William Prynne and the "Histrio-Mastix."
WILLIAM PRYNNE is one of the representative Puritans of the Old England under Charles I., when the great storm of the Civil War was gathering; and, as a conscientious hero, who could not be cowed by the cruel and illegal action of the Star-Chamber, he is one of the worthy figures of English history. Born in the year 1600, in the West of England, he was educated first at the Grammar School of Bath, and subsequently at the University of Oxford. Prynne took up his residence at Lincoln's Inn, where the Puritan Dr. John Preston was lecturer, and he became a follower of that divine. He seems to have commenced his career of authorship by writing against Arminianism and Prelacy; and by this and other actions he won the undying hatred of Laud and his school. Prynne was a writer of such industry that his works fill nearly two hundred volumes, the best remembered of which is probably his "Histrio-Mastix; or, a Scourge for Stage Players." When we consider the enormous labour which the preparation of this book of considerably more than a thousand pages must have entailed, we feel justified in styling it the most wonderful indictment of the stage ever written. The Christian Fathers, the ancient classic authors, and apparently all who down to that time had mentioned the subject, are laid under tribute, so that if the book was really written in seven years, we can understand that the writer must have worked hard during the greater part of that time. The sentence of the Star-Chamber pronounced on Prynne as a punishment for his work, including, as it did, the loss of his ears, branding in the face, imprisonment, and ruinous fines, was worthy of the Inquisition in its worst days. By this action, however, the court overshot the mark, turned Prynne into a popular favourite, and thus hastened the catastrophe of civil war. Although the book was regarded as a libel on the Queen, the affair was really a duel between Laud and Prynne, the Archbishop hating the barrister on account of his writings against Arminianism.
As Prynne's book is usually described as coarse and scurrilous by historians, and as it is so extremely scarce that few of our readers are likely ever to have an opportunity of looking into its time-stained pages for themselves, we have gathered a few flowers and fruits, just to show what Prynne could do when in his happier moods. While reading such utterances we shall not wonder that patriots took up the sword to put down tyranny, when a man of this character was tortured, imprisoned, and ruined for the offence of writing against theatres as things destructive of religion and morality.
Concerning evil things that seem to be good, he says: "Though the devil may sometimes commend some seeming good unto us, yet there is always poison in his best and sweetest potions: there is a soul-entangling snare in all his intentions, a dangerous and inevitable book in all his baits. All his works, contrivances, and delights, whatever glittering outside, or honey-tastes they seem to have, are but so many traps and poisons to captivate and endanger souls."
Then, again: "Where the fountain is polluted, the streams are always filthy; where the root is bitter and corrupt, the fruit and branches are so too; where the foundation is decayed, the building must be ruinous."
579
But some say that plays and the stage may exercise a great moral influence; who will become the reformers? "Good men will not," answers Prynne; "they rather wish their ruin than their hopeless, useless welfare. Bad men will not, because they approve them not but for their pleasing corruptions, which feed their carnal lusts."
In one place Prynne remarks: "He that sins thus in jest [i.e., on the stage] and merriment, sins more wittingly, wilfully, contemptuously, and presumptuously than he that sins in earnest."
Describing the stage as he found it, he says: "Sin is the mistress, virtue but the handmaid which occasionally attends it. Vice hath the whole, at least the greatest share in all our stage plays; poor virtue hardly finds a part in any, most parts in none. The virtues, therefore, that are acted in our theatres, as they do not balance, so they cannot justify nor excuse, the vices." And again: "The supremest virtues of the most renowned Pagans are too inferior precedents for the meanest Christians." Hence, "suppose there are some real virtues acted in our interludes, yet who can be so grossly stupid as to think to learn any grace or virtue from a playhouse? Who ever sought for gold, for pearls in dirt? for a crystal spring in filthy mire? for wholesome water in a noisome kennel? Who ever resorted to a pesthouse to look for health, or drunk down poison to preserve his life?"
Then, it would appear, that the line separating the church and the world was very plainly seen in those Puritan days; for instance—"But among any others that go to the theatres, when shall you see an ancient citizen, a chaste matron, a modest maid, a grave senator, a wise magistrate, a just judge, a godly preacher, a religious man not blinded in ignorance, but making conscience of his ways? You shall never see any of these at plays, for they count it shameful and ignominious, even an act of reproach that may redound unto them."
But what if some good people do find entertainment in stage plays? "When good and bad men join together in religious duties, the goodness of the lesser part denominates the whole," answers Prynne, "and makes it good in God's, in men's account, because the end, the cause of this convention, is God's glory. But when good and bad confederate themselves together in any delights of sin, God looks not on the goodness of the good, but upon the wickedness of good and bad, condemning all for a congregation of evil-doers, because the object, the end of their conventicles, is unlawful."
Concerning dancing, the Puritan barrister says, that "the way to heaven is too steep, too narrow for men to dance in." In another place he adds, "they that work hard all day, had more need to rest, than dance, all night."
Another argument against frivolous recreation is thus expressed: "That which doth always unavoidably produce an intolerable misspence of much peerless time, which should be carefully improved and redeemed, must certainly be sinful, and so unlawful, unto Christians." Another argument is the great expense which theatres involve—money which might well be employed for better purposes.
What will the patrons of the drama say to this? "Solon . . . beheld Thespis acting a tragedy, wherein there were many lies and cheats. He demanded of him, after the tragedy ended, whether he were
not ashamed to lie and cheat so egregiously before so great a multitude? To which Thespis replied, that there was no hurt in it; for all he had uttered or acted was but a play, it was all in sport, nothing in earnest: which answer Solon hearing, struck his staff upon the ground with indignation, making this reply: 'If we commend this play of yours, we shall shortly find it in our bargains.'
It seems to have been Chrysostom who first called the theatre the Devil's Conventicle; and Prynne maintains that nothing more effectively counteracts the influence of the house of God than stage-plays. Doubtless many illustrations proving the truth of this might be given. "He is too audacious who strives to pass over these when he hath seen another to have fallen. He is outrageously unruly who is not struck with fear when he sees another perish in that course which he is running. He only is a lover of his own safety who takes warning by another's death; and he only is a provident man who is made solicitous by the ruin of other men."
Elsewhere he says, "The truth, then, is this: most play haunters learn no good at all at sermons, not because sermons have no goodness for to teach them, but because they are unapt to learn it."
Prynne did not repine at being called a precisian; for he maintained that if Christ, the patriarchs, the prophets, and the holy men who had lived in the past were back on the earth, "they would all be pointed at, hissed, reviled, hated, scorned, if not persecuted, as the very archest Puritans." Again: "Let a man make conscience of drunkenness, of drinking and pledging healths, of frequenting ale-houses, taverns, and tobacco-shops, and presently he is cried out upon and censured for a Puritan by all the pot-companions." Still, he is fully confident that the despised sect are masters of the situation; for, as soon as ever their opponents are prostrated by sickness, and see what a sinful course entails in the coming world, "they will then turn Puritans in very good earnest, desiring to die such as they would never live."
He thinks the objection that people must have recreation a frivolous one, because God has in creation plentifully provided for the rational pleasure of intelligent creatures. "They have the several prospects of the sun, the moon, the planets, the stars, the water, the earth, with all the infinite variety of creatures, of fishes, birds, fowls, beasts, creeping things, trees, herbs, plants, roots, stones, and metals, that are in them, to delight their eyes."
Such are some of the flowers from Prynne's garden, which are not unworthy of attention in the present day. The Puritan combatants of two centuries and a half ago seem hardly to have been aware that a small book could be effectively written on a great subject, and hence the Histrio-Mastix has become neglected, on account of the wearisome wordiness concealing the flowers and fruits which are still there for those who will only look for them. The old author is also interesting as one of the martyrs who suffered in the cause of liberty. It is some consolation to know that the infamous sentences passed upon him were declared illegal by the Long Parliament; and that after his release from prison, the most extraordinary demonstrations in his favour were made by those who eventually put down tyranny by the sword.
