Menu
‹ Chapter 4 of 255 ›

Religion in the Eighteenth Century

16 min read · Chapter 4 of 255

ALTHOUGH Queen Anne herself was not a great woman, her reign was one of those eras in our country's annals of which readers of history are never tired, for it was characterized by a succession of remarkable events such as rarely fall to the lot of one reign. Though in point of intellect she was one of the feeblest of her race, the queen inherited all the dogged stubbornness of her family, and this hereditary characteristic showed itself in a favourable light in her successful resistance of her father's entreaties that she should enter the Church of Rome. Losing her mother in early childhood, Anne had no father worthy of the name, and she probably learned to despise his weaknesses and vices. It was her misfortune to be ruled by designing adventurers of a mental strength superior to her own; the Established Church was her idol, and her sympathies were with the plotting Jacobites, who hoped to restore her exiled brother. It was a fortunate thing, both for her own people and for posterity, that her majesty did not mature the crotchets which possessed her mind. When the queen's death made room for the Hanoverian Succession her removal was regarded by the Christian part of the population as a providential deliverance. Still, her reign is a period of absorbing interest. There were giants in those days. There were great men in the Church, and the period has always been regarded as a golden era in English literature. Party feeling ran high, and well it might, when the bone of contention was nothing less than the liberties of a free people, which the Tories would have swallowed up. It is this interesting ground and that of the succeeding reigns which Dr. Stoughton traverses in his lately published and best historical work.

Dr. Stoughton enjoys a well-earned reputation in his chosen field, and we have no doubt that his book will be read as a standard work for years to come. As a historian, he has succeeded in keeping to a middle way, always difficult to follow without tripping or coming to grief. He has won the favourable criticisms of Anglican reviewers, and at the same time he commands the respect of Nonconformists—a pretty strong evidence that it is possible for an impartial writer to please the sects all round. There are no signs of hurry in his work; he is competently acquainted with the subject; and it is fortunate both for himself and his readers that Dr. Stoughton is not afraid of offending the dignity of history by mentioning the little things which ordinary people wish to know. Historians who walk on stilts are hard to follow, and in spite of their dignity are likely to get neglected. Even the gossip of a given era should be taken account of in history, for little things in the characters of leading historical personages frequently supply the key to the whole situation.

The day of Queen Anne's accession was not an auspicious season for those who held the principles of the Revolution. How could the time

* Religion in England under Queen Anne and the Georges. By John Stoughton D.D. London: Hodder and Stoughton. 1878.

7

be promising when the new monarch was a Stuart, sufficiently superstitious to revive the custom of touching for the evil, and sufficiently wilful to determine to be supreme in the Church as well as in the State? As though a fatality were attached to the family, a reaction commenced on the very day on which the crown rested on the head of a Stuart. For the moment it seemed as though the excesses of the Restoration would be re-enacted in the eighteenth century. According to Calamy, the queen's accession was a triumph for those who were the enemies of liberty and of Nonconformity. When even moderate Whigs began to be despised, how much more was odium cast upon frequenters of conventicles. All in a day, as it were, the discovery was made that Nonconformists were enemies to the monarch and the State. The queen returned no reply to the dutiful address of The Three Denominations presented on her accession. The language of good churchmen became threatening; and, tutored by their betters, the ignorant population showed a disposition to pull down, or otherwise destroy, the meeting-houses. Modern readers regard Sacheverell as a fanatic, who inflamed people's minds against principles more reasonable than his own; but, as was the case with the red-handed zealots of the French Revolution, Sacheverell was only an embodiment of popular prejudice. This Anglican enthusiast would have been consigned either to a prison or a madhouse in a better age; in those uncanny times he became a popular idol; drunken brawlers shouted his praise, and boorish villagers danced around village maypoles in honour of Church and Queen. The new House of Commons was ready to undo all the reforms of King William's time, but happily more than one intolerant measure was rejected by the House of Lords.

Affairs grew more and more threatening all through the queen's reign. By their ill-advised prosecution of Sacheverell the government sent a firebrand through the country who did no small service in furthering the success of the Tories in the general election of 1710. Church-and-Queen riots followed in several places, and in some instances the meeting-houses of the dissenters were destroyed. Emboldened by success, the Tories became more daring and insolent, working night and day with all their power to abolish all liberty outside the pale of the Anglican Church, and to place a popish king on the throne. After repeated defeats the Bill against Occasional Conformity passed both Houses, and a little later the still more obnoxious Schism Bill was adopted. In point of fact, the Government was beginning to emulate the intolerance of the Spanish Inquisition, when the hand of providence removed Anne from the throne, and the plotters failed. With the disappearance of the last of the Stuarts from the scene, liberty again became something more than a name in England.

On the death of Anne, before their traitorous schemes were half completed, nothing could exceed the consternation of the High Church party, the Nonjurors, and the Jacobites. A headstrong, double-dealing fanatic like Atterbury, bishop of Rochester, might offer to proclaim "James the Third" at Charing Cross in full canonicals, but his allies were more cautious; and, while they hesitated, the Protestant Succession, in the person of George I., had already been proclaimed by "Bold Bradbury" in the meeting-house of Fetter Lane. Bradbury

performed this piece of service with a satisfaction more intense than we in these days can realize. The story is well known of his walking up and down Smithfield on the Sabbath morning of the queen's death, and there encountering Bishop Burnet, who, in reply to the Nonconformist's anticipations of renewed persecution, mentioned the report of the queen's illness and the possibility of her decease. The signal agreed upon—the dropping of a handkerchief from the gallery by Burnet's messenger—told of Anne's death, and, before the conclusion of the service in Fetter Lane, the accession to the throne of the present royal family was announced to the congregation.

Thus news of an event which took place at seven a.m. was several hours in travelling to Fetter Lane, and, when the truth became known, those who were not of a disposition to rejoice at anyone's death were still overjoyed on account of the quiet triumph of the Protestant Succession. The question of the Succession had created great excitement in England, and a harsh letter from Anne to her relative, Sophia of Hanover, is said to have hastened the death of that princess, who, as grand-daughter of James I., would have become Queen of Great Britain had she survived a few weeks longer. On the other hand, it is supposed that a few weeks added to the life of Anne would have changed the current of English history. The air was filled with rumours of plots which fell through because they had not time to ripen, and a storm of discomfiture overtook those who had hoped to instal the pretended James III.

Though he was not an Englishman, and had few tastes such as the best of our educated forefathers could admire, George I. was welcomed to his new empire by the popular vote, the Nonconformists especially being enthusiastically devoted to his interests. The cause represented by King George rather than the man himself was dear to Englishmen. Though not a pattern either in religion or in morals, George I. contrasted favourably with certain of the Stuarts; and he represented a good cause, for he was the hope of Protestantism. The Dissenters generally would have subscribed to the remark of Bradbury, that the accession of the House of Brunswick was the resurrection of liberty.

Bradbury, who prided himself that he had been the first to announce to the people the new dynasty, was a representative man, whether we view him as an orthodox divine of the Old Dissent, or as a politician who had been a man of war as well as a preacher from his youth. As Dr. Stoughton tells us: "The populace in the riot of 1700 burnt his meeting-house; he was, as he says, 'lampooned in pamphlets, derided in newspapers, threatened by great men and mobbed by the baser sort,' but none of these things moved him." While fearing God, he was a veteran who knew nothing about the fear of man. It used to be believed that Bradbury, overjoyed at the extinction of the Jacobites' hopes, preached a sermon from the text, "Go, see now this cursed woman, and bury her," &c.; but we are not obliged to believe that so shrewd a man would commit himself by so impolitic an act. The Fetter-lane pastor was a man of sense, and this could hardly have been the case if he had been the preacher of such a sermon.

Bradbury and Burnet were two representative Liberals of that bygone age, and the intimate acquaintance of the determined Dissenter

9

with the large-minded Churchman is characteristic of a state of things which has long since passed away. The Bishop of Salisbury was a good man, to whom the liberties of England were dear; his charitable bearing towards other denominations was exemplary, his learning was extensive, and an unequivocal testimony to the worth of his character is seen in his being the object of the bitter hatred of unprincipled courtiers—men whose names in many instances are either forgotten, or are remembered with contempt. We have said that there were giants in those days; and though this amiable prelate may not stand out in history as one of the foremost, he is certainly one of the great men of what it has become the fashion to call the Augustan age. From early youth to old age his industry was enormous; and such was his forwardness in learning that he became Master of Arts at fourteen, and four years afterwards, at an age when our own preachers are only beginning their college curriculum, he was ordained a minister of the gospel. In after life his unselfish nature frequently showed itself—as when he declined the rich living of Cripplegate because another candidate was in the field. By the service he rendered in promoting the Revolution he earned the gratitude of all right-thinking people, while the History of his own Time is an original source of information, and a most valuable legacy to posterity. A wise and enlightened politician, a good Christian, a lover of all who honoured Christ, he would have been the first to discountenance the follies which have since found favour in the cathedral and diocese of Salisbury.

When George I. ascended the throne Dr. Calamy was one of the foremost men amongst Dissenters, and while he was a competent scholar, a solid divine, and of good family, the quality of his silken gown and the whiteness of his bands showed him to be a pastor of the approved standard of politeness, a gentleman who exemplified in his person the first article in the Claytonian confession of a century later. Yet Calamy was throughout a consistent, straightforward Nonconformist, and would have gone to martyrdom before he would have imitated the genteel weaknesses of the Claytons, the father of whom especially, by abusing men more patriotic and enlightened than himself, showed that he was false to the leading political principles of the party he professed to serve. Calamy had lived in times of persecution; and he could remember how his own father had been dogged by Government agents. Many things in his life, which are not alluded to by Dr. Stoughton, afford a suggestive insight into the life of Nonconformists both in town and country. For a time Calamy lived in Hoxton Square, and although he preached in one of the leading pulpits of the metropolis his stipend was only ten pounds a quarter. He was a man of diversified talent, who could hold his own, and appear to advantage in difficult situations, and in more than one audience with George I. he won the esteem of that monarch. He also received fifty pounds in acknowledgment of literary services, and became a chief instrument in originating the Regium Donum.

As we look back upon it through the vista of years, there is a charm associated with life in the eighteenth century, although few might be inclined to exchange its quietness and leisure for the present faster times. Being less than a quarter of its present size, London did not so

completely overrun the earth as to make it impossible to reach the country otherwise than by a lengthy ride. A walk to Kingsland on the north brought the pedestrian to country air, fields, and gardens; Stoke Newington and Hackney were rural retreats, and well-to-do merchants had their suburban villas at Bethnal Green. On the south the green lanes and rich meadows came wonderfully near to the great water highway of the Thames, so that students who, like Dr. Gill, resided in Gracechurch-street, were still able to walk out into the pure air of the country. The era, undoubtedly, had its peculiar advantages; and when we unduly magnify these, or lose sight of its drawbacks, we are tempted to expatiate on the glories of "the good old times." The drawbacks, however, were very many, and were such as would be an intolerable burden could they be suddenly reimposed upon our shoulders. The common people are represented by a contemporary witness as being lewd and drunken; and we know that ignorance stimulated evil passions until the mob became the ready agent of Jacobite conspirators. "Live and let live" then found no place in the furious code of the Tories; the Whigs were engaged in a bitter warfare with political fanatics, who would have hanged or imprisoned them had it been in their power. Nonconformists expended little on their meeting-houses, for any sudden riot might level them with the ground.

The era of Anne and George I. was one of controversy. Dr. Stoughton says that, "Owing to the writings of Whiston, Clarke, Waterland, and others, the doctrine of the Trinity was a topic especially attractive. Clergymen read what was published by their betters, and enlisted themselves under the flags of different regiments, using, with more or less skill, weapons provided by their leaders. Some were orthodox, some were heretical. They also talked on the subject at clerical meetings and in the houses of parishioners, and failed not to discuss, with much or little learning, with much or little ability, the books on divinity poured out from the press."

The leading ministers in London who would have chiefly attracted the attention of a stranger during the reigns of Anne and George I. were comparatively numerous. At Devonshire-square Mark Key, the pastor, was a popular preacher; and as the member of another church, which hired the chapel for a couple of hours on each Sabbath, the Lady Dowager Page, a rich and charitable lady of that age, was there a worshipper. Dr. Gill, as a young man, commenced work in Southwark in 1719, and in the course of fifty years published sufficient literary matter to fill ten thousand folio pages. Perhaps, however, the most considerable man among the Baptists was Joseph Stennett, the Sabbatarian, who observed the seventh day of the week as a Sabbath, and also preached on the first for the edification of those who differed from him. The Presbyterians and the Independents had between them over seventy pastors in the metropolis, and many of these were men of mark and influence. At Hand-alley, Bishopsgate, preached Dr. Williams, whose name is still remembered in connection with the library he founded. The principal stations of the Presbyterians were at the King's Weigh House, Salters' Hall, and the Old Jewry. These were all served by able pastors. The last-named place was associated with Timothy Rogers, whose treatise on "Trouble of Mind" may still be read with profit by

11

afflicted persons; and Simon Browne, whose extraordinary mental vigour allowed of his excelling in the infidel controversy—even though he was the victim of insane ideas. As we now look back upon those days from our Nonconformist standpoint the period is to many the age of Watts and Doddridge. At all events there are no two characters more prominent, and yet in the third decade of the century the poet was preaching for £100 a year in a meeting-house inferior to the majority of our village chapels; and Doddridge was building up the church at Kibworth on about a third of that amount. Until quite recently Dr. Watts's chapel was still standing in Bury-street, St. Mary Axe, but none of his modern biographers appear to have been aware of the fact.

The character of the clergy in the National Establishment was far from what could have been desired; but at the same time remarkable cases of devotion to duty in the cause of Christ were to be seen in out-of-the-way rural parishes. Among these examples was John Bold, whose story is thus related:—

"There was a clergyman named John Bold; he served the curacy of Stony Stanton, near Hinckley, his stipend being but thirty pounds a year, which, added to a salary of ten, received as a schoolmaster during a portion of his life, made him just as rich as Goldsmith's parson. Remote from polished and literary society, which he was calculated both to enjoy and adorn, he never cast any longing, lingering looks behind, but girded up the loins of his mind for diligent service in his narrow sphere. Conscientious in the discharge of his duties on the Lord's-day, and in connection with fasts and festivals, he was exemplary in visiting his parishioners and in holding catechetical meetings, so that an old man said, 'I have often at the ringing of the bell on Saturday afternoon left my plough for half an hour for instruction, and afterwards returned to it again.' Out of his scanty pittance he saved ten pounds a year for charity, and with all his care and thrift he had a great regard to the neatness of his person and the decorum of his dress. He always wore a band and a large decent gown which folded over, and was bound by a sash. He exhibited no variety of apparel to accommodate himself to different companies."

The clergy of the reigns of Anne and George I. usually presented a sad contrast to the above refreshing example. "According to Burnet," says Dr. Stoughton, "their lives generally were not immoral; but they were not exemplary, not religious, in any deep meaning of that word, not zealous in their divine Master's service, not seeking to save souls and glorify God." Of the reign of George II., Dr. Stoughton remarks: "In country villages, where no exemplary ministers were found, where the rector or curate lived a free and easy life, and liked to drink a dish of tea with the landlady, and afterwards a bowl of punch with the landlord of the inn, not much attention would be paid either to spiritual necessities or to the decencies of religious service. Buildings were neglected; chancel and nave fell into decay; the communion table presented a shabby appearance; surplices were dirty; and, from beginning to end, everything presented a slovenly aspect."

A better time was at hand; for the reign of George II. saw the rise of Methodism, and the wide-spread revival of religion in connection with the preaching of Whitefield and Wesley; but we have no space to

follow Dr. Stoughton to the end of the century. One figure, however, may attract a passing glance—that of John Clayton at the Weighhouse, where he preached to "an old-fashioned congregation in the first half of the reign of George III." The historian speaks of Mr. Clayton's ministry being "a beautiful memory," but probably his conception of beauty will not be shared by all his readers, certainly not by all who read The Sword and the Trowel. In point of fact the elder Clayton was an anomaly, peculiar to his age, and as such he would not now be tolerated in the ranks of Nonconformity. His regularity was such that he reduced life to the routine of clockwork; and his favourite symbol of authority in the family was a substantial cart-whip over his study door. His crotchets in private life were outdone by the audacity with which he circulated political opinions worthy only of Tory parsons in secluded spheres, and the endeavours he put forth to make it appear that he spoke as the mouthpiece of Dissenters. It is at this distance of time impossible to estimate the indignation that was aroused by the publication of his sermon on the Birmingham riots, during which Dr. Priestley's residence and meeting-house were destroyed. The preacher showed that he harboured no sympathy for the common principles and traditions of Nonconformity; and while it mattered little to the world what the individual opinions of such a man might be, people of liberal opinions were indignant at finding such unmanly sentiments fathered upon themselves. "Every party will have its apostates of this kind," said Robert Hall, writing of the man and his discourse; "it is our consolation, however, that their numbers are comparatively small, that they are generally considered as our reproach, and that their conduct is in a great measure the effect of necessity, as they consist almost entirely of persons who can only make themselves heard by confusion and discord."

While we may thus differ from some of his minor conclusions, we very heartily welcome Dr. Stoughton's volumes as a valuable addition to our historical literature. The eighteenth century, like the year with winter at both ends, began and ended in storms; but the story of its religious characteristics, changes, and progress, with glimpses of its quiet life and social usages, should be known to every one who aspires to rank among the well informed. The book would have been better had the author not attempted to be so coldly impartial as sometimes to be a partisan without seeming to be conscious of it; but, notwithstanding minor defects, the book is the best out of many good ones which our author has written, and it ranks with standard histories. May it be long ere a pen so nimble, so accurate, so elegant shall drop from the hand which has wielded it so judiciously.

Everything we make is available for free because of a generous community of supporters.

Donate