Menu
‹ Chapter 196 of 279 ›

An important Letter

4 min read · Chapter 196 of 279

To the Editor of "The Sword and the Trowel."

DEAR SIR,—I believe there are few of your congregational readers who will not thank you for your insertion in "Notes" in the June number, of the letter from "A Congregational Minister." I trust that the "Pastors' College" is not the only one in London which is "intended to teach faithfully the foundation truths of the Gospel of God." But there are more than he, he may be well assured, who have felt burdened by the occurrence to which he alludes (and it does not stand alone), and who are well pleased to see public expression given to his and their anxieties.

His letter instantly recalled the utterance of one whose name is still pronounced with lively gratitude in all the churches. By it, "he being dead yet speaketh," and, in view of present facts, in tones how solemn! Writing more than five-and-twenty years ago, the late John Angell James made the following observations:—

"For years past there has been gradually forming among reading, thoughtful, and devout men, both in the ministry and out of it, an undergrowth of conviction, impatient of, if not hostile to, many of those metaphysical forms in which the teachings of Christianity have been distorted and stereotyped by the dogmatism of theological schools." He then went on to say—"I am afraid the meaning of this is but too obvious, and that, if followed out, it will lead to a new theology, not only in form but in substance. I am happy, however, in the conviction, that the theological teaching of our colleges is the inculcation of a sound orthodoxy, and that, in the main, the doctrines held by our ancestors, the Puritans and the Nonconformists, are the divinity of our seats of learning. I believe the great body of our ministers still hold fast these

453

momentous truths. But I will not conceal my apprehensions, and they are painful ones, that a few of our young ministers, in their anxiety to avoid a stereotyped phraseology, which, if the change be confined to this, would not be mischievous, are in some danger of giving up truths which were stereotyped nearly eighteen centuries ago upon the page of revelation, and were intended by the Author of inspiration to be stereotyped there for all ages and all generations. It is an age of liberalism and independent thinking, and this is finding its way into our ministry to such an extent, that, in the anxiety to get out of the old and deep ruts, some add the danger of getting off the rails. It is one melancholy symptom of the age, that orthodoxy, if by one party it has become almost a cant term, is by the other pronounced with a sneer, or made the subject of ridicule and satire. In some cases where a sound theology is retained, it appears to me to be held with too slight an idea of its vast importance as the means of all spiritual life. It is maintained as a creed, or a kind of religious science, which cannot be logically disproved; but it is kept sadly in the background, as if we could carry on religion without it, and treated as a thing by itself, which has no vital connection with Christian experience. We hear a great deal indeed about 'spiritual life,' but it is a life apart from spiritual truth—a kind of religious, poetic sentimentalism, or of merely a zealous activity—a life and an activity that may be carried on upon almost any system of doctrine. A negative theology—I scarcely like to use a phrase so bandied about, yet it is a very expressive one, and I can find no substitute for it—is almost sure, if it be long maintained, to end in positive heresy. If the ground be not occupied by the plants of truth, the weeds of error will be sure to spring up. And I confess that, without being panic-stricken at all, I see many things, which way soever I look, that make me serious and sad. There is in some quarters, if not among us, yet in other places, a mischievous operation going on, of chipping, and filing, and edging away Christian truths, until they square themselves into their places in modern philosophies. But all these attempts 'to render Pauline notions' into the graceful equivalents of 'modern thought,' give us a philosophy which philosophers may well scoff at, and a theology which biblical theologians ought to denounce as little better than 'covert Atheism.' The whole evangelical church is coming into a crisis, and all the great critics of religious belief, which we thought had been settled, are going to be tried over again.

"May God carry us and all others safely through the crisis! I bear in recollection that our body a century and a half ago had one great lapse from truth. Most of the Unitarian congregations which now exist sprung out of those that were once Trinitarian. And it can neither be denied nor concealed that some of the periodicals sustained by that body are already rejoicing in hope of another defection. May their hopes never be realized; and in order that they may not, may a spirit of enlightened and holy zeal for truth be poured out upon our ministers, and especially the younger portion of them; and may a spirit of earnestness and importunate supplication pervade our churches for the preservation of sound doctrine among us!"

I make no comment; but would only suggest the inquiry, were that lamented servant of God to appear among us now, after the lapse of a quarter of a century, would he alter what he then wrote? And if so, in what direction?

Yours, in defence of "the faith once for all delivered to the saints,"

June 12th, 1883.

A CONGREGATIONAL DEACON.

Everything we make is available for free because of a generous community of supporters.

Donate