anything, if you are to be scientific, as you call it. But, to come out with the plain truth, you, who claim to hold strictly to the scientific method, make a greater demand upon people's faith and trust than do all the theologians in the world. The genealogy of the Bible, which traces man's origin up to a living God, is neither irrational nor hard to accept; but to believe that he sprang from a tadpole requires more faith than would he necessary to remove all the mountains of the earth into the midst of the sea. What theologians demand is faith; what you demand is credulity. I mean not to be rude, but I must say—what I think is true—that the credulity of men of science about the origin of man has no counterpart in Christendom; and I doubt if it can be matched even in heathendom."
Matters were getting warm, but here Jimmy Riggs came nobly to the rescue of his guest. He said the subject was very interesting, but, not having much book-learning, he could not understand what was said, because so many hard words were used. He asked the book agent if he could not explain things in a more familiar way, especially such words as differ—something or other—and that protoplasm; for he did want to get hold of the idea.
"With pleasure, Mr. Riggs," said the book agent. "Let me see: how shall I state it?" and he paused to meditate. Presently his face lighted up. "I have it," said he; "I can get an illustration from your own house. Your good wife, Mrs. Riggs, makes so many very nice things for the table. First of all, she prepares a large quantity of dough. Now, the dough, Jimmy, is the protoplasm. All sorts of nice things are made out of that same dough. For instance, one part of it is made into a loaf of bread; another part is made into biscuits, another part is made into doughnuts; another part is made into mince pies. Of course, other things, such as butter and milk and sugar, may be added for some things; but still they all start out with dough of some kind or other as the protoplasm. They are very different from each other when finished, but they start out with essentially the same original substance. Now, that making of the original dough into different things, such as doughnuts and pies, may be called differentiation. They are made to vary in form and outcome."
"Oh, I see," said Jimmy. "Well, well! I never understood it before."
Yet Jimmy's mind was not clear, after all. A confused idea seemed to possess him that something had been left out. So he proceeded to inquire further—
"Yes, but what makes the dough divide up into different things? It don't divide itself up. If my wife didn't make them, the pieces of dough wouldn't differ among themselves, or whatever it is."
"Oh yes," said the book agent, with a sudden cautiousness of manner. "In that case, it is indeed your wife who makes the difference."
"Well, then," asked Jimmy, "is there no hand outside of all these different living beings that makes them differ among themselves?"
"Oh, that's a different matter," said the agent. "Science does not know of
any such power, and therefore declines to recognise any. I did not mean to have my illustration of the dough carried too far. I merely meant to explain what protoplasm and differentiation were."
"That is," continued the stupid Jimmy, who could not see that his inquiries were distasteful to the agent, "you don't recognise that my wife had anything to do with the difference between the pies, the cakes, and the doughnuts?"
"I meant," said the agent, "that for the purpose of pure science such an inquiry was not necessary."
"Well," said Jimmy, "it won't do for us to go home and tell her so. She will feed us on pure dough for the next six months until we could find out the differ—differ—differsomeness."
The schoolmaster here suddenly broke out with an ejaculation in Greek, "Me genoita!" apparently quoted from Gal. ii. 17. As he is boarding with Jimmy Riggs at present, he has special reason for wishing to undergo no such half-year's experience.
But here, to the astonishment of everybody, who should start up to the support of the book agent but Jericho Jones? He declared himself a convert; he had become an evolutionist. He could prove the theory to be sound.
