Fletcher of Madeley
PROVIDED we have read and digested all that has been published on the subject during the last ten years, we probably know about all concerning the Methodist Revival of the eighteenth century that the historians can tell us. As a concisely complete account of the whole movement, the brilliant narrative of Dr. Abel Stevens is not likely soon to be superseded; but such is the lasting interest of the subject, that, on the one hand, there appears to be a demand for briefer histories; and, on the other, for elaborate and exhaustive biographies of the more distinguished actors in the Methodist Revival. At this moment, our eye lights on eight substantial octavo volumes, all from the industrious pen of Mr. Tyerman, the publication price of which is £4 10s., and which extend to over 4,500 pages. In contrast to this voluminous method of treating the subject we have the more compact volume of Mr. Daniels, which will be welcomed by those who want a Methodist history of moderate length, which at the same time is tolerably complete. If Mr. Daniels has erred at all, it is in making his book too exclusively Wesleyan, not only by apparently writing for one denomination alone, but by needlessly inserting remarks which are likely to give offence to all others. It ought to be generally recognised that "the people called Methodists" originally included all those who believed in the doctrines of grace, and whose rule of life was the New Testament. Such a critical oracle as Sydney Smith, for example, would have discovered no material difference between Dr. Carey and Billy Bray, who would have been to him equally eccentric Methodists.
The literature of Methodism, taken in its broadest sense, is certainly one of the most curious phenomena connected with English letters; and a racy book on the subject might be written such as would meet with wide acceptance. In the preface to his three volumes, Dr. Stevens mentions that a catalogue of three hundred and eighty-four publications hostile to Methodism, and published between 1729 and 1846, was printed at Philadelphia. "If we add to these the works in favour of Methodism, and others bearing directly or indirectly on its history, the list can hardly be short of fifteen hundred." What curiosities these may contain can alone be known to patient historians who are not content to use second-hand materials.
In his preface, Mr. Tyerman quotes some classic opinions on Fletcher which devout readers of this generation will doubtless fully endorse. Southey says that "no church has ever possessed a more apostolic minister;" Dr. Dixon conceives the vicar to be "the most holy man who has been upon earth since the apostolic age;" and Robert Hall declares him to be "a seraph who burns with the ardour of divine love." Several lives of this worthy have been published since his death, but the only complete one is the ample volume by Mr. Tyerman, from
* I. Wesley's Designated Successor: The Life, Letters, and Literary Labours of the Rev. John Fletcher, Vicar of Madeley, Shropshire. By the Rev. L. Tyerman. Hodder and Stoughton. Price 12s.
II. A Short History of "The People called Methodists." From the Days of the Wesleys to the Methodist (Ecumenical Conference held at City Road Chapel, London, in September, 1881. By Rev. W. H. Daniels, A.M. Revised, with preface, by the Rev. Thornley Smith. Hodder and Stoughton. Price 6s.
which probably no facts of importance relating to the champion of Arminian Methodism are omitted.
Jean Guillaume De la Flechère appears to have come of a good French family, his father having been an officer in the army, who subsequently retired to Switzerland. Speaking of his ancestral home, Fletcher says, that the view from the windows is one of the finest prospects in the world; and when it is remembered that the view included Lake Leman, Geneva fifteen miles off, Mont Blanc, and other Alpine peaks, the assertion will not appear inconsistent with fact. What was better, however, the home was one in which God was honoured. "I think it was when I was seven years of age," remarks Fletcher himself, "that I first began to feel the love of God shed abroad in my heart, and that I resolved to give myself up to him and the service of his church, if ever I should be fit for it." At an early age he was a hard student, for, besides some proficiency in mathematics, he acquired the Hebrew, English, and German languages. It was at first intended that he should take holy orders; but he relinquished this notion in favour of the military profession, to find his path hedged up in that direction. Just after coming of age he came to England, in 1752, to perfect his knowledge of our language.
It will thus be seen that the young adventurer visited England just when the Revival was rising to its height; and having been always accounted as a youth very religiously inclined he would naturally be attracted by the preachers. As he listened, he found to his surprise, and probably to his mortification, that something was wrong, and accordingly, like so many have done before him, he began "to strive with the utmost diligence according to his light, hoping by much doing to render himself acceptable to God." He then, one day, on hearing a discourse from a Mr. Green, made the further discovery that he was even more ignorant concerning the nature of saving faith than he had suspected. "Is it possible," he exclaimed, "that I who have made divinity my study, and received the premium of piety, so called, from the university for my writings on divine subjects—is it possible that I am yet so ignorant as not to know what faith is?" He accepted Wesley's advice, as given in his journal, to go to Christ with all his sins and hardness of heart, and he soon found life and peace. In March, 1757, he was ordained in accordance with the usage of the Established Church, and immediately afterwards he commenced his ministerial work at a Methodist meeting-house in Snowsfields, Bermondsey.
At this time he was tutor to the sons of Mr. Hill, a Member of Parliament, who during each session resided in town, and at other times at Fern Hall, Shropshire. He embraced all the opportunities of preaching that occurred; but when his pupils came to such an age as no longer to need his services, he began to look for other employment. As was usual with gentlemen of his class, Mr. Hill was disposed to act handsomely, and actually procured for him the living of Dunham in Cheshire, which was worth £400 per annum. The offer was a very generous one, for as Mr. Hill remarked, "The parish is small, the duty light, the income good, and it is situated in a fine, healthy, sporting country." The idea of a "sporting country" offering any charms to a man like Fletcher was in itself sufficiently grotesque; but passing that
497
by, he at once cried, "Alas! sir, Dunham will not suit me; there is too much money and too little labour." "Few clergymen make such objections," added the patron. "It is a pity to decline such a living, especially as I know not that I can find you another. What shall we do? Would you like Madeley?" The prospect of Madeley, which would have repelled the majority of men, allured this man in a way that proved the sincerity of his motives. It was a rough, semi-civilized, mining district that needed the gospel more than anything else; and thinking only of his Master's glory, thither the young pastor decided to go. The preliminaries were soon arranged; for as Mr. Hill's nephew was patron of Madeley, an agreement to instal Fletcher in the latter parish was made during a meeting at Shrewsbury races.
The state of this parish when the young pastor first entered upon his life-work was bad in the extreme, but its condition was fairly representative of other mining or manufacturing districts in that day. Always afraid to run, as he expressed it, before he saw an open door, the vicar was at first "greatly mortified and discouraged" by the scant congregations; but notwithstanding that he was denounced on all hands as "a Methodist and a Baptist" the week-day congregations soon exceeded in numbers the Sabbath assemblies of his predecessors. The church filled, branch-meetings were set up in the hamlets of the parish, and in spite of fierce opposition, the work advanced. He touched the sore places in the people's minds when he spoke against drunkenness, bull-baiting, and shows; and when he endeavoured to put down the infamies of Madeley wake. "The publicans and maltmen will not forgive me," he wrote. "They think that to preach against drunkenness, and to cut their purse, is the same thing." And yet the preacher never either spoke or wrote as a teetotaler. His notion of temperance never advanced to total abstinence.
The opposition encountered from the baser sort among the people was not more virulent, however, than that which was offered by the clergy, the magistrates, and the genteel residents of the neighbourhood. There was one clergyman more particularly, who while accusing Fletcher of being a rebel, a schismatic, a disturber of the peace, and a Jesuit, headed the roughs in mobbing the man of God. One magistrate, whose sympathies ran in the same direction, raved against Methodism as though the blood of Jeffreys was in his veins; and this worthy even threatened to put the Conventicle Act in force against the gospeller until he found that that statute was not so accommodating as he had fondly imagined.
What kind of work it was which these people opposed may be learned from the words of Mr. Gilpin, who was well acquainted both with the Vicar of Madeley and the sphere of his labour:—"It was a common thing, in his parish, for young persons of both sexes to meet together for what was called recreation; and that recreation usually continued from evening to morning, consisting chiefly in dancing, revelling, drunkenness, and obscenity. These licentious assemblies Mr. Fletcher considered a disgrace to the Christian name, and determined to exert his ministerial authority for their total suppression. Frequently he burst in upon them with a holy indignation, making war upon Satan in places peculiarly appropriated to his service. His enemies twisted
his words, misrepresented his actions, and cast out his name as evil; but whether he was insulted in his person, or injured in his property; whether he was attacked with open abuse, or pursued by secret calumny; he walked amid the most violent assaults of his enemies as a man invulnerable; and while his firmness discovered that he was unhurt, his forbearance testified that he was unoffended."
The godly vicar was acquainted with Miss Bosanquet—who afterwards became his wife—for twenty years prior to his marriage; but though frequently advised to the contrary, he supposed himself to be necessarily destined to a lot of single blessedness. He even wrote out in parallel columns a set of reasons for and against marriage, and of course in the case of a man whose mind was already made up, the Noes were in the majority. "It is true that the Scripture says that a good wife is the gift of the Lord," he remarked; "and it is also true that there may be one in a thousand; but who would put in a lottery where are nine hundred and ninety-nine blanks to one prize? And suppose I could find this Phoenix, this woman of a thousand, what should I gain by it? A distressing refusal. How could she choose such a man as I? If, notwithstanding all my self-love, I am compelled cordially to despise myself, could I be so wanting in generosity as to expect another to do that for me which I cannot do for myself—to engage to love, to esteem, and to honour me?"
His estimate of the worth of women was manifestly too low; and it is quite possible that many maidens might have been repelled by his eccentric mode of life. Writing in November, 1765, to an expected visitor, Fletcher remarked: "I live here in a little market-town, three or four miles from the foot of the Wrekin, at the south-east of that hill. I live alone in my house, having neither wife, child, nor servant. I can, therefore, without inconveniency, spare you a room in the meantime. If you choose to provide your food, you shall have conveniences for it; if you choose to table with a neighbour, as I do, you may." Though he "tabled" out, however, he breakfasted at home in true primitive style. A lady who had been at a boarding-school at Madeley used to tell of an early morning visit once paid by the vicar to the establishment. Having spoken to each child, the vicar addressed the whole body: "I have waited some time on you this morning, that I might see you eat your breakfast; and I hope you will visit me to-morrow morning, and see how I eat mine." At seven a.m. next morning, the girls were in the vicarage kitchen, and noticed that the only preparations for breakfast were represented by a basin of milk and pieces of bread. When Mr. Fletcher arrived, he seated himself on a bench and said: "My dear girls, yesterday morning I waited on you a full hour while you were at breakfast. I shall take as much time this morning in eating my breakfast as I usually do, if not rather more. Look at my watch." Having despatched the meal the vicar enquired as to the time occupied. "Just a minute and a half, sir," shouted the school; and then remarking that fifty-eight minutes of the hour were left, the pastor gave out a hymn, and spoke of the brevity of life and the value of time.
This example is hardly worthy of commendation; for they who are diligent in business are at least entitled to enjoy their meals in a
499
reasonable way. It is surely false economy for the earnest workman not to take proper care of his own body, which is none too strong at the best. The vicar's mode of life some years later is well portrayed by John Wesley: "He was more and more abundant in his ministerial labours, both in public and private; not contenting himself with preaching, but visiting his flock in every corner of his parish. And this work he attended to early and late, whether the weather was fair or foul; regarding neither heat nor cold, rain nor snow, whether he was on horseback or on foot. But this further weakened his constitution; which was still more effectually done by his intense and uninterrupted studies, in which he frequently continued, without scarce any intermission fourteen, fifteen, or sixteen hours a day. But still he did not allow himself such food as was necessary to sustain nature. He seldom took any regular meals, except he had company; otherwise, twice or thrice in four-and-twenty hours he ate some bread-and-cheese or fruit. Instead of this he sometimes took a draught of milk, and then wrote on again. When one reproved him for not affording himself a sufficiency of necessary food, he replied, 'Not allow myself food? Why, our food seldom costs my housekeeper and me less than two shillings a week!' Compulsory absence from his flock, consequent on declining health, was a natural consequence of such a course of life; and was at the same time its severest condemnation."
Fletcher was the literary champion of the Arminian Methodists; but though his writings are still widely circulated by that body, it is quite unnecessary for us to touch upon the controversy. We are neither convinced by his arguments, nor charmed by his spirit, and could heartily wish that the controversy had never arisen. Mr. Tyerman has given an account of each publication, and of the various interesting incidents connected with the dispute, which at one time awakened a good deal of unnecessary angry feeling. It is due to Fletcher to say, that so far as keeping his temper was concerned, he showed himself to be a model controversialist; but we should not think that his opponents thought so.
For nearly five years—the last, and probably the happiest of his not very long life—Fletcher's lot was cheered by the presence of the Phoenix, the one of a thousand, about whom he had written or dreamed, without ever expecting to win the prize for himself. For long before she became the wife of the Vicar of Madeley, Mary Bosanquet had become a convert of the Revival, and she had shown that she could renounce all the alluring prospects of the world for the kingdom of heaven's sake. Never were man and wife more congenially matched. By dividing the work at Madeley between them, they must have doubled its efficiency. Though Fletcher was Wesley's designated successor, the latter survived his younger friend for six years; but even if the Vicar of Madeley had lived on to old age, it is hardly probable that he would have shown sufficient administrative ability to have allowed of his taking the leader's place. His rather sudden death in 1785, at the age of fifty-five, occasioned widespread grief, only paralleled by the loss of John Wesley himself; but the pastor's works lived after him; and people still visit Madeley for the purpose of seeing a locality where so eminent a saint successfully laboured through the best years of his
devoted life. He will not be disturbed in his repose though a decided Calvinist thus places a wreath upon his tomb. We admire holiness of life most heartily wherever we perceive it, and we feel concerning this consecrated man of God, that his shoe's latchet we are not worthy to unloose.
