Notices of Books
Rock Brothers, of 11, Walbrook, send us specimens of their new Hypatia Note-paper and Envelopes. We do not think we can commence judging articles other than literary; but as these are letter-ary, we will for once give an opinion. We can find no fault either with price or quality: the paper has a rosy tint. Stationers are requested not to follow the example of this Rock Company, for we cannot set up to be connoisseurs in paper.
Anecdotes and Incidents of the Deaf and Dumb. By W. R. Roe, M.C.T.D. and D. Derby: Francis Carter.
STORIES about deaf and dumb people gathered from all sources, not all equally worthy of preservation, but as a whole possessing special interest. We hope the little book will be of service to this afflicted portion of humanity. It is well done of Mr. Roe to have collected these notes, and we trust the sale of his little book will be so large as to encourage him to continue his memoranda. We shall transfer a story or two to our pages. Here is one:—
"Lord Seaforth, who was born deaf and dumb, was to dine one day with Lord Melville. Just before the time of the company's arrival, Lady Melville sent into the drawing-room a lady of her acquaintance who could talk with her fingers, that she might receive Lord Seaforth. Presently Lord Guildford entered the room, and the lady, believing him to be Lord Seaforth, began to spell on her fingers quickly. Lord Guildford did the same, and they had been carrying on a conversation in
this manner for about ten minutes, when Lady Melville joined them. Her female friend said, 'Well, I have been talking away to this dumb man.' 'Dumb!' exclaimed Lord Guildford, 'Bless me! I thought you were dumb.'"
"Ecce Homo." By the Right Hon W. E. GLADSTONE, M.P. Charles Higham, 27a, Farringdon Street.
WE shall never forget the day in which we fell in with "Ecce Homo." We were starting for York, and we opened the book as we left the London terminus. How the train proceeded, and at what stations it stopped, we never knew: having taken one plunge into the deeps of the book we only rose out of them to consciousness when the northern city was reached. The memory is sweet to us. Hence it is refreshing to read what Mr. Gladstone said upon the remarkable volume which so many condemned. Personally we did not join in the fierce censures which were uttered by many of the orthodox: the moral character of the book seemed to us to depend upon the author: it would be specially good if written by a candid unbeliever, and singularly traitorous if composed by a professed Christian. Its mental character is confessedly of the highest order; it is a fascinating volume to a thoughtful mind. Whatever Mr. Gladstone has to say is always worthy of respectful consideration, even if we do not agree with it. In this case his remarks upon the book are much to our mind; but their republication seems rather late in the day.
37
The Vocation of the Preacher. By E. PAXTON HOOD. Hodder and Stoughton.
THE preface is touching: Mrs. Paxton Hood herein acts as mother to this fatherless book. The pages are brilliant, for Mr. Hood was always full of fire and light. The work, as a whole, is probably more complete than any other of its author's productions. Those who do not possess his previous writings should invest three half-crowns at once in the purchase of this volume, and they will never regret it. Those who are already well up in Paxton Hood will recognize a good deal of what they have seen before, but yet much that is quite new. We do not quite agree with Mr. Hood's estimate of William Huntington and James Wells; and we wonder why he again and again calls Joseph Irons William. Some of the stories to the detriment of these good men are mere distortions of fact: not that Mr. Hood has distorted, but he has retailed statements which were inaccurate when they came to him. Perhaps we may yet give our readers an interesting paper of corrections; and if so, this will prove how capital the book itself must be, since its very errata are suggestive. Mr. Hood was within an inch of being one of our greatest writers, and we often wonder where it was that he missed the centre of the target: as it is, he was beyond all question one of the most piquant, amusing, and instructive of authors. Sometimes he appeared to be in a great hurry, and then he produced writing which was not up to the mark; but in the present instance he was at his best, and that best was very superior. We fear he killed himself with excessive labour. Peace to his ashes! It will be long before we meet with a man whom we more heartily esteemed.
Two West-End Chapels; or, Sketches of London Methodism from Wesley's Day. By Rev. J. TELFORD, B.A. T. Woolmer.
A REMARKABLE bit of Methodist history. We suppose it is published as a pioneer to the enterprise in the West-End which is proposed by Mr. Hugh Price Hughes. All London Wesleyans will like to read it.
Livingstone Anecdotes. A Sketch of the Career, and Illustrations of the Character, of David Livingstone. By DR. MACAULAY. Religious Tract Society.
ANOTHER of Dr. Macaulay's Anecdote Series. He makes capital extracts from biographies, and puts them together well: he has a genius for making books of this sort. Livingstone is an admirable subject. The book costs 1s. 6d.
Stories for the Band of Hope. Compiled and edited by J. L. NYE. Sunday School Union.
ARE you going to address a Band of Hope, and do you want a few anecdotes? Examine this collection. It is not so good as it ought to be, but it may help you. We select a bit from Canon Wilberforce.
An old sailor from Hong Kong has met with an accident, and the doctor says to him, "You must take some port wine." "No," said the old salt, "I am a tectotaler." "But," said the doctor, "you need it to strengthen you." "Doctor," said the old man, "do you think I shall die if I don't take the wine?" "Yes," said the doctor. "Then," answered Jack, "when you get into the St. Katherine's Docks, go round to the little room, and tell them that the old man died sober." But he did not die.
Australian Pictures, drawn with Pen and Pencil. By HOWARD WILLOUGHBY, of the "Melbourne Argus." Religious Tract Society.
WE half wondered what land the Society would describe for us this year. We are right glad to journey through the Australian colonies under the guidance of Mr. Willoughby. The engravings and letter-press are up to the high level of former volumes: we do not see how they could be better. This is not only a drawing-room book of a high class, but it is so solidly instructive that it might be used as a guide to these vast regions. The 8s. which it costs is a small sum for such a banquet as we have enjoyed in merely looking it through: we expect much more entertainment when we can secure a deliberate study of it. We prophesy that this will be the most popular work of the series; for it is so seasonable.
547
How Readest Thon? or Christian Baptism as contained in the Word of God. By FRANK H. WHITE. Partridge and Co. Paper, 4d.; cloth, 6d.
VERY gracious and convincing. Our brother is free from all party prejudices, but none the less faithful to the teaching of our Lord. Those who are perplexed about baptism should read this excellent treatise.
Christian Unity: what is it? The Church of England Book Society. Price one penny.
VERY good so far as it goes. We would go a great deal further. If we do not exchange pulpits with evangelical clergymen it is no fault of ours. The difficulty, so far as we are concerned, is not on our side; and we will be fair, and add that in many instances it is not the fault of the brethren on the other side, but of that unbrotherly system which holds them beneath its iron sway. Lately a neighbouring clergyman promised to attend a meeting at a Baptist chapel, but the incumbent of the parish prohibited it. He now invites the Baptist brother to read prayers in his church as a protest against this exclusiveness. We do not quite see how the Baptist is to do it, but we like the brother's offer. Shall we never see the end of this disunion?
This tractate coming from the Episcopal side is to be commended. It is rather watery, but it is as welcome as a drop of dew.
The City Youth. By J. THAIN DAVIDSON, D.D. Hodder and Stoughton.
ADMIRABLE, most excellent brother, J. Thain Davidson, D.D.! Your instructions are sound, sensible, and scriptural; and you have a telling way of setting them forth. Your printer and bookbinder have done their work well, and now we wish you multitudes of readers among "the City Youth." The book costs 3s. 6d.
A Subject dear to the Saviour's Heart. By WALTER J. MAYERS. Bristol: Rose and Harris.
THE subject is Christian union. The neat little tractate contains notes of an address read by the author before the Bristol and Clifton branch of the Evan-
gelical Alliance. Those who requested the publication were well advised, for the treatise is excellent.
The Period of the Reformation—1517 to 1648. By LUDWIG HAUSSER. Edited by WILHELM ONCKEN; translated by Mrs. G. STURGE. Charles Higham, 27a, Farringdon Street.
THIS history is so well written that when we began to read it, we found ourselves fairly bound to keep on. The story of the Reformation movement in England is tersely told with commendable impartiality. The volume is composed of lectures delivered at the university of Heidelberg by Dr. Häusser, and we all feel much obliged to Professor Oncken for having taken shorthand notes of such able productions.
The Comfortable Words. Being meditations on the Sentences of Holy Scripture following the absolution in the Communion service. By THOMAS THOMASON PEROWNE. Elliot Stock.
CHURCHIFIED in tone; so much so that the High Church clergy can accept it. The "comfortable words" used in the office of Holy Communion in the Anglican church have suggested Mr. Perowne's addresses, and therefore it was natural that a sort of liturgical spirit should pervade them; but yet they are sweet evangelical utterances. We call the attention of our Episcopal readers to this little devotional book; for it may be helpful to them.
Edwin Arnold as Poetizer and as Paganizer: containing an Examination of "the Light of Asia," for its Literature and for its Buddhism. By WILLIAM CLEAVER WILKINSON. Funk and Wagnalls, 44, Fleet Street.
A SLASHING review of Arnold's Pagan poems. We have no desire to gaze upon "the Light of Asia," which Mr. Wilkinson shows to be darkness of the densest kind—fit sphere for Arnold's glow-worm poetry. This essay makes No. 131 in Funk and Wagnalls' Standard Library, which contains some of the cheapest literature ever published. Many of the editions in this series can only be sold in America, as the works are copyright here.
Can the Old Faith Live with the New? or, the Problem of Evolution and Revelation. By REV. GEORGE MATHESON, M.A., D.D. Second edition. William Blackwood and Sons.
WE answer the title of this book in the negative, with all the emphasis of our soul. Either true religion must die, or else the new theology: they are as opposed as light and darkness. Our excellent author makes a vain attempt to show that they are compatible, and in this he is likely to do more harm than good. His design is to sustain the orthodox faith, but the result is rather to weaken than to strengthen it. We do not care for the book at all.
New Outlines of Sermons on the New Testament. By EMINENT PREACHERS. Hodder and Stoughton.
THESE new outlines appear to us to be far better than the majority of such things. They have a freshness and a vivacity about them which are specially taking. We have not thought "The Clerical Library" to be quite as good as it might have been; but this volume is up to the mark, and will make its way. Price 6s.
Blessings for the Little Ones. Illustrated. Religious Tract Society.
A PRETTY story, showing how children can partake of the blessings of the Beatitudes. A good idea.
The Biblical Treasury. Proverbs to Solomon's Song. Sunday School Union.
EVERYONE who has begun to take in this admirable collection of Scriptural illustrations will be sure to wish for the completion of the series. The work is as valuable as it is unpretentious.
The Divine Institution of David's Psalms, and the Unlawfulness of using Uninspired Hymns in Divine Worship. By A LOVER OF PURITY IN RELIGIOUS WORSHIP. Edinburgh: James Gemmell.
IT is pleasant to read what can be said upon such a question. We cannot say that we are convinced, but very much the reverse; yet we like to know what can be written. The Psalms are too much neglected among English Non-
conformists: if they were better known, and oftener sung, they would soon be preferred to numbers of the poor, meaningless hymns which are now current. If one wishes to sing a hymn upon electing love, or upon others of the deeper truths, where will he look for one in the denominational hymn-books? To suit the many, the more precious doctrines are pushed into a corner. Were the Psalms of David more frequently sung, it would evidence a deeper spiritual life: but the exclusive singing of them would be impossible when that life rose into full fellowship with Christ.
In our more elevated fellowship we pine to "sing unto the Lord a new song," and like holy Mary and Zacharias we speak in other language than that which the older forms supply to us. There must be room left for hearts that glow with love to express themselves in rapt devotion; the free Spirit can no more have tied us down to sing in fixed language than to pray with a liturgy.
The Acts of the Apostles: divided into Short Sections, with a Simple Commentary for Family Reading. By REV. FRANCIS BOURDILLON, M.A. Elliot Stock.
WE are always pleased when we come across a work by our well-beloved brother, Francis Bourdillon, for a rich dew from the Lord rests upon all his writings. As a gracious, popular commentary on The Acts, we commend this work to Christian readers. It is not wishy-washy because it is intended for families; but it will repay the careful reading of any devout person. Mr. Bourdillon aims at the culture of the graces, and the salvation of souls; and his labour is not in vain in the Lord.
A Missionary Band: A Record and an Appeal. By B. BROOMHALL, Secretary of the China Inland Mission. Morgan and Scott.
THIS should be in the hands of every lover of China. It is a noteworthy book in many ways. As a memorial of the going forth of Cambridge graduates to mission-work, it is deeply interesting; but, besides this, it is rich in holy utterances and inspiring information. It is a beautiful work in its best binding, and cheap at 3s. 6d.; in paper it is only 1s. 6d.
549
A Century of Protestant Missions, and the Increase of the Heathen during the Hundred Years. By Rev. JAMES JOHNSTON, F.S.S. Nisbet and Co.
MR. JOHNSTON is doing great service to missions by issuing this sixpenny pamphlet. It contains many startling facts. How few persons are aware that there are two hundred millions more of heathen in the world now than when modern missions began! Nor is it generally known that Buddhism and Mahometanism are making converts by millions. We do not share Mr. Johnston's fear about food for the growing myriads, but we heartily join with him in his zealous desire that the bread of life should be handed to them. Twenty-five shillings will buy a hundred of these tractates, and their distribution would greatly increase the missionary spirit.
Shaftesbury: His Life and Work. Second edition. By G. HOLDEN PIKE. Partridge and Co.
ANOTHER edition of the most popular life of our venerated friend which has yet appeared. It is first-rate change for a shilling.
Up the Rhine and over the Alps. By SILAS K. HOCKING, F.R.H.S. Andrew Crombie, 119, Salisbury Square, E.C.
NOTHING very brilliant. A simple, chatty book, which might almost serve as a guide-book to friends who are about to do the Rhine and a part of Switzerland. The engravings are first-rate. Good change for half-a-crown.
Wayside Lyrics. BY GEORGE NEWMAN. Gravesend: T. Hall, 4A, Windmill-street. London: Whittaker and Co.
YES, pleasant verses, always written with good intent. Gravesend need not be ashamed of its songster, any more than of its hero who ranked among the bravest of the brave.
The Morning Song, a Ninefold Praise of Love. By JOHN WATKINS PITCHFORD. Elliot Stock.
WE have had to traverse morasses of poetry, as flat as pancakes, and as monotonous as desert sands; but in reading this work we are in another country—a land full of beauty, a land of hills, and valleys, and brooks of water. We had
not read a page before we felt refreshed and exhilarated. If we have not here a poet of the first class, we have certainly one of no mean order. We shall be greatly surprised if the world does not yet ring with such minstrelsy as this. The song of nature is blended with the hymn of redemption, and the double theme is worthily expressed. Our author is an observant naturalist, and he is evermore devout, as a true poet must be. We must be content with this brief notice now, and return to the volume when we can set apart an hour or two for deliberate reading.
A Royal Service, and other Poems. By JEAN SOPHIA PIGOTT. S. W. Partridge and Co.
CONTAINS many sweet verses. Devout and musical; these sonnets will please and edify.
Plain Talk for Plain People. By JOHN VAUGHAN. J. Toulson, 6, Sutton Street, Commercial Road, E.
ANSWERS to its title. Rather too full of stories of the manufactured order, but entertaining and bracing.
Out of Step. By C. M. CLARKE. Partridge and Co.
To our mind this story is quite "in step" with the great regiment of similar writings. There is nothing above the common average, and while we pity the little boy of whom the tale tells, who is misunderstood by everybody, we are much afraid the book will share his fate.
Loyally Loved; and Lost and Found. By Mrs. CHARLES GARNETT. "Home Words" Publishing Office.
TWO really good tales. The former tells, in a touching manner, the sad havoc caused in a happy home by drunkenness; and at the same time the heroic love of a wife in winning back a dissolute husband. "Lost and Found" is a story of want, bravely borne, during the severe winter of 1879, when the sorrowful song of "We've got no work to do" filled many a street with its doleful notes. It shows in a very interesting way how lovingly the poor help each other. The authoress is founder of the "Navvy Mission Society." God bless both worker and work!
Help on the Way. By Rev. JOHN S. SHIELDS, D.D. Hodder and Stoughton.
SERMONS worthy of their title, real helps to faith and hope. Orthodox and able, devout and forcible, these discourses must have ministered grace to the hearers, and we hope they will be still more useful to a numerous company of readers. The Irish Church is happy in having such a preacher within its borders.
Anecdotes Illustrative of Old Testament Texts. Hodder and Stoughton.
VERY good. We have here a very fair admixture of new anecdotes together with certain old ones which are inevitable. Good money's worth at six shillings. This would be a very acceptable present to a minister or teacher. We wish every poor parson had one given him. It is one of the best of the books which make up "The Clerical Library." Get it.
The Contemporary Pulpit. Vol. V. Swan, Sonnenschein, Lowrey, and Co.
THIS magazine for ministers preserves its high character. The five volumes now completed give a full and fair reflection of the pulpit of the period. We like this periodical much.
Fruits of Solitude in Reflections and Maxims relating to the Conduct of Human Life. By WILLIAM PENN. James Clarke and Co.
OUR estimate of these maxims is moderate: they are good, but not of the very finest metal. Our judgment may possibly be wrong, for the work has passed through many editions, and feeble books do not usually live and flourish at such a rate. The fact that the book is by one of the most eminent of the Quakers has secured it a circulation among that excellent body of Christians, and so has kept it alive. It contains much sound sense and practical wisdom. This shilling edition is a reproduction from the folio of 1726.
Under the Shadow of his Wings: or, Comforting Words for the Weary. Religious Tract Society.
SCRIPTURE, hymn, and word of a holy man: a select reading for each day of eight weeks. Very good, of course, but
nothing very remarkable. With a little care any Christian man, with a few books, could make as good a selection for himself; but then he may not have the time or the books, and in such a case this volume will be of much service to him. The readings have an eye to the sick and sorrowing; the type is large and clear, and the price is half-a-crown.
Sermons. By JOSEPH LECKIE, D.D., Ibrox, Glasgow. Second edition. Glasgow: James Maclehose and Sons.
SERMONS full of poetic feeling. They do not so much belong to the old-fashioned weighty school of Scotch divinity as to the more polished order of later days. By this criticism we would by no means insinuate that there is anything questionable or deficient in the theology, for such is not the case. It is a great refreshment to read such graceful and gracious discourses, and we doubt not that they will have a high place in sermon literature. Personally we prefer discourses which go deeper, and contain more doctrine; but these in their own order are masterly and profitable. A friend calls these sermons "enjoyable and stimulating," and they deserve the description.
Is Life worth Living? An Eightfold Answer. By JOHN CLIFFORD, M.A., LL.B., B.Sc., F.G.S., D.D. Fifth edition, with a new Preface on the Ideal of Life and Agnosticism. E. Marlborough and Co.
WE do not wonder that this book is in a fifth edition; it is so concise and forcible.
Lines and Links in the New Testament. By CALEB C. BROWN. Part I. S. W. Partridge and Co.
WE can believe that placing texts in juxtaposition, as we have them here, is often highly suggestive to readers. This book is very elementary, and for that reason would be all the more useful to many if we could induce them to give their minds to it. The distinctive features of the four gospels are brought out, and many hints are given. We wish the work were better; but we are right glad that it is so good that we can commend it, not to general readers, but to gracious students whose object is real profit, and not passing pleasure.
551
A Handbook of the Church of Scotland.
By JAMES RANKIN, D.D. W. Blackwood and Sons.
FULL information is here given on all points of interest connected with the Scotch Establishment, and herein lies the value of the "Handbook." It attempts to defend the principle of establishments, and the particular instance of it which is seen in the Old Kirk. Certainly the crumbling walls of Church-and-State organizations need defence very badly, and those who are eager for such protective service should get at it at once, for the days of establishments are numbered. Dr. Rankin does his best, but there is not much in it. But we forbear; for when we alluded to the Scotch National Church the other day, a friend who had read The Sword and the Trowel for many years with delight wrote us a boiling-over epistle, assuring us that the magazine should never enter his house again. What is to become of us? Shall we break our sword, and sell our trowel? No, we shall not, for we feel a sort of inward assurance that our boiling-over friend has cooled down by this time, is now taking the magazine, will read these very lines, and will smile over them. Give us your hand, most valiant State-Church brother. No, we don't mean mark us under the eye with your fist. But just believe, as we do, that it will be for the public weal that there be no gagging of tongues upon important questions, and at the same time no lack of hearty faith in one another's honesty. A State Church is to us a gross injustice, and a terrible blunder, and so we war against it: and those who think differently must take the opposite side.
Peril and Adventure in Central Africa.
Being Illustrated Letters to the Youngsters at Home. By the late Bishop HANNINGTON. Religious Tract Society.
We all lament the good Bishop Hannington, for he belonged to all humanity. This little children's book, with woodcuts drawn by himself, is merrily written, and reveals the great, simple, earnest heart of the man. It only costs one shilling, but it is a remarkable little missionary work, and will do more for Africa than the big volumes of travellers. Commend us to such fresh talk as this. It
makes us mourn the dear servant of God more than ever.
A Letter to the Rev. Samuel Davidson, D.D., LL.D., in Answer to his Essay against the Johannine Authorship of the Fourth Gospel. By KENTISH BACHE. Parker and Co.
WE cannot conceive of anything more crushing to the dubious Doctor's assertions. Many are so credulous that they believe any rubbish which bears the name of "Modern Criticism"; yet this pamphlet makes it clear that if there be blundering and barefaced assertion anywhere, it is to be found with the new school. To doubt that John wrote the fourth gospel reveals a want of sense rather than a plenitude of learning. To all really candid doubters this demolition of a D.D. will be truly helpful.
The Steps of a Good Man; and other Poems. By H. S. ENGSTROM. Wm. Hunt and Co.
PLEASANT enough, and musical. Not to be put down as mere rhyme, nor even to be cast into the limbo of respectable mediocrity, where lie the multitudes who are doomed to be forgotten. The tone and teaching are excellent, and gleams of poetic light gild the gracious thought.
Four Essays on the Sabbath, to which were awarded Prizes of £100, £50, £30, and £20, by the Sabbath Alliance of Scotland. Edinburgh: James Gemmell.
WE have aforetime commended Mr. Hamilton's paper, which is the first and best of the four. The others are strikingly good, and the four make up a huge volume, which stands very little chance of being read. It is a laudable work to lead thoughtful men to produce such dissertations, and there is special need for them at this period, when the Sabbath seems to be gradually slipping away from under us.
Rest on the Way. Hodder and Stoughton.
A BEAUTIFUL present for a shilling. Something between Christmas cards and a book: after the manner of "Sunrise" and "Sunset," which were such a success last year.
Dissertations on the Creation. By WILLIAM GALLOWAY, M.A., M.D., Ph.D. Hamilton, Adams, and Co.
THIS work is both learned and luminous, and those desirous of studying what the oriental nations thought on the subject of the creation of the world, and of the condition of its first inhabitants, cannot do better than accept the guidance of Dr. Galloway. He is most familiar with the literature of his great theme, and hence his volume, which is well got up, is quite a storehouse of interesting and important facts and arguments. The volume is quite unique in its method of dealing with the relationship of God's word to God's work. Mythology and science alike are made to illustrate the author's argument, and he is equally at home in his knowledge of both; and though we do not accept all the conclusions of the learned author, we cannot but admire the wide research, rich scholarship, and reverent thought which the volume reveals. The work deserves a wide circulation. It is massive, weighty, forceful, and suggestive.
A History of the Jewish People in the time of Jesus Christ. By EMIL SCHURER, D.D., M.A. Second division. Translated by SOPHIA TAYLOR and Rev. PETER CHRISTIE. (3 vols.) Edinburgh: T. and T. Clark.
As a splendid help to the realization of the times in which the New Testament was written, these volumes are of great value. A scholar will find in them much more pleasant reading than Continental writers usually offer us; but those of our readers who are not scholars will possibly think them heavy. He who wishes to know upon the best authority all about the language, the religion, the morals, &c., of the Jewish people in the days of our Lord, cannot have a better instructor. This work, under another title, has been unanimously voted to a high place in religious literature: it is here presented in an enlarged form, and its value is greatly enhanced by the additions. Possibly nobody but a German divine would have issued the second part of his work before the first, as in this case: but let it come how it may, each part is welcome. For singular learning and deep research, these volumes cannot be excelled. We suggest
that many a weary mind might refresh itself by entering upon a fresh and special field of study, and we further suggest that these volumes offer just such an inviting subject. Possibly some ministerial brother may be glad of the hint. If notes for Bible-classes, and lectures for young men's meetings, came out of such study, so much the better.
Creation and its Records. A Brief Statement of Christian Belief with reference to Modern Facts and Ancient Scripture. By B. H. BADEN-POWELL, C.I.E., F.R.S.E. Hodder & Stoughton.
WE are not prepared to accept evolution as a proven, nor even to regard it as a probable, theory. Hence we have no liking for attempts to reconcile it with the Bible, or the Bible with it. There is no need for such reconciliation. It will be time enough to do this when the fanciful hypothesis becomes associated in some remote degree with facts. At present this madness is best left to its own ravings.
Agnosticism and Herbert Spencer. By WILLIAM ARTHUR. Bemrose and Sons, 23, Old Bailey, and Derby.
THOUGH, to ordinary readers, common sense and daily observation and experience may suffice to refute the subtle errors which, under the title of Agnosticism, have been taught by men who assume to be the most learned of the present day, yet it may be needful to refute them upon their own ground, and to show how far they are opposed to the wisdom of this world, as well as to that which cometh from above. Mr. Arthur, who has written well in direct explanation and defence of Scripture truths, must have felt strongly the necessity of entering upon such an arena, and of qualifying himself for it, to have produced such an elaborate and exhaustive treatise upon the subject. It is well that Herbert Spencer and his admirers should know that there are those amongst the most fervent believers in all Scripture given by inspiration of God, who are as qualified for metaphysical discussion as themselves, who could follow them if they would, but would not if they could, who know all that they know, and infinitely more which to them is unknown.
