Menu
‹ Chapter 87 of 294 ›

Compulsory Tithes — By Pastor W. M. Hawkins, Hundon, Clare, Suffolk

8 min read · Chapter 87 of 294

WHEN the people of England study the tithe question, they will be prepared to deal with tithe-payments in a just and equitable manner. The nation will be relieved of a great burden and a gross injustice; and religion will be freed from heavy, although golden, fetters.

What is the origin of tithe-payments in England? If we get a clear idea of their origin, we shall carry a light in our hand all the time we explore the subject. Compulsory tithe-payments were not commanded by the Head of the Christian church. He said nothing about them. Compulsory tithes were not commanded or sanctioned by the apostles, or early teachers of Christianity; they had another and a better method of meeting all their temporal needs. The early Christians never sought help from the sheriff's officers. Paul laid down the law in 1 Cor. xvi. 2: "Upon the first day of the week, let every one of you lay by him in store as God hath prospered him." Also in 2 Cor. ix. 7: "Every man according as he purposeth in his heart, so let him give; not grudgingly or of necessity: for God loveth a cheerful giver." The apostle had in the previous verse said, "He that soweth sparingly shall reap also sparingly; and he that soweth bountifully shall reap also bountifully." "Even so hath the Lord ordained that they which preach the gospel should live of the gospel:" 1 Cor. ix. 14. Our Lord himself taught, in Luke x. 7, that "the labourer is worthy of his hire."

Church historians and ecclesiastical lawyers tell us that the early Christians cheerfully practised this voluntary and proportionate style of giving, and that no other method was needed. The Rev. R. Burn, LL.D., Chancellor of the Diocese of Carlisle, and Vicar of Orton, in Westmoreland, in his "Ecclesiastical Law," second edition, published in 1767, says: "What was paid to the church, for several of the first ages after Christ, was all brought to them by way of offerings; and these were made at the altar, or at the collections, or else occasionally." "Afterwards, about the year 794, Offa, King of Mercia (the most potent of all the Saxons of his time in this island) made a law, whereby he gave unto the church the tithes of all his kingdom; which the historians tell us was done to expiate the death of Ethelbert, King of the East Angles, whom, in the year preceding, he had caused basely to be murdered."

"But that tithes were before paid in England, by way of offerings, according to the ancient usage and decrees of the church, appears from the canons of Egbert, Archbishop of York, about 750 A.D., and from an epistle of Boniface, Archbishop of Mentz, which he wrote to Cuthbert, Archbishop of Canterbury, about the same time; and from the seventeenth canon of the general council, held for the whole kingdom at Chalchuth (Chelsea) in the year 787."

"But this law of Offa was that which first gave the Church a civil right in them in this land, by way of property and inheritance, and enabled the clergy to gather and recover them as their legal due, by the coercion of the civil power. Yet the establishment of Offa reached no further than to the Kingdom of Mercia, over which Offa reigned, until Ethelwulf, about sixty years after, enlarged it for the whole realm."—Dr. Burn's "Ecclesiastical Law," vol. iii. p. 347.

Dr. Burn refers to a valuable work on tithes, written by Dr. Prideaux, Dean of Norwich, pp. 139, 165, 167. It appears that Offa invited Ethelbert to his court, with the view of giving his daughter to him in marriage; but instead of doing so, he caused Ethelbert to be put to death, and then seized his kingdom. The bishops, priests, and deacons, assisted by cardinals, improved the event by working on his fears and his guilty conscience, threatening him with eternal sufferings, unless he passed the law they had long clamoured for—to make tithe-payments compulsory.

Dean Prideaux took great interest in tithes, and is deservedly regarded as a great authority on the subject by church people. He was a devoted

185

Churchman. In a considerable treatise, published in 1707, urging the propriety and justice of demanding ten per cent. as tithe-payments on house-rents in cities and towns, we find the following remarks against all who were not of the Church of England: "For now, they being at full liberty to set open their shops of faction and schism in what place they please, to be sure they will especially do so where they are likely to have the best trade, that is in the cities and larger towns, &c." (See p. 54, "Vindication of an award of King Charles I., setting two shillings of the pound out of rents of houses in Norwich, for the maintenance of the parochial clergy of that city, in lieu of personal tithes.") I mention this to indicate that the Dean is not likely to write anything in favour of any sect but his own. In the year 1710 he published a work on "Tithes: their origin in public law." In chapter iii. he says, "The primitive Christians being without any law from the State to provide for the support of God's worship in the maintenance of those who ministered in it, each became a law unto themselves, and freely gave of their own accord what abundantly answered the end intended." "For the first ages of the Church I confess we find no mention of tithes, because the zeal of Christians was such that they gave more in their voluntary offerings than the tithes could amount to. So that, out of them (voluntary offerings) there was not only a sufficiency for the ministers, but over and above, a large portion for the maintenance of the poor also. And thus, till towards the fourth age of the Church, all the necessities of it were fully answered by the voluntary offerings of the faithful, and what was given by them this way, as it much exceeded a tenth of their income, so did it more than suffice, not only for the ministers, but for all other occasions also."

In these extracts from Dr. Prideaux, we have two most important facts clearly proved by a strong Churchman.

1st. That ample provision was made for all church purposes without compulsory tithes or rates of any kind. Church purposes include buildings, incidental expenses, maintenance of the ministry, missionary enterprise, education, and the relief of the poor. For three centuries Christian people successfully witnessed for Christ, laid deep the walls and ramparts of the Christian religion in many lands against the most fierce opposition, and met all the costs without a penny except from voluntary offerings. They proved to a demonstration the practicability and efficiency of the voluntary system. The people gave as God had prospered them, and of a willing mind. They gave it "not unto men, but unto God." They gave it "for Christ's sake."

2. During those early and prosperous ages of Christianity the Master's dictum, "My kingdom is not of this world," was regarded and received as law. The Church and the State were two. They were distinct and separate. The Church was governed and in all respects sustained by people who loved the Saviour—such people only constitute the true Church. No Sheriff's officer seized people's goods to support religion. The Church had not been united to the State—that is, it had not been established in a national, official, and legal sense. Neither had the people who loved and followed the Saviour been united into one society, or into large bodies, but each little company of disciples constituted a Church. The pastor was called the Bishop. We read in the Epistle to Philemon, "Paul . . . unto Philemon . . . and to the Church in thine house," &c. Each company of believers was a Church.

The Rev. G. Townsend, D.D., Canon of Durham, in his Ecclesiastical and Civil History, Vol. I., pp. 178 and 180, says:—"The independence of the Churches of each other while they maintained the union both of doctrine and of discipline, is shown by the general absence in the first three centuries of any act of authority on the part of any bishop by assuming the office of ecclesiastical superior over another Church." . . . "All Churches, in truth, were independent of any external superior." . . . "Church was independent of Church before the Christianity of the Empire was protected and established by the civil power."

13

During all the time that the Churches were free from State patronage and State control—self-sustaining and self-governing—they had more than sufficient income to supply all their wants. The income in each case arose from free offerings. These Free Churches, as they were called—and they were free from the State—voluntarily supplied more than enough funds for all purposes, and always had money in hand.

These important facts we have on the testimony of Dean Prideaux, the Rev. R. Burn, LL.D., Chancellor of the diocese of Carlisle, Father Paul, author of the "Complete History of Ecclesiastical Revenues," dedicated to the Bishop of Durham, A.D. 1730; Father Simon, A.D. 1683, "The History of the Original and Progress of Ecclesiastical Revenues"; and many other authors and historians.

Father Simon says, p. 5: "At that time the ministers of the Church had no other revenues but what they gathered from the charity (love) of believers; for as to the tithes, firstfruits, and other rights that belonged to the Levites and Priests, they were abolished with the sacrifice. Our Saviour having instituted a new form of ministry, appointed also a new way of providing for the necessities of the new ministers. He received the alms that were given him, and put them into the custody of a steward, to be distributed according as need did require. St. Paul, who often speaks in his Epistles of the duty of ministers towards the people, and of the people towards their ministers, says no more, but conform to the words of our Saviour, that they who preach the Gospel should also live by the Gospel, and that they who serve at the altar should participate of that which is offered upon the altar, thereby alluding to the offerings of the Old Testament; he never makes mention of tithes, nor of those dues that were given to the priests, because he supposes that that priesthood being abolished, the rights that from thence accrued to the priests ought likewise to be abrogated. And therefore the primitive Christians, who sold their estates for the relief of the poor and maintenance of the ministers, thought it not sufficient to bestow the tenth part, but freely gave all that was necessary, knowing that the rights of tithes and firstfruits were but only ceremonies and customs of the Old Testament, of which they retained no more but what concerned morality. So that love was the rule of what they were to give to the ministers of the Gospel."

Father Paul confirms this, and gives additional facts. Speaking of deacons who had the management of the temporal affairs of the Churches, he says, on p. 6: "And this order of admitting none to any ecclesiastical function but by election of all the faithful in a general assembly, was inviolably observed, and so continued for about 200 years; the ministers of the Church and the poor subsisting all the while out of the common stock, which had no other fund than the offerings of the faithful at their devotions. But they were so abundant that the charity of those times had no other bounds than what every one could spare from his necessities. So that when the abilities of one city were more than sufficient to supply the necessities of its own Church, collections were there made for other Churches that were poor. At Rome, where the greatest wealth abounded, the offerings indeed were so large that about the year 150 they served not only to maintain the Clergy and the poor Christians of the city, but to contribute largely to the neighbouring and more remote Churches, as well as to the relief of great numbers of Christian captives in the several provinces, and to such as were condemned to the mines."

Here we have proof of self-supporting, self-governing Churches, and associations of these Churches, with their Sustentation Fund and Home Missionary Society.

Everything we make is available for free because of a generous community of supporters.

Donate