Menu
‹ Chapter 170 of 294 ›

"But Middling."

4 min read · Chapter 170 of 294

THERE is not much difficulty in grasping the meaning of a critic when he pronounces a sermon to be "middling": but when the verdict is further qualified, as above, the "but" takes off a liberal discount not easily expressed otherwise. If a sermon is described as "but middling," you may be sure it is somewhere below mediocrity: the preacher, either through incompetence or want of diligence in the study, has fallen short of half the distance towards success. And yet, perhaps, the failure may be accounted for on other grounds. Mental anxiety or physical pain, neither acknowledged nor betrayed by the preacher in the pulpit, would, if known by the hearer, greatly modify his judgment, and sympathy would silence censure. Many men never can rise above the "but middling," while certain individuals are conspicuous amongst their auditors. Their listless attitude, or their well-known mental or moral predilections, render it impossible for the preacher to do his best; and the fault is theirs, not his!

The presence of a greengrocer in the white cravat with which he appeared as a waiter at a public dinner on the previous evening, has been known to disconcert a preacher and degrade his sermon, till it was "but middling," because, forsooth, he was mistaken for a college professor. Does the reader pronounce this to be unworthy of the man whose call to the ministry is divine? Let the reader remember that a man even with a divine call is a man still, and, most likely, a man with a very sensitive nervous organization. He would give all he possessed if, in facing an audience, he could feel himself master of the situation, and infinitely superior in every way to all the members of his audience. But, alas! he can do nothing of the kind. No sooner is he on his legs than he begins a process of introspection, and sits in judgment upon himself from the standpoint of his hearers, and the result is, his sermon is "but middling."

Few men are always at their best under all circumstances; and the sermons of some of the best preachers are sometimes "but middling." This being so, a man should not be finally judged by any one sermon he may deliver. "We will hear thee again" should be the wise resolve of hearers, even when they feel the sting of disappointment following upon the just verdict of the sermon—"but middling."

We have known preachers whose sermons are always "but middling," because they never seem to have a clearly defined idea of the subject they are handling, or of the purpose the sermon ought to serve. "He don't seem to get at it," said a critic to me on one occasion, when the preacher had pretty well exhausted his vocabulary of stock words and phrases with as much coherence as one might expect from the narration of a garrulous idiot. This want of definiteness or perspicuity must bring down any discourse to a level far below mediocrity. "But middling," is too great a measure of praise for it. There is nothing middling about it: it only borders throughout its course on the extremes of nonsense.

Then, again, we have known preachers so profound that they are lost in their own profundity. "I can't get at him," was the uttered regret

861

of a devout hearer who had listened to a sermon couched in terms which affected culture mistakes for learning. A select few, to whom such sermons are specially addressed, vote the production sublime; but the average hearer, whose poor brain has been pelted with vocables, and not wishing to be censorious, takes refuge in the very safe formula when he declares it to be "but middling." He would not be far out if he said it was "but muddling"; but Christian charity is careful even in the selection of a vowel.

If the average sermons of a preacher are "but middling," he cannot wonder if empty benches stare him in the face. Fewer people than ever attend a place of worship as a matter of course, and fewer still are content with any utterance simply because it is delivered from a pulpit. The congregation will be "but middling" if the sermons are "but middling." Nowadays, it is the men who preach because they have something to say, and not because the time has come when they are expected to say something, and, having something to say, know how to say it with the accent of personal conviction, who command a congregation. Even when they are not at their best, they never descend to mediocrity. If their sermons lack greatness, they are never deficient in goodness; if they contain but little for the head, they minister to the heart, and the verdict of the emotional outweighs that of the intellectual. Thomas Binney was an unequal preacher, but he was always worth hearing, and so he succeeded in getting and holding a congregation.

I happened to enquire of a deacon whose minister's sermons are "but middling," how they were getting on. The good man treated my question as a conundrum, and replied, "Don't know: I'll give it up. Ask another!" There was no necessity to add another question, for I was well able to grasp the situation. The sermons were "but middling," and the condition of the church was ditto. As the minister is less than half awake the people are more than half asleep. There is no movement till the benediction is pronounced, and then the congregation are on the move; but they move off with an undisguised sigh of relief that they are free from a similar affliction for another seven days. Sermons which are "but middling" will never rouse a church to vigorous life and aggressive action. If the preacher drones, the people dawdle.

Of this same minister, the last thing I heard was an opinion expressed by a visitor to one of the deacons—"You won't be troubled with him much longer"—the comment evoked in reply being, "It will be a merciful providence which removes him!" Sad as this case undoubtedly is, it is rather a type than an instance. There are, alas! far too many of whose sermons it must be said, they are "but middling."

V. J. O.

Everything we make is available for free because of a generous community of supporters.

Donate