Menu
‹ Chapter 283 of 294 ›

Scepticism among Working Men

9 min read · Chapter 283 of 294

IT may be pleasantly consolatory to take pleasant views of the present condition of our industrial population, and their attitude towards the gospel; but the most profitable thing in the end will be to face the question bravely, and use all legitimate means for arriving at the truth. Adopting this course, we cannot but see that there is a disease to be cured—a disease more widely spread, and committing more ravages, than many suppose. While, however, we admit this, we have still abundant faith in the remedy. The gospel of Christ is still the power of God unto salvation; so that, after all, the disease is not so great as the remedy provided.

It is a very easy thing to draw comparisons between our industrial classes at home and the artisans of the Continent, and to arrive at conclusions favourable to ourselves; but while indulging in this vein we may unwittingly mislead. It is possibly true that when compared with the peasantry of the Continent our own cottagers of the rural districts show a favourable contrast. Having accepted the Reformation, we are in large measure free from the degradation which is the natural outcome of Romanism. We cannot tell of medieval darkness such as now reigns in Spain, where savage prejudice against the gospel still lingers in town and country. We are not aware that we ever were so low down as France, where before the Revolution, an ass and a woman were repeatedly seen yoked together to a plough, the man behind carrying a whip which he applied indifferently to either. We do not find tourists hastening away from London, as a nobleman actually did on one occasion from Rome, because he could not bear the sight of the peasantry, who seemed even to have lost the human countenance. But although we may appear to greater advantage outwardly, there is more destructive unbelief among our working people in the towns than ever before; and it is more aggressive and more thoroughly organized than was formerly the case. In all our great centres of population the infidel propaganda is systematically carrying on its crusade against the truth by means of preachers and tracts. To say emphatically, as one leading minister has lately done, that the English working classes are *not* infidel, is to show surprising want of acquaintance with known facts, especially as regards the towns. Ask any City Missionary in London whether this is the case, and he will soon show that secularist and atheistical teachers are the greatest hindrances he meets with in his work.

One of the City Missionary band, who is well acquainted with this subject, and who as a Christian teacher has repeatedly visited many of the so-called “halls of science” in London, is Mr. J. W. Morden, a friend from whom we have received information and illustration for the present paper.

On the south side of London there are several Secularist institutions, one being at Walworth and another at Camberwell. The attendants at these places are for the most part artisans, or ordinary working people; and the speakers employed are usually members of the National Secularist Society. A proportion of these teachers are literary men of some culture, and others are ambitious mechanics. They lecture on a variety of subjects, all of which are not necessarily on religious topics;

but an effort is invariably made to make the lectures tell against religion, and the passages specially prepared with that object are the parts which are most heartily cheered. It is evident that the lecturers exercise a great influence over their audiences; and if their sophistries are opposed in a feeble manner by Christians present, no counteractive impression is likely to be produced. It appears that the lecturers are usually paid for their services, although such is their native modesty that they do not desire this fact to be too widely known.

When we ask who these lecturers are, we hear of one who was originally trained for a Unitarian minister, and this painfully suggests that the dark border-land between the Socinian pulpit and the infidel platform is so narrow that it may be readily traversed. The seceder just referred to is an educated man, he has some acquaintance with ancient manuscripts and kindred subjects; but with characteristic bitterness he says many things which are intended to pander to the lowest tastes of the poor deluded people. There are other lecturers who confess that they have been through our Sunday-schools, while others have been chorister boys in fashionable churches. One or two have been even heard to boast of having gone through all the phases or processes of Christian conversion, only to find that there is nothing in it. Not knowing that spiritual things must be spiritually discerned, and that their confident teachers have never had their hearts touched by the truth, the artisan audience readily rush to the conclusion that Christianity is a hoax. It is evident that it must be so, when uneducated persons are continually hearing lectures on one side only. It is thought by some well-wishers of the working classes that more ought to be done in the way of counteraction. Scientific lectures are given which are made to tell against Christianity; why should not science be made to tell in an opposite direction?

Mr. Morden assures us that it is a curious characteristic of the class to whom we are referring, that numbers of them are remarkably fond of studying hard facts, physical science, and mechanics, with which they have to do as operatives. They contemptuously reject very much of the history contained in the Bible; and will not believe in miracles; so that it is of no use presenting to them any arguments founded on the latter. It is thought, therefore, that if, humanly speaking, such are to be brought back to faith, appeals must in the first place be based upon what they know and care about. Lectures and articles on science, social and political matters, followed by a Christian application, need to be provided to supersede, as far as possible, the lectures with an anti-Christian application, in which the people now take such delight. Very much of the working man's unbelief is founded on nothing better than misrepresentation, prejudice, and bigotry: it is even said that sentiments which would be hissed if they came from a Christian will be cheered when they come from an unbeliever.

It is interesting to notice the way in which the lecturers and the lectured regard each other. "Talk of idolizing a popular preacher," remarks Mr. Morden, "these people literally worship their leaders; these are indeed infallible. The result is an inflated self-assertion and dogmatism. Yet it is amusing to see how different they are, how much more careful to weigh their words when a Christian critic is present taking

623

notes. I have frequently heard Mr. Bradlaugh lecture on 'Jesus Christ, His Life and Teaching'; and on each occasion it struck me that while his blustering self-assertion is unequalled, yet he was personally conscious of the hollowness of his arguments, but was forced to repeat them at the bidding of his followers, and that he was pleased when all was over, and he could revert to politics again. Certainly his gauge of the mental capacities of his hearers on these occasions was not at all flattering to us; a Sir Henry Peek's prize-boy could have refuted his fair arguments easily.*

If the people think too highly of their teachers, the teachers themselves have no very exalted opinion of those who sit under them, or of those with whom they co-operate. It is felt by others than believers, that when men abandon the idea of a personal God presiding over creation, they are anything but desirable neighbours. "When men abandon this ground," says Dr. Thain Davidson, "and, carried away by the teachings of modern materialism, think of the Deity only as the great presiding force in nature, there is no longer any sound basis of morality or virtue. When that singular man, Joseph Barker, was lecturing against Christianity, he found this to be true. He says, 'Often when I came to be acquainted with the men who had invited me to lecture, I was ashamed to be seen standing with them in the streets, and I shrank from the touch of their hand as from pollution. When I saw their character,' he goes on to say, 'it went far towards convincing me that, whether religion was founded in truth or not, it was necessary to the virtue and happiness of mankind. It prepared me still further to return to Christ, and brought me a step or two nearer to his side.'" †

In conversing with Mr. Morden upon the general characteristics and difficulties of his work as a public-house missionary, he gave several illustrations which helped us to realize more vividly the sorrows of the great city wherein some ten thousand youths are said to go to the bad every year. Though not directly associated with scepticism, the first example is a very suggestive one.

A tall and very genteel-looking man was encountered at a house in Vere Street, Strand, and when addressed in a kindly tone, he put a newspaper before his face to conceal the emotion which caused him to burst into tears. "Excuse me," he said at length, ashamed of his weakness, "I was a preacher once"; and then with emphasis, in a more confidential tone, he added, "Always teach teetotalism with religion. When I was a student they always told me that if I did not drink I should never pass my examination." The missionary said, "Christ can give you a new heart"; but the mournful answer was, "Too late; I am over sixty." He then seized his umbrella to support him, as he added with more intense emotion, "All is going." Who can tell whither he will go when he once begins to go on the downward road as the slave of a bad habit?

* This extract is from Mr. Morden's pamphlet, "The Christ of the Gospels Self-evidently Divine; comprising Arguments used against Lecturers in Free Thought Hall, in South London." E. Stock, 1886. Price 6d.

† "The City Youth." By J. Thain Davidson, D.D. Hodder and Stoughton. Price 3s. 6d. A capital book to place in the hands of a young man embarking on London life.

The agents of infidelity seem to be ever on the alert, lest believers in Christ should gain an advantage unobserved. Thus, on one occasion, in a house at the West-end, the missionary entered into conversation with a young Scotchman, whose attitude was that of an enquirer. A Secularist stepped forward to take what he considered as the prey out of the missionary's hands. When he saw that his efforts were vain, he used very bad language, but this recoiled on his own head.

On another day, about a dozen workmen were encountered in a public-house. Six of the party were bitterly opposed to the gospel; they were representatives of their class, and proved how mistaken those persons are who affirm that artisans are not disposed to infidelity. The time has come when scholars in our Sunday-schools ought to be more thoroughly drilled in Scripture evidences. The leaders in our churches do not understand the situation. Working people are shrewd observers of what is done in the world. They point to the Established Church, into the ministry of which so many have entered without proper qualifications, only seeking a lucrative profession. They also notice the ways of Christian people, and some stoutly aver that professors of religion are the worst class of men with whom they have to deal. This is manifestly untrue; but it should, nevertheless, be a warning to Christians to be circumspect.

But, while the outlook is thus, in some degree, discouraging, it must not be thought that the messengers of truth work without results and without reward. Mr. Morden once talked for forty minutes in a public-house, in Long Acre, with a Secularist, whose dictatorial manner at last gave place to deference. The man's mates declared at parting, "You have done good; you have the best of the argument; but we have almost lost our dinner-hour, for our time is almost up." The arguments are frequently of the most flimsy kind; but the truth appears to be that many men have a desire to be animals, and nothing more.

The tendency to declared unbelief may not be characteristic of some of the lower parts of the town; but its place is occupied by something quite as bad. In certain quarters of Westminster, for example, the low Irish have learned to become persistent beggars; and the serious question arises, who is responsible for thus pauperizing the people in the name of charity? Talk to these people about their highest interests, and you will not be insulted with infidel replies, but you will soon perceive that they cannot meet a missionary, or speak about the gospel without asking for a ticket for something or other. It is quite as difficult to raise these mendicants from their degradation as it is to convince and win over the unbelievers.

Those who come in contact with these various classes complain that they are neglected by the Press. There are plenty of tracts, and an abundance of high-class magazines and journals, but there is not a general newspaper such as working people care to read, conducted on Christian lines. Mrs. Garnett, of the Navy Mission, has spoken about the need of such a paper; and city missionaries express a similar opinion. For a well-conducted paper, containing a full selection of the week's news, with well-written articles, there is, undoubtedly, a fine opening; and the wonder is that in an age of universal philanthropic effort such an enterprise should have been overlooked. G. H. P.

Everything we make is available for free because of a generous community of supporters.

Donate