Menu
‹ Chapter 67 of 255 ›

The Humiliation of Christ in its Physical, Ethical, and Official Aspects — By Alex. B. Bruce, D.D

12 min read · Chapter 67 of 255

IN this substantial volume we have a sterling contribution to sacred classics. It forms the sixth series of the Cunningham Lectures; an institution designed to advance the theological literature of Scotland in connection with the Free Church. The worthy author has acquitted himself of a delicate and arduous task with much discretion and ability. Deep learning, wide research, and sound catholicity, qualify him to perform the part of a guide for those good people who seek recreation in romantic literary excursions to the summit of mountains that terrify ordinary travellers, or through districts not marked upon common maps. The title of this book suggests a theme, beyond all others to our taste; yet in perusing the treatise, we seem to be traversing a road where the trail of the serpent is to be traced at every step.

In the dignity of the person of Christ we take infinite delight; and in the depth of his humiliation we find matter for devout gratitude. With the sweetness of his character as a sojourner on our earth we are always charmed. His sufferings awaken our tender sympathy. We hail him as the Saviour of our ruined race, and we greet the redemption he wrought with a faith that feasts on the sacrifice he offered of himself. For contemplations of Christ we have the keenest relish; but from controversies about Christ we recoil with the utmost aversion. There are fields of enquiry into which we should never venture were we not venturesome enough to follow a foe. We had thought that there was no limit to the interest we felt in thinking of Christ, and conversing about him; but we must confess that we should shrink from joining with Ebrard, Martensen, Liebner, Keim, and other German professors in a discussion as to whether he had any particular temperament. Be the question propounded on a physical or ethical basis, we should equally demur to it. But even amongst intricacies like this Dr. Bruce does not lose his way.

What think ye of the Christ? Who do men say that the Son of man is? These have been moot questions ever since his advent. Two heresies of an opposite character, the seeds of which were sown in the apostolic age, witnessed a remarkable development in the age that immediately succeeded it. Of Judaism and Gnosticism, our readers have, we presume, a general idea: and those who have tracked the course of church history in the controversies of the schoolmen, would be aware that Ebionites, the extreme on one side, saw little that was divine in the person of our Lord Jesus Christ, being content to recognise him as another Prophet, greater than Moses; while, at the other extreme, Docetists ignored his human existence, holding that his appearance in the flesh was merely an illusion; or, at least, in their writings the realism of his biographical history became more or less overshadowed by the idealism of their sentimental speculation. For five centuries from the opening of the Christian era, the great anxiety and care of the

• Edinburgh: T. and T. Clarke.

189

church was to preserve this one article of faith in the Only-begotten Son of the Father pure from sceptical corruption and sinister construction. For our own part, in the teeth of modern prejudice, and since it has become a fashion dogmatically to denounce all dogmas, we are rather prone to look back with respect, and even with veneration, to the creeds and confessions which were framed to preserve orthodoxy. They are but the masonry of men, we may be told. Not exactly so, we should reply. They are fortifications built into the Rock, and form a promontory which looks defiantly on all assailants. A brief extract from the fifth book of Hooker's Ecclesiastical Polity will perhaps help to put this matter in a clear light: "There are but four things which concur to make complete the whole state of our Lord Jesus Christ: his Deity, his manhood, the conjunction of both, and the distinction of the one from the other being joined in one. Four principal heresies there are, which have in those things withstood the truth; Arians, by bending themselves against the Deity of Christ; Apollinarians by maiming and misinterpreting that which belongeth to his human nature; Nestorians by rending Christ asunder, and dividing him into two persons; the followers of Eutyches, by confounding in his person those natures which they should distinguish. Against these there have been four most famous General Councils: the Council of Nice, to define against Arians; against Apollinarians, the Council of Constantinople; the Council of Ephesus against Nestorians; against Eutychians, the Chalcedon Council. In four words—atéthōs, tēlēōs, adairētōs, asugnchūtōs—truly, perfectly, indivisibly, distinctly; the first applied to his being God; and the second to his being man; and the third to his being of both one; and the fourth to his still continuing in that one both; we may fully, by way of abridgment, comprise whatsoever antiquity hath at large handled, either in declaration of Christian belief, or in refutation of the aforesaid heresies. . . . We conclude therefore that to save the world it was of necessity the Son of God should be thus incarnate, and that God should be so in Christ, as has been declared." This quotation is but the fragment of a paragraph (No. 54). The entire treatise may be studied with advantage. Hooker having flourished three centuries ago, carries us back to a period when the Anglican church had not as yet put forth by the mouth of her prelates or presbyters any monstrous pretensions to catholic authority or apostolic succession. The "Lambeth Articles" had been framed by Archbishop Whitgift and others, asserting the Calvinistic quality of her Protestantism; but Archbishop Laud had not inaugurated the reactionary movement which encroached upon liberty of conscience by enforcing a Popish liturgy with wilful espionage and wanton tyranny.

Although Dr. Bruce, in his second lecture, takes an interesting retrospect of the Patristic Theology, yet, so far as the general design of his work is concerned, he starts his survey from a point and a period when the dogmas were all determined. Digging down to the division between the Reformed Protestant churches, he inspects the strata, and minutely examines the volcanic rocks where the fires once furiously raged, and then he works his way gradually upwards to modern theories that have never crystallized, and it is not likely that they ever will. It is all quicksand, and no quartz, by the time we reach McLeod Campbell

and Horace Bushnell, who reduce momentous questions to petty quibbles.

"In the sixteenth century, memorable on so many other accounts in the annals of the Church, Christology passed into a new phase. Only a few years after the commencement of the Reformation, there arose a dispute on the subject of Christ's person, producing in its course a separation of the German Protestants into rival communions, distinguished by the names of Lutheran and Reformed, and even giving rise to bitter internal contentions between the members of that section of the German Church which claimed Luther for its founder and father. The long, obstinate, and, in its results, unhappy controversy originated in what to us may appear a very small matter—a difference of opinion between Luther and Zwingli as to the nature of Christ's presence in the sacrament of the Supper. Zwingli maintained that the Redeemer was present spiritually only, and solely for those who believe,—the bread and wine being simply emblems of his broken body and shed blood, aids to faith, and stimulants to grateful remembrance. Luther vehemently asserted that the body of the Saviour was present in the Supper, in, with, and under the bread, and was eaten both by believers and unbelievers; by the former to their benefit, by the latter to their hurt. It is easy to see what questions must arise out of such a diversity of view. If Christ's body be present in the Supper, then it must be ubiquitous; but is this attribute compatible with the nature of body, with the ascension of the risen Lord into heaven, with the promise of his second coming; and how did the body of Christ come by this marvellous attribute? &c."

Page 82. The area of these polemics widened as they progressed. From the ubiquity of our Lord's body, the debate advanced into a discussion of his complex person, and still further into a third stage—the theory of his earthly humiliation. "The final result of the whole controversy on the Lutheran side was the formation of a doctrine concerning the person of Christ artificial, unnatural, and incredible." Dr. Bruce, in his first lecture, deals very discreetly with axioms, chiefly drawn from two passages of Scripture which are forcible enough of themselves, but which have become rather more famous in debate. A modern author has observed that "We do not commonly enter or dwell very long on minute criticisms of a text until some subtle heresy has been proposed to us, and, perhaps, already prepossessed our thoughts; and such criticisms are doubly perilous, both as drawing us away from the true means of assurance, without which the questions must remain open for ever, and as leaving us at the mercy of the subtlest, not always or necessarily the most enlightened, disputant."

R. H. C. Sandys. Just so. Well may Dr. Bruce complain as he does:—

"It is specially discouraging to the inquirer after first principles to find that as a rule the interpretation of the passage in question depends on the interpreter's theological position. So much is this the case that one can almost tell beforehand what views a particular expositor will take, provided his theological school be once ascertained." In treating of Philippians ii. 5-9, and Hebrews ii. 5-18, his exegetical criticism is alike searching and satisfactory. Both passages bring before us the subject of Christ's humiliation, but from a different point of view. In the one Paul exhibits that humiliation as something voluntarily endured by

191

Christ in a spirit of condescension and self-renunciation which he exhorts his readers to admire and imitate. In the other he regards the same humiliation as an experience to which Christ was subjected, and which, as apparently incongruous to his intrinsic dignity, demands explanation. The grand thought here is that Christ to be a Saviour must be a brother, and that, as things actually stand, he must be humbled, must pass through a curriculum of temptation and suffering as a man, in order that he may be in all things like unto his brethren. This is a condensed quotation of our author's own words. We beg his pardon, but we lack space to do him full justice.

For the parentage of modern thought, or at least of modern religious thought, we turn to Fatherland. German genius has been generating theological problems for the past half century. We have not for our part been scared by the scepticism in which on the outset it seemed to be clouded. No fear ever crossed our simple hearts that neology could supplant Christology, or that inspiration would be imperilled by investigation. The Pyrrhonists may have led the van, but they have pioneered the way of progress. Our great antipathy is to indifference. When a storm is raging men are obliged to keep their eyes open, and their wits ready for an emergency; but in a long, dead calm everybody gets demoralized. We note with satisfaction that such controversies have been entered into to promote concord. Authors, whose great aim has been to defend the faith, attempt one after another to define the truth in such terms as shall reconcile those who heretofore had professed rival creeds. "It is a feature common to modern Christologists of all schools, to insist with peculiar emphasis on the reality of our Lord's humanity. . . . Every theory must be recognised a failure which does not faithfully reflect the historical image of Jesus as depicted in the gospels, and allow him to be as he appears there, a veritable, though not a mere man." This is of course only a reiteration of the dictum that was delivered to us from the beginning, 1 John iv. 2, 3. The Greek word Kēnosis has been almost universally adopted as the motto of the litigants. Its meaning may be readily measured by anyone who takes the pains to compare the authorised and revised versions of the New Testament in Philippians ii. 7. In the one the Pre-existent Saviour is spoken of as having made himself of no reputation, in the other as having emptied himself. The latter is the more faithful translation. Two states are spoken of, and his condescension in each is recorded. "Being in the form of God. . . . he emptied himself, (then) taking the form of a bondservant, being found in fashion as a man, he humbled himself and became obedient even unto death, yea, the death of the cross."

Dr. Bruce has classified and reviewed the leading types, and diverse shapes, which the abstruse problems that have been raised on this passage have assumed in the divinity works of the last forty years. Count Zinzindorf, founder of the Moravian brotherhood, broached the exposition which awoke the lively interest of recent times. The grain of thought cast by him into the ground lay dormant for a hundred years; then in the fourth decade of the present century it began to germinate, and ever since it has gone on multiplying abundantly. We will, however, quote the doctor's admirable summing up. "The hypotheses are legitimate enough as tentative solutions of a har

problem; and those who require their aid may use any one of them as a prop around which faith may twine. But it is not necessary to adopt any one of them; we are not obliged to choose between them; we may stand aloof from them all; and it may be best when faith can afford to dispense with their services. For it is not good that the certainties of faith should lean too heavily upon uncertain and questionable theories. Wisdom dictates that we should clearly and broadly distinguish between the great truths revealed to us in Scripture, and the hypotheses which deep thinkers have invented for the purpose of bringing these truths more fully within the grasp of their understandings." Yes, yes; this is very true. But did not old Martin Luther put the matter into more forceful language long, long ago? That little word "How!" It is a hateful, damnable monosyllable. How did God do this or that? If a man come to the boldness of proposing such a question to himself he will not give over till he find some answer. Then others will not be content with his answer, but every man will have a different one. When the church fell upon Quomodo in the sacrament, How, in what manner, the body of Christ was there, "We see," (says old Dr. John Donne,) "what an inconvenient answer it fell upon, that it was done by transubstantiation. That satisfied not, as there was no reason it should, and then they fell upon others, in, sub, and cum, and none could and none can give satisfaction."

Our author draws nearer to our own doors when he proceeds to speak of "Christ the subject of temptation and moral development." We admire his patience, though we cannot emulate it, when he examines the writings of poor Edward Irving, convicts him of bad temper for contemptuously nicknaming the current doctrine of atonement "the bargain and barter hypothesis," and advocating in lieu of it a REDEMPTION BY SAMPLE, as though Christ took a portion of sinful humanity and made it holy, and through it sanctified the whole lamp. Nor is he less severe upon this erratic Scottish preacher for his rhetorical inexactitude, a confused habit of thinking, and a loose mode of using the same word in two distinct senses, which constantly involve him in self-contradictions. In the last chapter, however, the humiliation of Christ is surveyed in its official aspects, as a servant and an apostle; as a priest and a victim. As might be expected, the worthy doctor has raked together a great heap of rubbish, but then he has sifted and sorted it very carefully and very skilfully before he makes a grand bonfire of the ephemeral essays of self-opinionated professors. His own studied moderation gives special point to the censure or commendation he awards to other authors. Horace Bushnell, whom he designates an ingenious writer, comes in for a quiet lecturing, which men of his type who survive him may well lay to heart. In his treatise, "The Vicarious Sacrifice," he had expressed views which in a subsequent treatise, entitled, "Forgiveness and Law," he revoked and replaced with certain new views, which had come into his mind, he tells us, almost like a revelation, and propounded them as an unquestionable solution of the problem. His overweening confidence is the gravest fault of his book. It would not become every disciple to bring reproach against a brother because he was slow to understand the full meaning of Christ's death; but one who claims to have got new light by the very claim confesses previous partial

193

error, and ought to avoid the oracular style, and to speak with modesty. If the Catholic doctrine be true, Bushnell had still a good deal to learn. Of many American divines Dr. Bruce makes honourable mention: "but foremost of all, the great Transatlantic theologian of last century, President Edwards, whose statement on the question, in what sense Christ suffered the wrath of God, deserves and will repay the most attentive study of all who desire to think justly on the delicate theme."

In commending this valuable contribution to our theological literature to all students we take occasion to protest with all the emphasis in our power against the treatment that profound subjects meet with in paltry pamphlets with which the press constantly teems, and which are rather apt to excite uneasy doubt than to instruct the ignorant or confirm the wavering.

Everything we make is available for free because of a generous community of supporters.

Donate