Menu
‹ Chapter 206 of 294 ›

Compulsory Tithes: Enforced by Crushing Pains and Penalties — [Fifth Article.] — By Pastor W. M. Hawkins, Hundon, Clare, Suffolk

16 min read · Chapter 206 of 294

WE will now look at a few of the canons alluded to in our last paper. They reveal to us the unwillingness of the people to pay the tithe on the one hand, and the determination of the clergy on the other hand to have their legal due, no matter what else they did not have.

See Selden's "History of Tythes—that is, the practice of payment of them. The positive laws made for them. The opinions touching the right of them." —c. viii. pp. 195—217. Also Sir Henry Spelman's larger work of Tythes, chap. xxvii, where he proves that they are due by the law of the land.

A.D. 1064. "King William, in the fourth year of his reign, after the conquest of England, by the advice of his barons, caused the English noblemen that were men of knowledge, and learned in their law, to be summoned together through all the provinces of England, that he might from themselves hear their own laws, rights, and customs; therefore, twelve men, chosen out of every county of the whole nation, did make oath before the king that they would make known the sanctions of their own laws and customs, proceeding in a direct way, without swerving to the right hand or to the left, without making omissions, additions, or prevaricating variations; therefore, beginning with the laws of the holy mother, the church, because by her the king and kingdom stand upon a solid foundation, they declare her laws, liberties, and protection, saying—

'2. Let every clerk and scholar, and all their estates and possessions, wherever they are, have the protection of God and the holy church. . . .

'8. The tenth sheaf is due to God of all corn, and therefore to be paid. If any one keep a family of mares, let him pay the tenth colt. Let him that has one or two only pay a penny for every colt. Let him that has many cows pay the tenth calf; he that has but one cow, a half-penny for every calf. Let him that makes cheeses pay to God the tenth cheese; let him that does not, pay the milk of every tenth day; likewise the tenth lamb, the tenth fleece, the tenth cheese, the tenth butter, the tenth pig.

'9. Likewise of bees, the tenth of the profit; likewise the tenth is to be given to God who gives the nine parts, as well as the tenth of wood, meadow, waters, mills, parks, warrens, fisheries, osiers, gardens, and negotiations; let him that detains it be constrained to pay it by the bishop's court, and by the king's, if that be necessary. For the blessed Austin (Augustine) preached and taught this; and it was granted by the king, and barons, and people. But afterwards, many detained them by instinct of the devil, and priests being rich and negligent, did not care to be at the pains to get them, because they had sufficient maintenance: for there are now three or four churches in many places, where then there was but one. And thus [tithes] began to be diminished." —Johnson's "Laws and Canons of the Church of England," vol. i. pp. 522-4. Johnson quotes Dean Prideaux, c. 5. Sir H. Spelman, vol. i. p. 619. Wilkins, vol. i. p. 310. Thorpe, p. 190, &c.

Old Dr. Thomas Fuller says,—"King's arguments, we know, are unanswerable, as *ab authoritate*, carrying power and penalties with them. This charter might seem to give the tenth loaf of all the bread in the land into the hands of the English clergy." Fuller is not far out. As ages roll on, ecclesiastical exactions resemble the revolutions of a huge snow-ball.

A.D. 1070. The heads of a council, celebrated at Winchester. No. 10. "That laymen pay tithes, as it is written."

A.D. 1071. No. 14. "That tithes be paid by all."

A.D. 1230. No. 35. "As to tithes, we command them to be paid of all

things, which are yearly renewed, . . . and so that the churches be not defrauded of the tenth part on account of the wages of servants or harvesters. And we grant that the detainers of tithes, if upon a third admonition, they do not reform their error, be struck with anathema by the chaplains of the places till they make fit satisfaction."

In a canon A.D. 1175, No. 13, "Leave him that is insolvent to be punished at the bishop's discretion." Poor unfortunate wretch! If he had lost his money by bad seasons, or bad prices, and his cattle had died of disease, they took it out of his bones! How very like old Shylock!! "Holy" mother church, indeed! It ought to have succoured him in his sorrows. If he had been a felon, the church would have sheltered him, with the hope of getting fines and penance money from him; but having nothing wherewith to pay, he is to be punished by the bishop. It was better to be a felon than to be poor. The church opened its doors to shelter all law-breakers, except those who could not pay. Have we not sufficient here to account for the attitude of the poor towards the State-church?

A.D. 1305. No. 6. "Holy church hath ordained that prelates and ordinaries reclaim heretics, and such as are wavering in the Catholic faith, to ecclesiastical unity, and compel them to continue in the faith to which they are called. We understand that some parishioners are perverted to heresy and distrust: relinquishing the articles of the Christian faith, opposing ecclesiastical liberties, they impudently attempt to rob the church of her right by retaining tithes due by law to the churches, and withdrawing other church dues. And he who does not, when he can, revoke another from error, shows that he is not himself free from it; when, therefore, the church, and the rectors of churches, do not force such sons to pay their tithes, they destroy both their sons and themselves. Whereas, therefore, by the command of the Holy Scripture, tithes are to be paid of all things, yearly renewing without any diminution, without excepting any time, it is therefore allowed to every parish chaplain to compel his parishioners to pay tithes by ecclesiastical censure. . . . If men, out of contempt, do not obey their monitions, let them compel them to the payment of them by the sentences of suspension, excommunication, and interdict." It is easy to prove that these are no light sentences.

A.D. 1328. No. 7. "Because some sons of malediction endeavour to restrain the devotions of the people . . . not considering that the Almighty, to whom belongs the earth and its fulness, hath commanded tithes to be paid as a sign of his universal dominion, and hath assigned them to the clergy for his own service, do sometimes maliciously hinder, or cause to be hindered, the ecclesiastical persons to whom they belong, or their servants . . . from collecting, keeping, and carrying away the said tithes . . . unless gloves or shoes be first given, or promised them: we therefore, desiring to put a stop to such damnable devices of perverse men, ordaining nothing new, but enforcing the statutes of ancient canons, do by authority of this council declare every such instigator, hinderer, and others aforesaid, by whose wicked contrivances damage is done to the churches, or to the rectors or vicars of them . . . be involved in the sentence of the greater excommunication," &c.—Johnson, vol. ii. p. 351.

Chaucer gives some well deserved satire on the greed and worldliness of the clergy in the fourteenth century. Mr. Wright, in some comments on the poems, says, "The sermons of the friars in the fourteenth century were most frequently designed to impress the absolute duty of paying full tithes and offerings."

In Chaucer's Friar's Tale:—

"And smalle* tithers weren foul yshent,†

If any person would upon them plain;

There might astert them no pecunial pain.‡

* People who did not pay their full tithes.

† Troubled, put to shame.

‡ They got off with no mere pecuniary punishment.

429

For small: tithes and small offering,

He made the people pitcously to sing:

For ere the bishop hent* them with his crook,

They weren in the archdeacon's book;

Then had he, through his jurisdiction,

Power to do on them correction."

Also (as quoted by Selden) from Chaucer's plowman against the clergy of his age;—

"Their Tithing and their Offering both

They clemeth it by possession,

Thereof nil they none forgo,

But robben men by ransome."

And then of parish rectors:—

"For the Tithing of a Ducke,

Or an Apple, or an Aye (egg),

They make men swere upon a Boke.

Thus they foulen Christ's fay" (faith, religion).

And—

"'He woll have Tithing and Offering,

Maugre whosoever it grutch' (grudge)—

In spite of the ill-will caused.'"

The swearing has reference to the oath they had to take respecting the value of their personal property, so as to estimate the amount of the personal tithe. That Chaucer did not overdraw the picture is seen from a glance at suits instituted against farmers by the tithe receivers. Space only allows me to quote one now—Dent v. Salvin. It was necessary sometimes to clip the dirty locks of wool from sheeps' tails for better preservation from vermin. The ever watchful parson suspected fraud, and demanded his portion of the dirty mess. The farmer, aggravated and annoyed, told him to go somewhere—the exact locality does not matter now. The parson went to the law court, but returned home a "sadder, if not a wiser man." Imagine the trial of such a case! The depth of degradation the plaintiff had reached before he put in his claim!

This kind of annoyance and hindrance went on century after century, until the Tithe Commutation Act of 1837—which was another national assertion of State ownership—converted the payment from kind to a tithe rent-charge in cash, according to the price of corn. I now quote from "An Abstract of the Sufferings of the People called Quakers" (vol. i., sec x., p. 231) for non-payment of tithes in Suffolk. "Taken by distress—

| From | | Demanded | | | | Value taken. | | |

| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |

| | | £ | s. | d. | | £ | s. | d. |

| A.D. 1656. | Joseph Lawrance | 2 | 14 | 0 | .. | 10 | 0 | 0 |

| | R. White, of Wickhamskith | 3 | 5 | 0 | ... | 12 | 0 | 0 |

| 1657. | J. Fryer, of Felixton, he being at the same time in prison at the suit of an Impropriator | 0 | 18 | 0 | ... | 4 | 0 | 0 |

| | James Norton, of Flixton | 1 | 5 | 0 | ... | 3 | 15 | 0 |

| 1658. | John Fryer, aforesaid | 1 | 12 | 0 | ... | 14 | 0 | 0 |

| | James Norton, aforesaid (for the year's tithe, rent of land £12 13s. 0d.) | 5 | 10 | 0 | ... | 16 | 0 | 0 |

| | Thomas Bond had taken from him £3 10s. 0d. for tithe of land of no more yearly rent. | | | | | | | |

| | J. Coleman had hay, hemp, and flax taken of an uncertain value. | | | | | | | |

* Caught.

29

| From | Demanded | | | | Value taken. | | | |

| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |

| | | £ | s. | d. | | £ | s. | d. |

| 1650. | W. Driver, of Tremlie... | 1 | 14 | 0 | ... | 12 | 0 | 0 |

| | Thomas Pinson ... | 14 | 1 | 0 | ... | 57 | 0 | 0 |

| | W. Burrough, G. Finborough ... | 30 | 8 | 6 | ... | 40 | 0 | 0 |

| | Arthur Goddard, Clopton ... | 3 | 10 | 0 | ... | 14 | 0 | 0 |

| | Richard White, Mendlesham... | 4 | 0 | 0 | .. | 15 | 0 | 0 |

| | John Shipman, Crestingham... | 1 | 10 | 0 | ... | 6 | 0 | 0 |

| 1660. | James Norton ... | 12 | 12 | 6 | ... | 18 | 0 | 0 |

P. 233, Widow Posford, of Clopton, was sued in the County Court of Ipswich for tithes, and cast in treble damages. P. 234, Lucie Oxe, widow, her son, Christopher, and her daughter, Lucy, were cast into Melton gaol, at the suit of Francis Davis, priest, of Clifford; though the son and daughter had no property in the land, being only servants to their mother." In Vol. I. there are vast numbers of cases described of people called Quakers, who were fined and imprisoned on account of tithes. The amounts demanded were £1409 2s. 9d. The value seized and kept was £4603 14s. 6d. But the whole proceedings described only range from the year 1650 to 1660.

In Vol. II. p. 1. Bedfordshire, for non-payment of tithes, by distress, A.D. 1662. Taken from J. Bennett, of Stratfold, for 10s., a cow worth £2 16s. 8d.; from Anthony Bennett, for 18s., a cow worth £3 8s. 0d.; 1664, taken from widow Rawlings, of Little Bareford, for £5 10s. 0d., 5 cows, 3 beasts, and 3 horses, worth £50. In the year 1664 were prisoners for tithes in this county (Bedfordshire) six persons, of whom some have been confined two years, one, three years, and one widow, three months.

P. 67. In Cambridgeshire and the Isle of Ely, for non-payment of tithes—by distress—

| From | Demanded | | | | Value taken. | | | |

| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |

| | | £ | s. | d. | | £ | s. | d. |

| 1660. | Edward Peach... | 0 | 6 | 0 | ... | 5 | 0 | 0 |

| 1661. | Widow Peachy and S. Blow... | 0 | 7 | 0 | ... | 10 | 13 | 0 |

| 1662. | S. Fulbigg ... | 0 | 7 | 0 | ... | 2 | 10 | 0 |

| 1663. | Jeremy Rose ... | 0 | 0 | 2* | ... | 2 | 10 | 0 |

| 1664. | S. Blow ... | 0 | 12 | 0 | ... | 2 | 6 | 0 |

| | S. Wilson... | 0 | 10 | 0 | ... | 2 | 10 | 0 |

| | R. Read ... | 1 | 10 | 0 | ... | 10 | 0 | 0 |

Compulsory tithes themselves are oppressive and crushing. They have always been damaging to the material welfare of the country, and there is no doubt of their evil influence on the spiritual life of the nation. Christ's kingdom has been terribly torn and grievously misrepresented through them. Furthermore, they have been and are a most powerful engine to enslave the people, to instal and sustain wicked men in power, and to hinder God-fearing and Christ-loving people from communicating to their neighbours the "good news of salvation."

To prove all these serious charges would be an easy task indeed, if space were available. First, I quote Archdeacon Paley, whose works are text-books in our universities and colleges. In his "Moral and Political Philosophy," chap. xi., of population and provision; and of agriculture and commerce, as subservient thereto. Under the head of Taxation, Dr. Paley teaches, "A nation which is burdened with taxes, must always be undersold by a nation which is free from them, unless the difference be made up by some singular advantage of climate, soil, skill, or industry. This quality belongs to all taxes which affect the mass of the community, even when imposed upon the properest objects, and applied to the fairest purposes. . . . As governments are usually administered, the produce of public taxes is expended upon a train of gentry, in

* For tithe on a parcel of grass, for which the man was to give but eighteen pence he had to pay 300 times the amount demanded

431

the maintaining of pomp, or in the purchase of influence. The conversion of property which taxes effectuate, when they are employed in this manner, is attended with obvious evils." Here we have a graphic picture of the effects of tithes: unequal competition, maintaining gentry and pomp, and the purchase by them of influence. Are these not felt now to be evils—obvious evils—to any one who will examine them?

Paley says: "Next to the indispensable requisites of internal peace and security, the chief advantage which can be derived to population from the interference of law, appears to me to consist in the encouragement of agriculture. This, at least, is the direct way of increasing the number of people; every other mode being effectual only by its influence upon this. Now, the principal expedient by which such a purpose can be promoted, is to adjust the laws of property, as nearly as possible, to the two following rules:—First, 'to give to the occupier all the power over the soil which is necessary for its perfect cultivation'; secondly, 'to assign the whole profit of every improvement to the persons by whose activity it is carried on.' What we call property in land, as hath been observed above, is power over it. . . . The first rule of rational policy requires, 'sufficient power over the soil for its perfect cultivation.' . . . But secondly, agriculture is discouraged by every constitution of landed property which lets in those who have no concern in the improvement to a participation of the profit. This objection is applicable to all such customs of manors as subject the proprietor, upon the death of the lord or tenant, or the alienation of the estate, to a fine apportioned to the improved value of the land. But of all institutions which are in this way adverse to cultivation and improvement, none is so noxious as that of tithes. A claimant here enters into the produce, who contributed no assistance whatever to the production. When years, perhaps, of care and toil have matured an improvement; when the husbandman sees new crops ripening to his skill and industry; the moment he is ready to put his sickle to the grain, he finds himself compelled to divide his harvest with a stranger. Tithes are a tax, not only upon industry, but upon that industry which feeds mankind—upon that species of exertion which it is the aim of all wise laws to cherish and promote, and to uphold and excite which composes, as we have seen, the main benefit that the community receives from the whole system of trade and the success of commerce." I want the reader now to examine the opening paragraph of this chapter (xi.) "The final view of all rational politics is to produce the greatest quantity of happiness in a given tract of country. The riches, strength, and glory of nations, the topics which history celebrates, and which alone almost engage the praises and possess the admiration of mankind, have no value further than as they contribute to this end. When they interfere with it, they are evils, and not the less real for the splendour that surrounds them."

Unquestionably tithe-payments have interfered and do interfere with the cultivation of the land in England, which is now the only tithe-paying country. All the other nations have put an end to them, or entirely refused to have them at all. They would not hold to the ditty, "As it was in the beginning, is now, and ever shall be: world without end."

Our English farmers sing this over with upward glancings as if they were singing a divinely inspired mandate. Whereas it is simply a band cunningly devised to hold them in perpetual bondage. What an absurd impossibility! How can things remain as they are for ever? If they could, what good would it be? There is no sense in which this song is true. Does any one say it refers to the glory of God? I say the glory of God is ever increasing as new converts are made, and as multitudes of the redeemed gather round his throne. These two processes are continually going on and continually increasing the volume of the glory of God.

Paley is right in saying, "A nation which is burdened with taxes must always be undersold by a nation which is free from them," &c. No one in the

United States, or in Canada, pays tithe-tax. How can the English farmer compete with people who are free?

It is true that Dr. Paley was pleading for what he calls corn-rents before the Commutation Act of 1837. At that time the tithe was paid in kind. But his remarks on the noxious burdensomeness of tithes are now true with respect to tithe rent-charge. Tithe advocates tell us that the question belongs to the landlords, and that *they* ought to pay the "rent-charge." They say it is not a tenant's question at all. Accepting this, I will now put a landowner into the witness box. I quote from no radical or radical organ, but from the *Evening Standard* of January 1st, 1880. "Lady of the Manor," writes:—"As it is the intention of Mr. T. H. Bolton, M.P., to introduce a Bill in the forthcoming Session of Parliament for the abolition of extraordinary tithes, would it not be right to introduce into the same Bill a clause for the readjustment of ordinary tithes? None but they who have to pay them can know the terrible burden tithes are on an estate. The letter of Mr. Osborn Daintree, which appeared in your columns last week, showed how this tithe question affects all classes of the agricultural community. Mr. Daintree also says: 'As yet I have not heard of any instance where any rebate has been made from the sums which may be legally collected.' My experience entirely agrees with that of Mr. Daintree. Some time ago I wrote to the Ecclesiastical Commissioners, showing how overburdened we were by the large sum which annually left the estate on account of the Commissioners' tithes. I explained that we were no longer able to live on our own property on account of diminished income, and that in tithes alone we were annually paying more than one-fifth of that income. The only answer I received was that the Commissioners saw no reason why any alteration should be made. I may add that on our small estate are two small villages; therefore, in addition to the large sum—three hundred pounds—which we pay to the Ecclesiastical Commissioners, and for which we receive no benefit whatever, we have to pay tithes to two clergymen, one of whom is, and has been for over forty years, a non-resident. To the latter tithes I urge no objection; but I submit that the former case deserves the most careful consideration. I have no doubt that my own case, as quoted above, is but one in a thousand, but it is the number of similar cases which is bringing such distress on the agricultural community."

Distress in agriculture causes distress in the sale shop, in the workshop, in the mill, in the mansion, and in the whole community. If the strongest and healthiest man were to be bled every day, he would soon be weak and sickly. Is not this so with the national income? The sum exacted every day, in tithe rent-charge, and the letting value of the land and money taken in lieu of tithes, is above £14,294 sterling; or £5,317,561 6s. 8½d. a year. Agriculture contributes the greater part of this enormous amount. Is not this a distressing burden?

Everything we make is available for free because of a generous community of supporters.

Donate