Menu
‹ Chapter 45 of 311 ›

Notes upon the Covenanters

13 min read · Chapter 45 of 311

THE consummation of the Reformation in the north was attended with very extraordinary circumstances; for while other countries slowly emerged from the midnight of ecclesiastical corruption, the cold, depressing pall of Popery, which for centuries had darkened Scotland, was suddenly raised, as though a fog had been uplifted by the energy of the morning sun. The gospel was preached in its fulness, and with the thrilling power of earnestness: the people accepted the message, the nation was free. Doomed to extinction, the Pope's hierarchy did not so much crumble away as fall at once. The fate of Popery was even hastened by the fond services of its titled supporters; Mary could do no more than die a martyr to the cause, and her son James VI. was forced by public opinion humbly to proclaim in the ears of Christendom that the Reformed Church was a model for the world.

At the same time the land was not all at once completely purified from Popery; that deadly compound of truth, superstition, and paganism lingered in out-of-the-way places like those lowland damps which survive the warmth of day. There were likewise priests who, with a fanatical devotion to their cause such as shows how earnestly men may believe a lie, braved any amount of hardship in the forlorn hope of keeping alive in Scotland the dying flame of Romish faith. They would travel by day in a disguised habit, or steal forth under cover of the darkness, thinking themselves best protected by the terrors of mountain and flood. The Pope undoubtedly had enthusiastic devotees. Although the extravagant accounts of their achievements, hairbreadth deliverances, and so on, as detailed by their own historians, are probably inventions of Rome, the troubles of the priests who lingered in the country after the cause was virtually lost would make a curious chapter in church history. Our object in this paper is to point to the sufferings of true Protestants at the hands of professed Protestants in the seventeenth century.

With the exception of James I. it was the misfortune of the Stuarts to misunderstand the leanings and temper of the Scotch. People in London could see that a crisis was nearing in the reign of Charles; but he was willing to leave ecclesiastical affairs in the hands of Laud, and the Archbishop was weak enough to suppose himself stronger than a whole nation resolute in its faith. Even the court fool was more sagacious than Laud; for the witty jester openly-averred in a tavern in Westminster that the prelate was "a rogue, a monk, and a traitor"—a judgment which was terribly confirmed by the headsman's axe. Janet Geddes, who hurled a stool at a dean's head, and the unfortunate "fool," were wiser than the court and episcopal bench combined. Had the King and his satellites been equally discerning they might have averted the Civil Wars.

The various Covenants of Scotland had all one meaning; they were all designed to band the nation together in opposition to Popery and to the unwarrantable aggression of English Prelacy. The procedure of the Stuarts from first to last in regard to these covenants is not a little curious. When the first Scotch Confession of Faith was prepared by the

Reformer Craig, and promulgated in 1581, James VI. of Scotland adopted the document with an enthusiasm which it became inconvenient to remember when Holyrood was exchanged for Whitehall, and he became James I. of England. Surely there was no church like the Presbyterian for combining purity and liberty, and the king desired all his subjects to sign and think with him. On two occasions prior to the death of Queen Elizabeth, in 1590 and 1596, the subscription of the Covenant was renewed. In 1638 the arbitrary acting of Charles I., and the "thorough" policy of Strafford and Laud again directed the national attention to religion, and Craig's Confession of Faith, and a declaration that the subscribers would maintain what was therein contained, became the national Covenant, which the Edinburgh citizens adopted in Greyfriars' churchyard in February, 1638, and then sent throughout the length and breadth of the country to be signed. The Solemn League and Covenant of five years later, when the shock of civil war was beginning to be heard, was a still more comprehensive thing, extending its provisions to the three kingdoms. This formidable instrument was not only a bond of union, but a declaration of war against Popery and the school of Laud. With an honesty which was at least consistent, Charles I. rejected the Covenanters' principles when he became the captive of the army in 1646; but his time-serving son, when fortune placed him beneath the protection of the Scotch, professed to agree both with the letter and the spirit of the compact. The second Charles showed in the day of his power that a Stuart's honour was consistent with breaking his word, and persecuting those who had shown him kindness in time of need.

No historian is likely to err in over-estimating the judicial crimes of the Restoration; for probably no word-painting could convey a faithful picture of the beast-like amours, senseless profanity, and wild drunkenness of those who then undertook the administration of the laws. A brutal unrestraint in all kinds of vicious indulgence became fashionable in Scotland among certain classes, until the Edinburgh legislature earned the characteristic title of the Drunken Parliament. During its season of mad "loyalty" no insult was too gross to offer the nation it represented; no enactment was too absurd for the assembly to sanction. As a roaring, swearing company of wine-bibbers, the northern parliament manifested its attachment to Church and King by breaking, rather than by making, laws. Perhaps folly could not have gone to further length than when in one sweeping measure the laws of twenty-eight years were swept from the statute-book.

The Covenanters were not likely to be treated with any kindly consideration by these creatures. When it is necessary to humiliate an obnoxious party the most effective policy is to strike at the head; and therefore the English Government struck at Argyle, the General-in-Chief of the Covenanters. If the King had possessed any self-respect, leaving out of the question gratitude and honour, he would have hesitated before sacrificing a hero to whom the Stuarts owed so much, and whose execution alienated the better part of the Scottish nation from their cause. When his advice might have saved the monarch from the mistakes which entailed ruin and death, Argyle spoke out with true northern honesty what conscience dictated. He sympathized with

109

the cause of the Parliament during the Civil Wars, but he disapproved of the King's execution; and when Charles II. was crowned at Stone, in 1651, it was Argyle who placed the crown on the royal brow. When arrested and hurried to his doom, he had come to London as a friend, to offer his congratulations at court on account of the Restoration he had himself laboured to consummate.

In murdering Argyle, the Government struck at the head of a combination it was powerless to annihilate; but other victims, such as Archibald Johnson of Warrington, also left mournful gaps in the ranks of the Covenanters, which could not easily be filled up. Warrington, as he was commonly called, after his estate, was an erudite lawyer who heartily devoted his great learning and talent to the cause of religion. As the situation became more complicated, so that it became quite possible for a conscientious well-wisher of his country to differ from the more straitlaced Covenanters, Warrington was put down as a trimmer, and was disliked in common both by the orthodox partisans and the Remonstrants. It speaks much for his personal character and general aptness for business, that Cromwell contracted a strong liking for him; but his having served under the government of the Protector contributed to ensure his fall at the Restoration. He was a man who, amid the whirl and excitement of earthly care and business, waited for the coming of Christ, and his habits of devotion might even now excite remark. A hill-side often served him for an oratory, and on one occasion he continued in prayer during fourteen hours. His enemies were those in whose eyes Cromwell and his friends were murderers and usurpers, and he was sure to be the victim of their wrath. Although he escaped to the Continent, he was discovered in France, and surrendered by the amiable government of Louis XIV. In England a surgeon employed to attend him reduced his system by drugs and bleeding until there was apparently little left of the acute and fearless lawyer. His tears and incoherent talk before his judges in Edinburgh showed symptoms of mental failure. He made sport for those who loved cruelty for its own sake; but when in death on May 15, 1661, his former heroism returned, the change was ascribed by many to "God's miraculous kindness" to one who had been faithful to the good old cause.

The fact that he was one of the converts of Samuel Rutherford would alone testify in measure to the character of James Guthrie. He was a stout champion of the Covenant, too enthusiastic, indeed, to be always tractable. He believed in the Covenant with fervour, and was prepared to sacrifice his life in the cause of truth. He was no respecter of persons, and when Charles II. was in Scotland before the Restoration, the King endured from him many reproofs, which rankled in the heart of that profligate dissembler. By his fearless adherence to principle, Guthrie was led to do what he thought to be his duty with relentless impartiality. One of the favourites of the Stuarts, and a man who copied their licentiousness was the Earl of Middleton, a mortal enemy of the pious, straightforward Guthrie. The Covenanter earned the hatred of this political adventurer in a manner singularly characteristic both of the man and of the cause in which he was engaged. In a certain crisis Middleton proposed to aid the fallen fortunes of the King by raising a corps of Papists in the Highlands, and on account of this

act of treason to Protestantism the General Assembly of the church pronounced against him a sentence of excommunication; and it fell to the lot of Guthrie to administer from the pulpit this piece of wholesome discipline. Just prior to the time of service Guthrie received a letter—thought by some to have been written by the King—dissuading him from attempting to humiliate the nobleman in the open church. The warning only served to confirm the preacher in his purpose of obeying the Presbytery, and honouring God. That action cost the old man his life; for it was contrary to the nature of the Restoration statesmen to forgive an enemy. Guthrie was in due time arraigned on a paltry charge, which might have been equally brought against the best men of the country, and was sentenced to be hanged, and to have his head set up over the west-bow at Edinburgh. When his doom was pronounced, his heart was so wholly set upon Christ, that he came forth from the judgment-chamber with a heavenly countenance, which strangely contrasted with the profanity around him. He was an outcast from earth; but the gallows and market-cross at Edinburgh were to him the portals of heaven.

A belief in omens was common in his age, and Guthrie was not superior to the prevailing weakness. When, many years before, he had subscribed the Covenant, he was "stunned a little" by a circumstance which ruffled his composure—he met the hangman, in his uniform, passing along the street. This was an evil omen, according to the common belief, and Guthrie quite believed it to be so. What if the Covenant should entail death? The question was asked, the cost was counted, and from that hour there was no looking back. After his execution Guthrie's remains were carried into a neighbouring church to be dressed by a number of ladies of quality; and a youth more demonstrative than the rest entered and anointed the body with an ointment which perfumed the whole building. Persons in sympathy with the Covenant also dipped napkins in the warm blood, declaring their intention of spreading them out before the Lord, who would avenge the innocent in his own time. Some time after Guthrie's death a weird story gained currency in Edinburgh which, whether true or otherwise, shows the spirit of the times:—As the commissioner's carriage passed underneath where the head was spiked, some drops of blood fell upon the vehicle "which all their art could not wipe off." Men of science were consulted and asked to account for the startling circumstance, first of the blood dripping at all, and then of the impossibility of wiping it out. Baffled and alarmed, the commissioner ordered a new covering for the carriage; but that did not mend the matter, nor remove the guilt. A crime had been committed, and his conscience could not rest.

The assassination of James Sharp, Archbishop of St. Andrew's, belongs to the history of the Covenanters, or rather to the ecclesiastical civil war in which the government were weak enough to engage, a war carried on against a people who were determined not to submit to the yoke of episcopacy. We would not on any account apologize for the mistaken enthusiasts who laid violent hands on this enemy of his country; but while nothing can justify murder, it cannot be forgotten

111

that the prelate received in kind what he had meted out to others. He was but worsted in the fray which his own folly had provoked. It may be interesting to look at this curiously constituted man as he appeared to the people whom he first forsook and then oppressed.

From youth he appears to have been fired by worldly ambition, and to have studiously used his insinuating address to advance his own interests. At the opening of his career he held one position after another by which he was identified with the Covenant and the great movement thereby represented. At one time he might have been called a Presbyterian of the Presbyterians, and at that time he professed to shudder at the bare suggestion of forcing episcopacy on his beloved Scotland.

His subsequent doings show him to have been a double-tongued, two-faced schemer, over whose motives the chroniclers of opposite schools would be sure to wrangle in after days. He appeared before Cromwell in London to represent, and plead for, the Presbyterian cause; but friendship with the Protector did not prevent his corresponding with Charles in exile, any more than an apparently ardent attachment to the Scotch Kirk interfered with his courting the patronage of influential Anglicans. He was a dangerous friend and a treacherous ally; and it is thought that his opponents, who denounce his memory, have not gone beyond the truth, nor even up to it. He was an ecclesiastical weathercock, whose procedure was a trustworthy indication of the quarter whence the wind was blowing. History supplies few examples of baser treachery and dissimulation than are found in this extraordinary man. Just prior to the Restoration he left Scotland, ostensibly to represent and defend the interests of the Presbyterian cause; but what he really did would constitute an incredible story were not the facts well authenticated. He not only sold himself to the Anglican party as to the highest bidder, but, according to Burnet, he did so while sending news to the other party in Scotland concerning the zeal with which "he was soliciting their concerns, not without dreadful imprecations on himself if he was prevaricating with them." Such an adept at duplicity staked all, even property and life, in the game he chose to play; and he lost all.

It is interesting to look at Archbishop Sharp as he appeared from the Covenanters' standpoint, after he had deserted their standard to become a persecutor. Can we conceive the hatred and contempt with which a renegade, who presumed to persecute former allies, would be regarded in that stormy age? The prelate's self-seeking would be a common topic of conversation among all classes; his proud bearing would be marked as he passed along the street, and the blood of the persecuted would be laid at his door. As it was an age of superstition as well as of excitement, alarming rumours were abroad. Not only the common people, but many of their pastors, believed that the archbishop carried on an intercourse with evil spirits. Ridiculous stories of his dealings with the powers of darkness were current, and were widely accepted. According to popular belief he could move between Edinburgh and St. Andrew's faster than the fleetest horseman; and a certain dame confessed to Lord Rothes that she had seen Sharp and "the mickle black devil" in conference together. His murder was a crime unworthy of the Covenanting cause, and not to be identified with it; but, nevertheless,

when the bishop was dragged from his carriage and slain on the 3rd of May, 1679, there were many in Scotland who thought that a Goliath of the Philistine camp had fallen in accordance with the will of the Lord.

It was the misfortune of the Covenanters at an early stage of their great controversy with worldly powers to commit errors in judgment, and even to fight against their friends; on account of which mistake a terrible penalty was exacted in subsequent years. It is impossible for a dispassionate judge to approve of all that they did, in the way of retaliation; but then the world in the nineteenth century is not what it was in the sixteenth, and allowances must be made for the roughness of the times. When they joined hands with the Stuarts, preached down the English, and fought against Cromwell at Dunbar, the Covenanters acted like men who, having lost sight of their best interests, were determined to complete their own destruction. In this respect they sowed the wind and reaped the whirlwind after the Restoration. The mind of the Stuarts was never reflected in their words; but when the royal reprobates had regained their ascendancy there was no doubt as to their sentiments. The attempt to force episcopacy upon the Scotch people, the cold-blooded butcheries of Claverhouse, and the satisfaction with which the Duke of York presided at scenes of torture, all tended to open the eyes of the persecuted Covenanters as well as to teach them that trust was misplaced when yielded to princes of the house of Stuart. Virtually, the Covenanters were never defeated, nor was their spirit ever broken; for the energy and constancy inherited from the fathers of two hundred years ago have, through the Lord's blessing, set up the Free Church of Scotland in our more favoured times. May it abide faithful!

Everything we make is available for free because of a generous community of supporters.

Donate