Dr. W. Lindsay Alexander's Experience of the Organ
ON the 23rd October, 1863, a new organ, built for the church, and presented by William M'Murray, Esq., London, was inaugurated at a large meeting held in the church. In the course of the proceedings Dr. Alexander gave an interesting account of the movement in his church in favour of instrumental music as an aid to worship. For nearly twenty years he had advocated the introduction of an organ into the church. He had been moved to this, he said, not by any desire for fine music on its own account; for, whatever pleasure he derived from it, the love of music had never been a passion with him, but from a deep conviction that the great end of congregational worship was thereby more effectually and fully secured. When he first began to speak to his congregation on this subject, there were some who decidedly objected to the practice he wished to introduce. He respected their scruples, and took no active steps to gain his end, trusting, as he said, to reflection and argument gradually to win over to his side those who doubted or objected.
The attention given to psalmody had for many years been a special feature in the congregational worship in the old Argyle Square Chapel. The singing of the congregation had attained a remarkable degree of excellence. Indeed, it ultimately reached the distinction of being "the best sung congregation"—a rather singular expression—"in Edinburgh." It was the singing of the congregation, rather than of the choir alone (as not unfrequently happens), that procured the distinction. The expression given to particular passages in the hymns was much marked. One instance is well remembered. The last verse of "Rock of Ages"—
"While I draw this fleeting breath,
When my eyelids close in death,"—
was sung so softly, yet by all the congregation, that it was known to draw tears from a stranger who was not prepared for it—followed by the relief of pent-up feeling which found utterance in the refrain
"Rock of Ages, cleft for me,
Let me hide myself in thee!"
A lady from a distance, who found her way to Augustine Church shortly after it was opened, arriving too soon, had some conversation with the door-keeper about "the old place," and how she was moved by the singing of these words. He, rather gleefully, informed her that they were soon to have an organ.* "I am sorry to hear it," she said; "I am afraid there will not be much chance of my being moved then." And so, it must be confessed, it proved. The result seemed to confirm the belief of many who have given attention to the subject, that where the conduct of praise without an instrument is already excellent, the singing being with voice, heart, and understanding, the introduction of an organ, however lawful, is of more than doubtful expediency. The fear expressed by the stranger was, in the opinion of many, fully justified. They had great doubts as to whether the introduction of an organ proved of real
* The only instrument of the kind which many a Scotsman had heard was the barrel-organ (often accompanied by a monkey!) used by itinerant musicians. Of this Dr. Alexander once gave an amusing illustration. Walking along Princes Street, he was attracted by a child looking up in his face with a rather puzzled expression. The boy's nurse had gone aside to look at a window, and he, not observing she had done so, walked on, and suddenly finding himself by the side of a stranger, was somewhat perplexed. The Doctor's kindly nature spoke out, and he said, "Well, my little fellow, what's your name?" "Arnot," was the reply, "and my papa has got a new church!" [Free High Church]. "So have I. Has your papa's church an organ?" "No," said the boy. "Oh, but mine has," said the Doctor. The boy looked up quite interested, and cried out, "And has the organ got a puggy too?"—From "Life of Dr. Alexander."
advantage in worship. The mingling of its tones with the voices of the people seemed to lessen the impressive effect produced by the singing of the congregation led by a well-trained choir. Many who recollected the former days, before the organ was introduced, would not have been sorry had the organ, to use the church-officer's words, "given up the ghaist" altogether. This appears to have been Dr. Alexander's own opinion, for he more than once expressed the pleasure he felt when, on one or two occasions when the organ was silent, the voice of praise from the congregation, without instrumental aid, was heard as of old.
