Encouraging Superstition
THE following story is related in a book entitled "Round my House: Notes on Rural Life in France in Peace and War." By Philip Gilbert Hamerton. (Seeley, Jackson, and Halliday.) The author says that he tells the anecdote because of its deep significance, and because of the light it throws upon the relation of the Church of Rome to popular superstition.
"A peasant girl, called Annette, who lived on a farm quite close to our house, was in the habit of drawing water at a well which happened to be situated near a lane. As this lane serves for a communication between several farms, and also connects them with the high road, a good many people use it. Well, this girl was drawing water at six o'clock on a very misty October morning, when some one gave her a hearty slap on the back, said 'Bon jour, Annette!' in a cheery voice, and immediately disappeared in the misty twilight. What inference would the reader draw from this incident? He will conclude, at once, that some lad, belonging to a neighbouring farm, who knew Annette, had amused himself by giving her this greeting, and by disappearing in the mist before she could discover who he was. The vigorous slap on the back is evidence enough that the greeting came from a living human being, and not from an impalpable shade. This, however, was not Annette's interpretation of the incident. She told the story with evident accuracy as to the facts, but interpreted them as follows: the person who had said 'Bon jour, Annette!' was not a living human being, but a ghost, the ghost of her own father, and the reason why he came to say 'Bon jour!' in such an unexpected manner was that he was very uncomfortable in purgatory. This made the girl quite wretched. My wife tried to reason with her, adopting the obvious line of argument that, in the first place, the greeting had nothing of sadness in it, and, in the next place, that it had been accompanied by a good slap on the back, which a living lad might easily give, but a ghost not so easily. These arguments, however, proved utterly vain. The girl remained inconsolable all day, and in the evening went to seek comfort from the parish priest. Now the priest, instead of taking the rational side, and correcting the absurd superstition of which the girl was a victim, instinctively preferred to take the superstitious side. He accepted the incident as a real visitation from the dead, confirmed the girl's interpretation of it with the immense weight of his ecclesiastical authority, and told her that as she had now plain proof that her father's soul was unhappy she ought to have masses said for its repose."
When religious guides encourage superstition it is a grave fault. There is enough of the natural ore in most ignorant hearts, but it is a great pity that either priest or minister should go mining for it. If teachers smile upon miracles, they will soon have miracles to smile upon. We have heard of an instance of an ecclesiastic in high places, who said to a friend, "We shall have no miracles this year;" meaning that for certain reasons he intended to set his face against them, and so put an end to them. No doubt the crop of Papal wonders depends entirely upon the gentlemen with shaven crowns.
There is room even in England, and among Protestants, for a word
221
or two upon this subject. Our own observation makes us sadly aware that a superstitious belief in dreams, and visions, and voices, is not yet extinct; and we fear it will not be while some who should know better give a measure of encouragement to it. Not so very long ago, we were asked to interpret a good lady's dream, which struck her as very important. Its principal feature was a man whose head she could not see, but she could hear the dropping of blood. When we placed the ridiculous vision in its true light, as the result of a nightmare, or of indigestion, we fell in her esteem from the position of a prophet to that of an ignoramus. We heard afterwards that her own minister had given her a highly spiritual interpretation of the nonsense, and thereby raised himself in the lady's esteem. He was a ——, no, we will not mention the denomination to which he belonged; but we are half afraid that in that body there are not a few brethren who are prepared to endorse popular superstitions, or at least to utilize them for good purposes, smiling while they do so. The less of this the better. The error may seem trivial, but the outgrowth of it may be most mischievous. The belief in witchcraft would not still linger in our villages if all preachers of the gospel set their faces like a flint against it. We may never feel safe with regard to the inflammable material of superstition which remains in the human breast even in times of scepticism; at any hour it may serve as tinder for a new Mormonism, or some other form of wild fanaticism. There are not lacking portentous signs at this moment. What some have hailed as hopeful we have had reason to dread. Once or twice within the last dozen years the church at large has escaped from a fever of fanaticism by a hair's breadth, and the peril ought not to be perpetuated by unrebuked ignorance. C. H. S.
