Menu
‹ Chapter 241 of 288 ›

Liberty, not License — By "The Author Of The First Down-Grade Papers."

17 min read · Chapter 241 of 288

WHEN Madame Roland ascended the scaffold for execution, 8th November, 1793, during the reign of terror in France, looking round upon the scene, she exclaimed: "O Liberty! what crimes have been committed in thy name!" The words recurred to us as we read a recent pamphlet, entitled, "The Liberty of the Pulpit," and we could but mentally exclaim, "O Liberty! what treasonable words have been spoken in thy name!"

The theme of this pamphlet falls somewhat in line with the subject of this paper, previously projected; but we are otherwise unwilling to dwell, either on its details or general characteristics, so full of crudities from beginning to end; having a show, but no force of argument; with such trampling under feet of sacred verities, such a trumpeting forth of the praises of so-called liberty, and such depreciation of honest, faithful contention for the faith once for all delivered to the saints, that we are forcibly reminded of the bold and striking comparison which God employs in relation to revolting Israel: "Thou art a swift dromedary traversing her ways; a wild ass used to the wilderness, that snuffeth up the wind at her pleasure."

The pamphlet professes to be a plea for liberty in general, and, in particular, for freedom to propagate all the vagaries of "modern thought," and especially in the direction of Universalism.

The style of the writer is rather turgid, and sometimes boisterous; and his language is frequently misleading, as well known Scripture terms and phrases are used in other than their commonly accepted sense; and while the whole deliverance is avowedly an assertion of loyalty to Christ, to the careful reader, taught in the things of God, the entire performance will appear fraught with disloyalty to Christ, and with the very essence of rebellion against the rights, the claims, the honour of Jesus our Saviour and King.

The writer proceeds upon the lines of two opinions; the one is stated, the other is implied. The former hypothesis is the Universal Fatherhood of God, "the antithesis," the writer says, "of the old starting-point in the conception of God"; the latter is that, in addition to, and even apart from, the revelation of God in his Word, God is now, from time to time, revealing himself and his will in new forms and features to the minds and hearts of believers, especially to his servants the ministers of the gospel. These new revelations, or communications to the "inner consciousness," are claimed to be truth, and to be as a rule of faith, and everyone who receives them, it is claimed, should be at liberty to proclaim them, whether they comport with other revelations or not.

The nature of the Universal Fatherhood of God generally enters into, and is commonly the starting-point of, all the many various theories to which "modern thought," or, in plainer words, "rationalistic speculations," have given birth. Growing out of this one unscriptural sentiment have

549

arisen all the different speculations concerning the future state of the finally impenitent and ungodly: annihilation, post-mortem salvation, universal restoration.

That God, as Creator, is the Father of all men, is a truth no one can question; and that he extends his pity and compassion to all the souls that he has made, will also be admitted; but the Fatherhood in which he reveals himself, in which Christ reveals him, and in which the gospel makes him known, is something higher, grander, and more glorious. It is a Fatherhood, not of nature, but of grace; a Fatherhood embracing, not all the human race, but all that he has chosen to salvation; all that he has given to Christ; all who have been predestinated to the adoption of children by Jesus Christ to himself, according to the good pleasure of his will; all whose names are written in heaven, in the Lamb's book of life.

Innumerable have been the objections raised against this truth of God's Holy Word, and many have fought, and do fight, against it; but, like a mountain of brass, it stands firm and sure. "The Lord knoweth them that are his." They are his in a sense in which none other are his; he forms them for himself; they are his sheep—his own in a very high and holy and precious sense; he loves them with an everlasting love; Christ is their chosen head and representative; he loved them and gave himself for them; God has committed them to his care, and he will so keep them that they shall never perish.

If all these things are true of all the sons and daughters of Adam, then the theory of the Universal Fatherhood of God in a way of grace is true; but these things are not true of vast multitudes in every age, even where the gospel is preached and the Bible is circulated; they will not come unto Christ that they might have life; and yet Christ says, "All that the Father giveth to me shall come to me"; therefore, if they do not come, it is plain they were not given to Christ, and the idea of the Universal Fatherhood of God as the God of grace is not true.

The other sentiment, namely, that God makes revelations of himself and of his will to the minds and hearts of his servants other than, and in addition to, what he has caused to be written of his Holy Word, is alike untrue; it is contrary to the plain statements of God's Word, and out of harmony with the teachings of Jesus Christ and the plan and provision of the gospel, in which, in these last days, God has spoken to us by his Son.

The writer of the pamphlet claims "liberty" to propagate freely, in the pulpits of the Baptist denomination, at least, all those new-fangled ideas, novel sentiments, and false imaginings, which he supposes, indeed, believes, God reveals from time to time to ministers and others. No doubt he believes in these new revelations or inspirations, and so, no doubt, Edward Irving believed in his rhapsodical effusions, and that he had the gift of tongues, and such like; and in like manner, without doubt, Baron Swedenborg believed in the visions and revelations which he declared he had received. Fanaticism, indeed, has no bounds. But no man understands the liberty with which Christ makes his own free who speaks or writes as this man does.

As a man and a citizen, no doubt, one may write or teach what he pleases, so far as man is concerned, so long as he does not contravene righteous authority and just laws, endanger public morals, or blaspheme God; but when a man enters the sphere of revealed religion, and especially when he assumes the position of a teacher, a preacher, or a minister of God, he is not at liberty to teach and preach what he may happen to believe, unless his belief and his teaching are in harmony with the plainly revealed will of God, as made known in his Word and by his Son, who is Prophet, as well as Priest and King in Zion. A man ought to believe what he teaches; but, first of all, his belief must square with the Divine testimony, or his belief will be hurtful to himself and damaging to others. The eternal principles

of right and truth are the bounds within which liberty may be exercised. To go beyond these is to exercise, not liberty but license. To go against these is lawlessness.

Right is the bound of liberty to the citizen; truth the bound of liberty to the Christian and to the minister of the gospel, both in believing and teaching. To go beyond these is license, and to go against them, lawlessness. To depose Charles I. was within the rights of the subjects of the kingdom of Great Britain, for the king had contravened the laws of the kingdom in accordance with which he had sworn to rule. But when the Southern States of the American Republic sought to establish a Confederacy, making slavery its corner-stone, their act was lawlessness and rebellion, for it was in accordance with no acknowledged right or just law of man, and contrary to the law of God—the eternal law of “Thou shalt love thy neighbour as thyself.” The eternal law of right is the law of all, ruler and ruled alike, in the political world; and the eternal law of truth is the rule in relation to God’s claims of us and our obedience to him in the moral world. A strange world this would be if a man’s conceptions of what is right were to be his rule of action; that is, if he were to be a law unto himself. There would be as many laws as men, and no end of confusion and disaster and contention, resulting only in misery and ruin. So in the moral world, and in the kingdom of our Lord Jesus Christ. The rule is, not each man’s “inner consciousness,” each man’s idea or conception of what is right, but God’s own truth, which he has made the unalterable law of his kingdom.

When our blessed Lord speaks of the freedom with which he makes his own free, he takes us back to the foundation principles of his kingdom, which are also the foundations of all gospel liberty—eternal truth. “Then said Jesus to those Jews which believed on him, If ye continue in my word, then are ye my disciples indeed; and ye shall know the truth, and the truth shall make you free.” Certainly, as Cowper says,

“He is the freeman whom the truth makes free,

And all are slaves besides.”

But how can we attain to a knowledge and possession of the truth? The answer is here at hand, very positive and very emphatic—by continuing in the word of Christ—the message he brought, the revelations he made. “God, who at sundry times and in divers manners spake in time past unto the fathers by the prophets, hath in these last days spoken unto us by his Son.” These words are truth, because he himself, and his Father who sent them, is truth; and life and death depend on the keeping or otherwise of Christ’s saying, as he has said, “If a man keep my saying, he shall never see death.” And again, “Whosoever heareth these sayings of mine, and doeth them, I will liken him unto a wise man, which built his house upon a rock: and the rain descended, and the floods came, and the winds blew, and beat upon that house; and it fell not: for it was founded upon a rock. And every one that heareth these sayings of mine, and doeth them not, shall be likened unto a foolish man, which built his house upon the sand: and the rain descended, and the floods came, and the winds blew, and beat upon that house; and it fell: and great was the fall of it.”

The liberty which Christ has bought for us by his blood, and which he bestows, is a liberty through the truth, and in the truth. We come into the liberty of the gospel as we believe and obey the truth; we enjoy it as we love the truth; and we prosper and please God as we walk in the truth; but when we depart from the truth, believe the fables and fancies and dreams of men, and turn away our ears from the truth; and when we follow the vain imaginings of our own deceitful hearts; we lose, we surrender, and therefore do not stand fast in that liberty wherewith Christ has made us free. By following the supposed new light, and further revelations (of God, as men vainly dream) to the “inner consciousness” of the soul, we exercise not liberty, but license; we gain no more real freedom, but

551

virtually forfeit that which we had, or professed to have. The fact is plain, that the more loyal we are to the revealed truth of God's Holy Word, the more we shall possess and enjoy of that true and holy freedom which Christ gives; and as we depart from him, and the truth which he has made known in his own and his Father's name—the truth which centres in, and rays forth from him—the more we shall be hampered with bondage of some kind. Not walking in the truth, as did the beloved Gaius, and the children of "the elect lady," to whom John wrote his second and third epistles, we shall certainly be ensnared, as many are: some with the world; some with Pharisaic legality; some with the different forms and degrees of sacramentalism—Romish and Anglican; some with the pride of human reason; and some with the lusts of the flesh. Receiving the truth and holding fast the truth and walking in the truth is the antidote to all forms of bondage and slavery.

The liberty of the gospel is a precious privilege, and an invaluable treasure. It may be viewed in several aspects and relations.

It is a freedom from the condemning sentence of the law, under which all men lie, until through faith in Christ as their law-fulfilling righteousness, they find rest from their heavy burden of guilt, which falls from their shoulders at the sight of his sacrifice on the cross.

It is not only a freedom from the condemning sentence of the law, but from the law itself as a covenant of works. When we trust wholly in Jesus as our Redeemer, who redeemed us from the curse of the law, being made a curse for us, we are no longer under the law, but under grace. We are no longer servants, or slaves, but sons. For those who receive Christ have thereby the right and ability of sonship, and all its privileges. They are the free-born citizens of the heavenly kingdom, and heaven becomes endeared to them as their Father's house.

It is also a freedom from all legal rites, ceremonies, and exactions. They are crucified and dead, alike to the carnal ordinances of fleshly religion and the ensnaring vanities of this world.

Moreover, gospel liberty implies open access to God and free intercourse with him, in, through, and with Christ. Through and in the revelation God has given in and of Christ, and his eternal love and well-pleasedness with us in Christ we can rejoice before him. We participate in the common inheritance of God's saints, and here and now we have fellowship with the prophets, and apostles, and martyrs, and saints of every age, and "truly our fellowship is with the Father, and with his Son Jesus Christ."

The liberty with which Christ makes believers free also confers upon them the privileges of sons in all respects. They have the Spirit of Christ, that they may know the things that are freely given to them of God, and where the Spirit of the Lord is, that is, the Lord Jesus, there is liberty.

But though believers have so holy and blessed a freedom in Christ, they are under the law to Christ. The range of their liberty is within the bounds of God's truth; that is, the Word of truth, the Holy Scriptures, his own revealed will, where are written, by the inspiration of the Holy Spirit, all things necessary for our instruction and for our perfection in faith and holiness.

The authority of Holy Scripture is a matter carefully omitted from the pamphlet mentioned above, and in like manner the sufficiency of Holy Scripture, while it is not formally denied, is as carefully set aside; and throughout the whole of the crude production the perpetuity of Holy Scripture is as plainly ignored.

Under such conditions the writer, and those who go with him in his vague theories, are, apparently, like those philosophers in St. Paul's day, who, though "ever learning," were never able to come to the knowledge of the truth. As an antidote against all such teachers and errors, and seducers and deceivers of every kind, St. Paul exhorts his beloved Timothy, in language it

would be treason to question the divine inspiration of, and which is specially applicable now in these days of doubt and darkness, rebuke and blasphemy:—"But continue thou in the things which thou hast learned and hast been assured of, knowing of whom thou hast learned (them); and that from a child thou hast known the Holy Scriptures, which are able to make thee wise unto salvation through faith which is in Christ Jesus." He alleges the strongest possible argument for his exhortation, namely, that "All scripture is given by inspiration of God, and is profitable for doctrine, for reproof, for correction, for instruction in righteousness: that the man of God may be perfect, thoroughly furnished unto all good works."

Thus every Christian, and especially every Christian minister, has a vast magazine where he may find, and whence he may draw, all supplies for wayfare and warfare, for all kinds of work, for every possible necessity, and for all requirements; and what David wrote when not half the entire volume of inspiration was in his hand, can be repeated now with an immeasurable emphasis, concerning that priceless gift of God: "O, how I love thy law! it is my meditation all the day"; and again, "Thy word is true from the beginning: and every one of thy righteous judgments endureth for ever." Indeed, if the advocates of "advanced ideas" would only go back in their researches to David's time, they would find how much better acquainted with the divine Word the Royal Psalmist was than the most enlightened of them appear to be. Only let them read, or, if they will not, let us read carefully over Psalm exix., and we shall very plainly see what a strong and implicit faith David had in that Word, how his mind grasped its great truths, absorbed them into his soul, as it were, and how earnestly he commends that Word for all necessary uses, illustrating it by an endless variety of figures and emblems.* He hid that Word in his heart; he stuck unto it as a limpet to the rock; he observed it in all his ways; sought unto it for all he needed; and desired no greater liberty, no truer freedom, than to "run in the way of God's commandments," with a heart divinely enlarged. And we especially commend to the writer of the pamphlet referred to, and to all others, the purpose of the humble and holy psalmist to "keep God's law (Word) continually for ever and for ever," and his solemn resolve to find and enjoy his liberty in that Word, and not outside of it." "And I will walk at liberty: for I seek thy precepts" (v. 45).

Here, then, is true liberty; liberty within the realm of truth and according to the principles of righteousness; a liberty animated by love to him whose "service is perfect freedom." The Spirit of the Lord is at one and the same time the Spirit of truth, and the Spirit of liberty, or, as David prays, "Uphold me with thy free Spirit," for where the Spirit of the Lord is there is liberty—liberty to walk in the truth, and not license to depart from it, and roam unguided and unrestrained by holy love and gracious fear.

It is a sad discovery of the imperious pride of the human heart when man in any sense, way, or degree, seeks to exalt himself—his reason, his will, his desires - above that safe level of sure guidance and humble dependence which God grants to those who seek him and trust in him. The broad circumference of revealed truth affords ample scope for the mightiest intellects among created beings. Indeed, there are vast stretches of thought—heights, depths, length, and breadth—in the region of revelation as we have it in the divine Word, which are beyond the grasp of the most soaring and penetrating mind. God has in his Word made known to us more than angels know; for it is distinctly said of the things that God hath made known unto us by his Spirit, that "the angels desire to look into them." And so we further learn that the unfoldings of the manifold wisdom of God in the work of redemption engross their thought and fix their gaze, so that, in the pauses of the song over new, they receive fresh

* See the Golden Alphabet of Holy Scripture, by C. H. Spurgeon: Passmore & Alabaster.

553

accessions of knowledge, and grander and still grander displays of the "unsearchable riches of Christ," and of the aboundings of redeeming love.

The world's poet has punned upon the old pronunciation of Rome (as if it were written Room):

"Now it is Rome indeed, and Rome enough,

Since its wide walls encompass but one man."

And surely there is room enough for the largest liberty within the vast circumference of revealed truth. Men who think otherwise must have read to little purpose the all-comprehending prayer of the Apostle Paul for the Ephesian Christians and all believers:—"That the God of our Lord Jesus Christ, the Father of glory, may give unto you the spirit of wisdom and revelation in the knowledge of him: the eyes of your understanding being enlightened; that ye may know what is the hope of his calling, and what the riches of the glory of his inheritance in the saints, and what is the exceeding greatness of his power to us-ward who believe, according to the working of his mighty power," &c.*

Now, we fail to see what the greatest mind, the most soaring imagination, can want or would have outside of this. Let but the apostle's prayer be fulfilled in us; let us so have the spirit of wisdom and revelation in the knowledge of Christ, &c., and instead of wishing to soar higher or dive deeper, we shall rather exclaim with blessed Paul, as elsewhere recorded: "O the depth of the riches both of the wisdom and knowledge of God!"

And all these things which God hath revealed belong to us: they are part of our inheritance; they are among the things that are freely given to us of God; they are the things which the Holy Spirit makes known, and for the communicating of which to us the Holy Spirit is given; that we may know the things that are freely given to us of God.

The things that have not been revealed are among the many mysteries of God's inscrutable will which we must wait for the unveiling of, amid other scenes than those of this sin-benighted world. The path of duty is plainly set forth in the infallible Word in relation to the races and people outside the Christian Church. The gospel is to be preached to them; the earth is to be "called from the rising of the sun to the going down of the same," and the earnest prayer of King David, which is the desire and hope of the whole church, shall yet be fulfilled; "And let the whole earth be filled with his glory, Amen, and Amen."

We would offer a word, in conclusion, to our younger brethren. They live in perilous times; the times may be still more perilous, and they will be so if the Church of Christ do not awake, arise, and "shake herself from the dust, and put on her beautiful garments." Let each soldier in Christ's army be faithful; let us "mind our marching orders," and leave the plan and issues of the conflict to him who knows the end from the beginning, and who is our shield and our salvation at all times. God has given us each a banner that it may be displayed because of truth. Let us uplift that, and ever be loyal to our Master and to his cause, which is also ours. Perplexities, difficulties, mysteries, there will be, there have ever been, for God's ways are past finding out; but we have to do with One who is immutable, whose words are right, and all of whose works are done in truth.

"The wisest will is God's own will:

Rest on this anchor and be still;

For peace around thy path shall flow,

When only wishing here below

What pleases God."†

* The writer will always remember with great satisfaction the masterly exposition of this whole passage by the late Rev. G. Gould, of Norwich, in a sermon in connexion with the Autumnal Meetings of the Baptist Union, at Leeds, in 1878. The reader will find, also, some excellent thoughts on the Divine Inheritance, in sermons xvi., xvii., and xviii. of "A Year's Ministry" by Dr. Maclaren, First Series. † Paul Gerhardt.

37

With infinite and eternal truth, plainly revealed in Christ and in the Word, as our heritage; with the Spirit of truth as our Teacher and Guide, concerning whom it is promised that he will lead us into all truth, we may well be content to work on, wait on, and struggle on, acting on the good advice of the homely lines—

"Let all fruitless searches go,

That perplex and tease us,

And determine nought to know

But a bleeding Jesus."*

Here is true liberty, the liberty of light and love, in which we may serve God and one another, and our generation according to his will. Beyond this angels fear to tread, and our bold, adventurous thoughts may not seek to climb or rove. We conclude with a verse in which may every reader unite with the writer, as in humble, fervent prayer:—

"Jesus, only stand thou by me!

In thy strength my safety lies:

Search my spirit, Lord, and try me,

Free my heart from all disguise."

"Withhold me from paths that to ruin are basting,

And lead me, O Lord, in the way everlasting;

Till, dying, from earth and its cares I retire,

With Jesus to live—the one thing I desire."†

Everything we make is available for free because of a generous community of supporters.

Donate