"Oh, he is far too personal!" — By Thomas Spurgeon
IT is truly wonderful how soon solemn impressions and subdued feelings wear off, especially if these have been induced by a superstitious reverence for times and places. Not more quickly vanishes the morning mist or the early dew before the sun than does a fancied piety at the door of the place of worship. Conversation with friends, and the jostling of the crowd help to strangle the holy thoughts which had just been born, and the good seed seems likely to be trampled on and destroyed immediately after leaving the sower's basket. Sometimes, thank God, it springs up again; indeed, the very trampling can be used by the great Husbandman as one means towards the glorious end he has in view; but, as far as human judgment can decide, much of the seed is destroyed by the too rough harrowing that it undergoes at the very first.
Then, on the road from church to home, the converse is not always all it should be. Acquaintances are met, family or business matters are discussed, and after a brief remark about the preacher, the more serious matters are quite forgotten, and levity, in some cases, rules the hour. Christian people thus frequently lose the opportunity of experiencing that blessed heartburn which those who talk of Jesus know when Jesus himself joins their party and turns even its sadness into gladness. Alas, how often an unconverted friend, who has, perhaps, been impressed by the sermon, finds the impression more than counteracted by the irrelevant converse of his professed friends.
I do not know a better opportunity for the disciple who is a little timid in speaking to others about their souls than when homeward-bound from a religious service. It surely is not hard to speak a word for Jesus then. The friend cannot deem such converse out of place, nor be offended at it. The sermon is fresh in his memory and in yours. You have a text to hand, and something to start with, and if the service has been a blessing to you, you should be just in the right trim to tell of Christ's love. Try it, dear friend,—try it as soon as you can. Clinch the nail that the preacher has tried to drive. Stamp the wax which he may have been the means of melting. Your success will surprise you. If we only knew what others think of our ordinary and inappropriate conversation, we should, if only for our own sakes, engage in more solemn and profitable converse "en route" for home. But we have higher motives: the urgent need of the unconverted, and the glory of our Saviour, should prompt us to use this most fitting opportunity of spreading the truth.
I would far rather that the audience should speak of sermon and preacher, and criticize them both, however unfavourably, than that they should be placed together on the shelf of forgetfulness. The sermon and its solemn truths ought to occupy the mind and thought of those who have just heard it. Mrs. So-and-so's new bonnet is a usurper if it gets all the attention. Yet how often the crying of a baby, or the fainting of a woman, or the number of the audience, or the singing, takes the place of the rightful theme of conversation. Possibly this is sometimes due to the fact that there was nothing particularly
striking about the sermon to attract attention and deserve comment. Certainly, the pulpit could share the blame with the pew in such a case; but even then, as I said before, it were better to speak of defects and faults than to fly off at a tangent to some altogether unworthy subject. Better man the pumps of the leaking ship, or try to patch her up, than leap overboard into the surging tide. Better make the best of a bad job than go from bad to worse. An investigation of an ill sermon may produce some good; it will at least keep greater evils out. Try to arrange its confusion, correct its errors, bear your witness against its lack of earnestness, and uplift your prayer on his behalf who preached it.
Even when the doctrine of the discourse cannot be called in question, it is not to be wondered at if there are faults in matter and manner. Let these be overhauled rather than any other topic discussed. Although this is by no means the main matter, better this, I say, than worse. Such a calling-over-the-coals proves, at least, that the address was attended to, and perhaps when the critic has done with the scalpel, he also may open his own heart to the truths that were in the discourse despite its blunders.
I am very slow to expect everybody to be delighted with one minister, and slower still to hope to find all enraptured with a single sermon. It is altogether too much to look for: "so many men so many minds." "Spectacles to suit all sights" may be advertised over the opticians' doors, and can be had within provided the stock is sufficiently large and varied; but no one ever yet took the notice to mean that Professor Pebbles had invented a certain eyeglass which would suit the varied foci of a million eyes. Find me a parson who, in this sense, would "suit all sights," and I pronounce him "a spectacle" indeed to men and angels. It stands to reason that the whims and wishes, and fancies and foibles, of a thousand cannot all find satisfaction in one, that one perhaps as full of "character" as any of his hearers. No, "the cloth must expect to have holes picked in it." The pulpit is not surprised if it is sometimes turned into a pillory. The preacher would be fearing a "Woe," if all men spake well of him. It will be an ill day when the audience worships en masse the presiding genius of the rostrum.
Let it not be supposed from this that all the wisdom is with the critics, that they have all turned Solomons, and can bisect the sermon as the wise man would have divided the living child. After all, the pew is not the best judge of the pulpit, and certainly the ungodly are not at all able to call the preacher to account. They do not understand his mission or his message; nay, more, they do not know their own condition. It ill becomes those who sit in the seat of the scornful to sit in judgment on the men of God who preach to them the truth as it is in Jesus. Critiques from such as these have furnished us with mottoes for several previous papers, and another one heads this. A stranger to the vital power of true godliness utters this loud complaint, the language of many more, after a plain, practical sermon from a soul-seeking preacher, "OH, HE'S FAR TOO PERSONAL!"
Those who readily join this growl are more to be pitied than blamed. Poor souls, they little know the danger they are in, or they would not
21
chide the speaker for being pointed and personal! Many of these grumblers look upon the parson as an individual who is paid to do a certain work, as any other professional man may be—i. e., to do it as conveniently to himself as may be, but certainly to no one else's inconvenience. They put out their religion, to be done by him, as they give their washing to the laundry-woman; and are willing enough to pay the account involved, along with the baker's and the butcher's bills. But since they pay for spiritual pabulum just as for their animal food, so they must have it also to their choice and order. They have certain humours and crotchets about groceries and bakeries, and they must needs have likes and dislikes as to the loaves and fishes of the gospel; and why shouldn't their taste be met by the preacher as well as by the butcher and baker and candlestick-maker? They have a right, they think, to do as they like with their own, and since they support the minister, he should be guided by their wishes. He is their minister in a twofold sense, for they are his masters. A young man who read an "original tale" at a Mutual Improvement Society, found his story rather roughly handled, and some found fault with him for certain items in the narrative which they thought he should not have introduced. In his defence, he rather aptly asked the question, "Can't a fellow do what he likes with his own tale?" (Much laughter.) So, many a congregation looks upon the preacher as its own peculiar property—an appendage, in fact, which ought to be wagged and waggled according to the body's will. Thank God, some of us have yet to learn that this is our position. Content, as we trust we are, to be the servants of all for Jesus' sake, yet are we determined to call no man master, for one is our Master, even Christ. We are not yet convinced that it is our business to cater for the fastidious fancies and depraved appetites of these queer customers. The stage may be dependent on the caprice of the people, but not so the pulpit. A lecturer may be beholden to the society which employs him; a candidate for parliamentary honours to the voice of the people; but the pulpit gets (or should obtain) its advices and instructions from a heavenly source, and tells God's truth without fear or favour. Alas, for that day when the preacher's lips move at the dictation of the people's wills, and his words sound in harmony with the world's wishes.
Yet it is so to-day to some extent. Sermons are made to order, and might well be ticketed, "Fashionable!" "Latest novelty!" "Favorite!" and the like. "As you like it," might be sculptured over the stone porch of the church; "Take thine ease," inscribed on the softly-cushioned pew, and "Peace, peace" (without the rest of the sentence) on the pulpit front. Many a pulpit is nothing better than a treacle-pot; a canister of golden syrup would be an appropriate crest for the preacher, his own superfine silken gown will do for his coat-of-arms, and "Live, and let live!" for his motto. God save us from being the twenty-thousandth cousins of any who boast of such a heraldry!
There is no charge more frequent or more bitter against a faithful minister than that of being "far too personal." This is an unpardonable sin in the eyes of those who really stand most in need of such dealing. But they do not like it. A sham fight at a distance is
well enough; but close quarters and real conflict are not in their line. They are not enamoured of war and warlike matters in any shape, unless they be in Zululand or Afghanistan. If a Christian minister (especially theirs) takes up the cudgels and attacks certain practices (especially theirs), "Oh then," say they, "he's apt to do more harm than good, and raise prejudices" (especially theirs!). They may put up with General Skirmish, and even court his company, but Private Sharp-shooter is far too precise for them, and has too much of the rank and file about him. He who draws a bow at a venture is preferable to a "Thou-art-the-man" archer; but they would rather have one who has no bow at all, or at least no arrow. They prefer a bow (courtesy) to a bow, and a flattery to a battery. They would not mind a salute of twenty-one guns, or of twenty thousand for the matter of that; but then, of course, they must not be loaded. The ordinances of the church are well enough, but they will not stand its ordnance. However fond they may be of animals, they do not like battering-rams; and grape-shot is not a favourite fruit. If they had their way, every arrow would moult and become featherless, every gun would shut its mouth and be silent as the grave, every soldier would wear an edgeless sword and as many fineries as possible, and every preacher would content himself with preaching a ten minutes' sermon with nothing particular in it.
It is scarcely matter for surprise that personal dealing is not palatable. Even eels find some difficulty in getting used to skinning, nor do I think they ever come to enjoy it. To have one's inmost self laid bare, its motives examined, its interests exposed, is an operation from which the flesh naturally shrinks. Mr. Haughty does not care to be arraigned and condemned, and Mrs. All-Serene does not appreciate being undeceived and aroused. Who would choose to be turned inside out, if he had a choice in that matter? Who likes to be led to the bar, and adjudged "guilty" by God and conscience? Men have decided objections to such objectionable decisions. They will hear a little smoothly-given counsel, and even remark on the faithfulness of the preacher. A little summer-lightning is as a display of fireworks to them; but give them a forked flash, and they hide their faces even before the thunder follows. A certain amount of medicine it is right to take, they think, and they are prepared to have an occasional dose, provided the pill is sugar-coated or the draught highly flavoured. But, however it may be with physic, certain it is that the word is spoiled if mixed with anything but faith in those that hear it. It is useless to whisper to a deaf man, and a nod is as good (or as bad) as a wink to a blind horse; and an essay on morality is much the same to a soul dead in trespasses and sins.
The incumbent preached on St. Barnabas' Day from the words, "For he was a good man,"—and a very good sermon it was. And such good advice to the good folk, in the good place, from that good man! And such a good collection! Goody two shoes! what a mercy the church was large, or the preacher would have had no room where to bestow all his goods. "Do good deeds, live good lives, think good thoughts, have good desires, and you will earn this glorious epitaph, 'He was a good man.'" Goodness gracious, what soft goods to dispense to unsaved sinners. Thank God, the church was not half full.
23
Now, this is a sample of the sweetstuff that men rejoice in. They leave the church, exclaiming, "It was good for us to be there!" Instead of "wholesome words" they ask sickening sweets, and prefer smooth and flattering vanities to solemn and earnest verities. They would rather be pampered than healed, and cosseted than profited. "Give us sweet sounds," say they, "rather than 'sound speech which cannot be condemned.'" But, oh, what awful consequences may result from such a style of preaching. There is death in such a highly-flavoured pot, and unless the good Spirit supplies the antidote, hundreds of precious souls will be poisoned. There is reason to believe that many of our fellow-creatures reach premature graves through errors in diet, but many more lose eternal life by reason of the unwholesome fare on which they try to feed their souls. If parsons kept cookshops in which the most fastidious tastes were advertised to be met, some of them could not be more precise and particular with their joints, nor more lavish with their sauces and zests and relishes. Oh, what misery to have to read a sermon through on Saturday evening to see if it is proper and pleasing for the morrow! I do not envy the cook who has epicures and gourmands to satisfy; but I'd rather take his difficult post a thousand times than that of the people-pleasing preacher. What if there is too much salt for Mr. So-and-so, or not enough sage or mint for somebody else! Some there are who get out of the difficulty by putting no spice in the soup, no sauce in the gravy, and no flavouring in the pudding; but instead thereof they arrange an assortment of sauces and condiments and relishes on the table along with the usual cruet stand and sugar-basin. The preacher makes the bash, and the hearers flavour it to taste. Others adopt the method of spicing and flavouring in all sorts of ways, but they so manage (or mismanage) the business that one condiment destroys the pungency of the other. That sentence is a little bit acid and sharp, so in goes a dash of sugar to take off the edge. A certain remark by itself is a trifle too peppery or salt, so next comes a modifying phrase. Possibly the pudding does taste too plainly of lemon, and may be just a wee bit acid, so they pour some melted butter over it to help it down.
Now, it is too sure that if we do not put wholesome items in the viands, our hearers will not help themselves to them. The natural heart will never choose the wholesome before the toothsome. Most folk prefer sugar with their porridge to salt—I have caught some Scotchmen at it. A vivid recollection remains with me of a Christmas pudding whose head was sprinkled with salt instead of sugar, but, I need hardly add, it was a mistake; nor did this accident prevent the juveniles, at all events, from investing largely in that most risky of the season's compliments, nor hinder them from trying a mince-pie or two afterwards. Youngsters are not the only ones, nor is Christmas the only time, to whom and when the sugar-pot is in the ascendant. A sweet-tooth is by no means uncommon even with those who by reason of years have lost all their own. Oh, to have a wise appetite to choose the things which make for our peace.
It would appear from this that it does imperatively devolve on the minister to be personal, and not to shrink from declaring the whole counsel of God. "Too personal," indeed! Our hearers do not thus complain about their medical man. They are quite prepared to furnish
him with symptoms, to undergo examinations and to follow advices. Why is he never blamed for being too personal? Because health is a personal matter. Would that the people recognised the soul's health as a personal matter too, as it most assuredly is! Sin is personal. We suffer for our first parents' disobedience, it is true; but have not we ourselves sinned after the similitude of Adam's transgression?
Punishment, too, is a personal matter. "What mean ye that ye use this proverb, saying, 'The fathers have eaten sour grapes, and the children's teeth are set on edge'? . . . The soul that sinneth, it shall die. The son shall not bear the iniquity of the father, neither shall the father bear the iniquity of the son." And will not judgment and eternity be personal? "We must all appear before the judgment-seat of Christ; that everyone may receive the things done in the body according to that he hath done, whether it be good or bad." If these things be so, we cannot apologize for having been personal, nor promise to be less so in the future. Why do you object, good friends? We mean you well. You support us, it is true; but we would rather dig or beg than preach merely for the sake of pleasing you. We must be personal, though you should close your purses. We can give you no cloak for your sins, though you should give us the sack for our pains. We must sometimes supply cutting speech, though you may respond by cutting off our supplies. We must thunder at you, though you flash back your indignation like lightning; you tell us we must mind what we speak, we answer, "We must speak our honest mind." We will proclaim, "The wages of sin is death," even if you stop our wages in consequence. We must urge you to enter the strait gate, even though you should set before us an open door. We really cannot cut our coat according to your cloth, or tune our instrument to the pitch of your piano.
Say not then, "Oh, he is far too personal." Reckon those your best friends who speak plainest, and cut deepest; for these are they who pray oftenest that you may yet have a personal faith in a personal Saviour.
