A Batch of Moderates
I WAS sitting one day in my study, pondering the evils wrought by strong drink, when twelve gentlemen presented themselves, and said that, while they deplored the calamitous results of intemperance as much as I did, they wished to show me reasons in favour of moderate drinking, which they said was a very different practice from the excessive drinking that had brought so much evil repute upon alcoholic liquors. They hoped I would hear what they had to say for moderate drinking; and upon my signifying my willingness, the first, a Mr. Negative, stood forward, and said, with a slightly apologetic tone, "It does me no harm." This, I thought, is a good beginning; for it is certainly wrong for a man to take what injures him. I have always held that Paul's counsel to the jailer. "Do thyself no harm," was a bit of sound morality.
The second, Mr. Positive, came forward. "It does me good," he said. "I experience a general comfortable feeling after taking it;" and he rubbed his waistcoat as he spoke. "It makes me satisfied that the world is running round the right way, and I feel in good spirits." Or rather, thought I, that spirits are in you.
The third was Mr. Dyspeptic. This gentleman said, "It helps to digest my food." Poor fellow! A vivid picture rose before my mind of the specimens I had seen preserved in bottles of spirits in doctors' surgeries; and I wondered whether the alcohol he took with the idea of dissolving his food was preserving it with equal efficiency in his inside. I could not be surprised at his ill-nourished appearance.
Then the fourth spoke up. It was Mr. Craving. Said he, "I feel a dreadful sinking without it, here"—and he laid his hand upon his person with much emotion. My sinking friend, thought I, it must be dreadful to be you.
The fifth was Mr. Squeamish. "It gives me an appetite," said he; "otherwise I have no desire for breakfast, no relish for dinner, no appetite for tea.
But, with a drop of something in my coffee, and a glass of stout to dinner, you should see the difference!" I felt sorry for him, for he evidently lived by whipping himself. My horse, he seemed to say, is so weak he can't go; so I whip him! I'm afraid the whipping won't make him fat. I could have given him a recipe for want of appetite. Go without! No appetite for breakfast, my friend? Go without. Can't eat any dinner? Go without. Hardly care for tea? Go without. I'll warrant you'll relish a hot chop for supper.
Mr. Perennial Dose was the sixth; and he said very confidentially, "My doctor ordered it. I was ill ten years ago, and he told me to take a glass of port wine every day; and I have taken it faithfully and regularly ever since." "And do you still take the pills?" said I, "and the black draught?" No, he had not continued these; but he found the glass of port very beneficial, and it was the doctor's orders.
The seventh was Mr. Goodchild. He said, "My father practised it. He always had his glass as long as I can remember, and I can't do better than follow suit." Yes, thought I, his father wore a bag wig, I believe, and knee-breeches, and travelled by waggon, never sent a telegram, nor voted by ballot; and he couldn't do better than follow suit.
Then Mr. Complacent came forward. He was Number Eight. "I know when to stop," said he. "I'm not one of those who never know when they've had enough. I can take it moderately, I can." Ah! thought I: I dare say he could jump off a cliff moderately. He would know where to stop. I wish everybody was as clever as he.
The ninth was Mr. Self. "I have no notion of giving up my liberty," he said. "I've a right to take a glass, and I will not be deprived of it. I'm of the opinion of the bishop who would rather see England free than England sober." Thought I, you are a pretty long distance from the spirit of Christianity.
The name of the tenth surprised me by its length. This gentleman was Mr. Open-your-mouth-and-shut-your-eyes; and this is what he said: "It is a good creature of God, and to be received with thankfulness. What are hops for? What are grapes for? And why does fermenting sugar produce spirit?" He seemed to think these questions answered themselves. Just so, thought I. Iron is good to make knives of; but when the knife is thrust between my ribs, I am apt to think it is improperly used. Alcohol is useful to chemists and naturalists to preserve specimens, and to scientific men to make a pure flame for experiments. It may be useful for many purposes. It does not follow that it is rightly employed when poured down men's throats.
Mr. Scripture-shelter, the eleventh, now came forward. "Scripture sanctions it," said he. "The Psalmist speaks of wine which maketh glad the heart of man. The Saviour made wine at Cana, you know; and Timothy was told by the apostle to take a little wine for his stomach's sake." Yes, thought I, Timothy's medicine must become all men's drink. I have also read in Scripture, "Woe to them that are mighty to drink wine!" "Look not upon the wine; it stingeth like an adder." The wine Jesus made was of a sort that had not produced intoxication, though the guests had already "well drunk" of some like it; and the apostle who recommended medicine to Timothy enunciated a great Christian principle in the words, "It is good neither to eat flesh, nor to drink wine, nor anything whereby thy brother stumbleth, or is offended, or is made weak."
My thoughts were interrupted by the voice of the twelfth gentleman. It was Mr. Honest. "I like it!" said he, and smacked his lips. This was all he said. It was a clincher! I thought his argument the soundest of the dozen; but I was sorry that he had got to like it. I did not feel quite comfortable about him, and I believe his friends are of opinion that he sometimes goes a little beyond the mark.
The gentlemen having thus delivered their minds, took their departure, leaving me, on the whole, unconvinced of the virtues of moderate drinking.
C. A. DAVIS.
