Andover Theology — By The Writer Of "The Down Grade."
THE trial of the Professors of the Andover Theological Seminary, Andover, Massachusetts, has been attended by a great deal that is deeply interesting and immensely important, involving, as the matters under debate do, momentous issues.
It may be stated, in brief, that Andover Theological Seminary is an ancient institution—ancient, at least, for America—founded for the training of young men for the Congregational ministry. Its founders were sound Calvinists of the Cotton Mather type, and the College was instituted for the special purpose of training men in that faith. Accordingly, in connection with the institution and its endowments, there is a clear and definite statement of the doctrines which are to be taught, maintained, and propagated. To these doctrines the various professors are required to subscribe. It has come to pass, however, that the five gentlemen who now fill professorial chairs, articles of faith and subscription notwithstanding, have seriously departed from the faith of the founders. This has been manifest, not only in the tone and character of their divinity lectures, and the too palpable heterodoxy of some of the students, but in the articles published in the Andover Review, contributed by the professors. They do not, however, openly assail the creed of the founders to which they have subscribed, and for the teaching of which they have received their emoluments. They show unto us, as they suppose, "a more excellent way." The new theology is produced by some kind of evolution from the old; and hence it is called "Progressive Orthodoxy." This term may prove misleading. The unwary may conclude that its promoters are closely in sympathy with orthodox belief, and that their teaching in relation to the creed of the founders is really the same thing under another name. But a careful consideration of the points in dispute, and a candid comparison of the new with the old, will lead to a far different conclusion. The progressiveness of the professors seems to be like that of the preacher whose two divisions of his subject were: "First, my brethren, I shall go right round the text; and, secondly, my friends, I shall go right away from it." Indeed, the progression is so considerable that the "orthodoxy" is lost sight of. It may be remarked that there are two kinds of progression in nature—that of life, resulting in a thing of beauty and of joy; and that of death, of which a butcher's shop in very hot weather sometimes furnishes an example. There are similar processes in theology. Gold, we know, is the most malleable of metals. It may be beaten out into very thin plates, drawn into very fine wire, and even reduced to an impalpable dust; but it never becomes iron, or tin, or brass by the process. The plates, however thin, are gold plates; the wire, however fine, is gold wire; and the dust, however extreme the attenuation, is gold dust still. Some amount of beating, and drawing, and attenuation is needful in the inculcation of the great truths of the gospel, especially in the case of some congregations, and certain preachers and orators achieve wonderful success in this direction—like an amateur gardener whom I knew, who grew fine onions, so fine, he said, that he could hardly see them. But the men who hammer thin gold to the thinnest, and draw their wire to the finest, never come within sight of these
275
Andover professors in their achievements, who, in the extreme progressiveness of their "orthodoxy," come near to fulfilling the Scripture in a novel sense: "Old things are passed away; behold, all things have become new."
The trial took place at the United States Hotel, Boston, commencing 28th December, 1886, and extending over several days. It is testified by several witnesses—for the trial was a public one—that the proceedings were conducted in such a manner, and that all parties concerned conducted themselves in such a becoming spirit, as reflected great credit on all engaged therein. First of all, after the proceedings had been opened by Professor Dwight, of New York, the several professors stated at length their whole case, which occupied the chief part of three days, when Judge Asa French opened the arguments for the prosecution. From his statement, and the statements of Dr. Wellman, who followed him, the whole question at issue may be seen. Judge French said:—
"The question is now, not what these gentlemen would have the creed to be, or how they would have drawn it, but what was the intent of the founders, and what did they mean when they declared that nothing should be taken from it? The question is simple: Do these men hold the doctrines laid down in that creed, or do they depart from them in ever so slight a degree?"
This is a shorter cut, and a truer aim, than lawyers in general take.
The question of the orthodoxy or otherwise of the professors was not the chief question; it was subordinate, for all practical purposes, to this other: Is their theology in harmony with, or opposed to, the articles of the creed laid down by the founders of the Seminary? or, in other words, is their teaching, denominated "progressive orthodoxy," what the founders of the Seminary willed to have taught, and what the professors engaged to teach? It needs but little penetration to see that the divergence is very general and very great, and that on the most vital points it is the most remote from the old theology, the creed of the founders.
Let us enumerate some of these points.
As is usual in all cases of departure from orthodox belief, the professors are at variance with the creed of the Seminary and the general belief of orthodox Christians, on the subject of inspiration. Their sentiments on this subject are boldly expressed, and with as much subtlety as daring. We have heard the same sentiments avowed from a Congregational pulpit in this country by a young man at his ordination. Sad as this was, and it went to the heart of the writer, it was even sadder that neither the venerable professor who gave the charge, nor any of the other ministers engaged—some of them venerable, too—uttered a single word of protest or regret, or asked for any explanation or qualification of the statements made.
It was alleged against the Andover professors that they held the Bible to be fallible, not only in matters of science and chronology, but in some of its religious teachings also. According to their notion the writers of the Bible were inspired, but only in the sense in which men are inspired now. The Scriptures are not, therefore, a true or infallible standard of faith. The Scriptures sprang out of the religious consciousness of the writers, and they must be interpreted by the religious consciousness of the readers. God's word is not a revelation, but a vehicle
of revelation. Thus we are taught by the professors that the words as uttered by the prophets do not necessarily carry with them the authority of infallible truth. It is written—and David wrote out of his inner consciousness as well as by divine inspiration—“Thy word is true from the beginning: and every one of thy righteous judgments endureth for ever.” But for all that, it is not true, only as it is formulated, shaped, and fashioned by some advocate of “progressive orthodoxy.”
The written Andover Creed states, in accordance with the terms of the Westminster Confession and the Assembly’s Shorter Catechism, that the Word of God is infallible, and of paramount authority in all matters of faith and practice. This is very different from what the present professors would write.
Dr. Wellman stated concerning the professors that their views “dishonour and depreciate the Holy Scriptures. They violently antagonize the old Andover creed in various ways, but especially in that they erect a standard of truth and faith equal or superior to that of the Holy Scriptures, and render it impossible that the Bible should be, as the creed states, “the only perfect rule of faith and practice.” They are repugnant to Article II. of the statutes of the Associate Foundation, which says that every professor shall be an orthodox and consistent Calvinist, and it is impossible for one to be a man of sound and orthodox principles in divinity within the meaning of the statutes who holds the views set forth in “Progressive Orthodoxy.”
These views are by no means novel; they pervade a vast deal of German theology, and have been taught by men of the Maurice and Kingsley school in this country. They find favour in the columns of our cotemporary, “The Christian World,” where the Andover professors find sympathy, and are regarded rather as being sinned against than sinning. But this is by no means surprising. “Like loves its like,” as the proverb says. We expect, however, that it will be found true after all, that God’s commandments are sure; and that his words are “pure words: as silver tried in a furnace of earth, seven times purified.”
Another departure from the orthodox faith, as alleged against the professors is, concerning the Person of Christ. They teach that the humanity of Christ so limited his faculties that he was fallible, or not omniscient, and hence not perfect God and man, as the creed of the founders teaches, and as evangelical Christians believe. This, to say the very least, is dangerous ground, and argues a mind already greatly warped and corrupted from “the simplicity that is in Christ.” To hold and teach such fundamental errors is bad enough, but to make them the outcome of the teaching of Calvinism, and the proper expansion of the doctrine of the old creed, is even worse. But then it comes from the infallible “religious consciousness” which is to stamp every vagary of man’s disordered fancy as true, and put its mint-mark on all the speculations of those who have never become fools that they may be wise.
As the professors have departed from the form of sound words as to the Person of Christ, so in relation to his work they have progressed beyond “the faith once for all delivered unto the saints.” The atonement of Christ, according to these gentlemen, consists not in his vicarious sufferings and death, whereby he bought his redeemed ones with the price of his own blood, and presented an offering infinite in
277
its efficacy, and boundless in its merit, but in his assumption of human nature and his holy life. By his assumption of human nature he takes the whole human family into union with himself, making all men salvable, and giving them power to repent. Thus, by this "progressive orthodoxy" the sufferings of Christ to satisfy the claims of divine justice are practically ignored, and such passages as, "We have redemption by his blood, the forgiveness of sin, according to the riches of his grace," lose their light and glory, or are lost in the depths of man's "religious consciousness."
Sound Calvinism, as taught in the creed of the Andover Seminary, makes provision for the application of the blessings of redemption in the sense of our Lord's words, "All that the Father giveth me shall come to me." Hence the Person, work, teaching, and influence of the Holy Spirit have a prominent place in orthodox belief. In the "progressive orthodoxy" of the Andover professors this is lost sight of, and the drawings of divine grace are left out of the question. According to this scheme, man has the power to repent, but his heart remains hard. He is united to Christ, in common with the whole of humanity; but there is no life, no attractive power, and he continues alienated. His crimes have been somehow atoned for by Christ's holy life; but he is still far off by wicked works, a lover of pleasure more than a lover of God, and the promise of Christ to his disciples, "Because I live, ye shall live also," is a dead letter. The gospel would be a poor gospel, or rather, no gospel at all, if these things were so. It may be well, therefore, to recall the words which the apostle Paul wrote to the church at Galatia—words which were not merely evolved from his inner consciousness, but which were dictated by the Holy Spirit. It may be well, too, for all who sympathize with the views of the said professors, or who may be disposed to look upon their aberrations from the doctrinal formula they have subscribed as harmless, or as matters of quite secondary importance, to ponder the apostle's words, which, on account of their great pertinence, we quote in full:—
"I marvel that ye are so soon removed from him that called you into the grace of Christ unto another gospel: which is not another; but there be some that trouble you, and would pervert the gospel of Christ. But though we, or an angel from heaven, preach any other gospel unto you than that which we have preached unto you, let him be accursed. As we said before, so say I now again, If any man preach any other gospel unto you than that ye have received, let him be accursed." "A very uncharitable imprecation," some would say; and we should join them in saying so, if Paul had no higher authority than his inner consciousness; indeed, unless he had the infallible authority of One who cannot err, and who is infinitely above all the passions which may actuate the human mind and guide the pen of even the most holy among the children of men. And it was under the authority and direct influence of God that he wrote, "I certify you, brethren, that the gospel which was preached of me is not after man. For I neither received it of man, neither was I taught it, but by the revelation of Jesus Christ." Thus spake the man of God, whom God moved to write the Epistles to the Romans, Ephesians, &c., whence in part Calvinists draw their doctrinal statements.
Another very serious charge brought against the professors is, that
they hold that men who have not heard of Christ are not sinners, or are not sinners so as to be exposed to perdition. One, at least, of them denies this conclusion; but this is the legitimate inference to be drawn from their statements. The natural depravity of man, his loss of original righteousness, and his consequent exposure to eternal misery, are all either denied or ignored; so that, according to these conclusions, there is no such thing as original sin, and Paul was seriously wrong and off the line when he said, "Wherefore, as by one man sin entered into the world, and death by sin; and so death passed upon all men, for that all have sinned." The simple-minded people, who are not philosophical in their tendencies, who are not advanced thinkers, and who have not been perverted from the truth to accept human speculations as veritable gospel, will, perhaps, be ready to respond to Paul's vehement words, which may well sum up the dispute, "Let God be true, but every man a liar."
Another heresy charged upon the professors—and it is a chief point of the departure from the lines of revealed truth, and the creed of the Seminary—is the notion of a second probation. "Men who have never had Christ offered to them in this life, will meet his gracious face in the mercy of a future state. Their choice then will fix their doom for ever." The defence the men set up for teaching this sentiment is, not that there is anything in the creed for it, but that there is nothing against it, and that the framers of the creed, were they now living in this day of greater light, advanced thought, and "progressive orthodoxy," might possibly include it. It must be a poor case that stands in need of such a sorry argument. What wrong might not be proved right, what evil might not be made to appear good, upon such a principle? The process of their reasoning seems to be widely different from the straightforward methods which Paul so highly commends. We "have renounced the hidden things of dishonesty, not walking in craftiness, nor handling the Word of God deceitfully; but by manifestation of the truth, commending ourselves to every man's conscience in the sight of God."
Thus we have given a brief statement of the case of the accused professors, and of their wide departure from the orthodox belief of the founders. To call their sentiments "advanced orthodoxy" is a misnomer. They have little, if any, relation to orthodoxy, except as they controvert its teachings. It is the same case again of the water being added to the wine, until the liquor is no longer wine at all, or only so in imagination.
It will be seen that the points of departure affect nearly all the vital truths of the gospel. Original sin is denied or ignored; the Person and offices of Christ are greatly shorn of their glory, though there is a strange setting forth of his worth and love. The three R's are nowhere. The Person and offices of the Holy Spirit are somehow dispensed with. The "blood of the eternal covenant"—the blood that redeems from death and hell unto God, and imparts its constant cleansing to all who walk in fellowship with God through Christ—is a matter of very secondary importance. The grand old doctrine, so beautifully emblemized by Christ in his parting discourse to his disciples, "I am the vine, ye are the branches," is a mistake or a dream. All the grand
279
and beautiful imagery by which the Holy Spirit, in guiding Paul's pen, set forth the actual living oneness of Christ and his church—the Head and the body, the Foundation and the house, the Shepherd and the sheep—are, practically, so many myths. In fact, so far as regards the Christ of the epistles, the whole family of the Saviour might weep and sigh with Mary, "They have taken away my Lord, and I know not where they have laid him." If such sentiments, such negations of the truth, are to be the gospel of the day, then we say, "Alas! alas! The glory is departed from Israel!" But this cannot well be. "The foundation of God standeth sure, having this seal, the Lord knoweth them that are his." This is not the first time that the truth of God has been assailed. Alas! many and many a time men have gone out as with the high authority of the church's sanction, "speaking perverse things, to draw away disciples after them." But the gospel of God is the gospel of power, while the gospel of heresy is the gospel of weakness.
The truth of man's fallen and lost condition underlies all aggressive theology and all Christian activity, Paul's teaching in his day was in keeping with the teaching of the prophets: "O Israel, thou hast destroyed thyself; but in me is thine help." Sin and utter misery and ruin in man's case, grace and sovereign mercy through Christ, on God's part, were the themes everywhere of Paul. Augustine, Calvin, and Luther taught the same. And it is this teaching which has done for the world what has thus far been achieved by Christianity. The living hymnody of the Church in all ages embodies the same facts: Greek, Latin, German, English, French, Swiss and American, all unite their voices. The theology of Paul was the theology of the Puritans, and the theology of the Puritans did much to build the American people into a great nation. The Pilgrim Fathers were all men of this right noble mould, and would as soon have thought of questioning their right to live and be free as to entertain for a single moment a doubt of the inspiration of the Word of God.
The roots of all evangelical preaching strike deep down into the truths of man's sin and ruin and of the grace of God in Christ to sinners deserving eternal wrath. The mighty men of old, the men of renown in all ages, the captains and leaders of the "Sacramental host of God's elect" in all lands, have ever been men who were strong and steadfast in all those truths which relate to the perfection of the Scriptures, the person and work of the Redeemer, and of salvation through faith in his name. Beyond the Word they would not go, and short of the Word they would not stop. Christ in his mediation, his substitution, his redeeming death and his glorious resurrection, was ever the centre of their life, the foundation of their faith, the theme of their faithful testimony. To him they all bore witness. Search the history of religious revivals, and you will find that wherever real revivals have been experienced, they have been in connection with evangelical preaching, more or less sound and thorough. Look at the work of Luther and others in Germany, at the work of Zwingle in Switzerland, at the work of Calvin in France, and at the work of the Puritans in England. Mark the career of President Edwards, of George Whitefield, of the founders of Welsh Methodism, of the Haldanes in
Scotland, of Robert Haldane at Geneva, of the late Dr. Malan in Geneva, of the Erskines and Bostons and such like in Scotland, and the most successful soul-winners in England, and you will find them to a man sound on the inspiration of Holy Scripture. The Wesleyan Methodists of all parties are sound on that question. And whatever "down grade" tendency there may be in their Arminian theology, faith in the inspiration of the Word of God and in the atoning work of the Lamb checks all downward progress. Shall we forsake the faith of our fathers? Shall we give place by subjection to fundamental error dressed in the guise of "Progressive Orthodoxy"? No, not for an hour. That were to put out the fire of evangelical zeal, to quench the altar flames of love to Christ, and to undermine the very foundation of all that is stable and strong and true in religion. "No man having tasted old wine straightway desireth new; for he saith, The old is better."
