The Days of our Fathers and our own Times — A Contrast
MR. BESANT, in his book, makes us see things as they were fifty years ago. By describing things as they were when the present generation of middle-aged people were little children, Mr. Besant greatly encourages those who are working for the Christian and social elevation of the population. Since the last reign, the nation has made wonderful progress; but in emphasizing this, and in glorifying our own times at the expense of those which have gone before, there is danger of losing sight of abuses and evils which are still rampant. The present days are not characterized by anything of which we can consistently boast; they merely show a favourable contrast to those older times, which were bad beyond description. Nevertheless the disappearance of certain abuses, grievances, and evil customs encourages us still to work on, in hope of seeing yet better times.
Keeping this fact in view, we can the better understand Mr. Besant's answer to the question, What was life in England like in the reign of William IV., when the manners and customs of the eighteenth century still lingered in the land? "Rank was still held in the ancient reverence; religion was still that of the eighteenth century church; the rights of labour were not yet recognized; there were no trades-unions; there were no railways to speak of; nobody travelled except the rich; their own country was unknown to the people; the majority of country people could not read or write; the good old discipline of Father Stick and his children, Cat-o'-nine-tails, Rope's-end, Strap, Birch, Ferule, and Cane, was wholesomely maintained; landlords, manufacturers, and employers of all kinds, did what they pleased with their own; and the Blue Ribbon was unheard of."
This was anything but a satisfactory state of things, but it was quite in keeping with the general state of the people; and what is perhaps most surprising, it was altogether an immense advance on the state of things which had obtained in the reign of George II., before the awakening of the Methodist revival had brought its waves of blessing. The church had become a missionary church, and enterprise in the foreign mission-field had stimulated work at home; but, notwithstanding, very little was being done to bring in the working people. It is asserted that, in the old times of fifty years ago, nine-tenths of the industrial classes were the infidel disciples of Paine, Carlile, and Taylor, and that "not one working man in a hundred ever opened a Bible." The improvement on this state of things is seen in the fact that "about one person in nine now attends church or chapel on a Sunday"; but does that afford occasion for congratulation? The proportion of those who attend public worship would be somewhat greater if the congregations of mission-halls, &c., were included; but if seven out of nine thus turn their backs on the gospel, what an alarming state of things does that represent! In this country, and in other lands, experience has proved to a demonstration, that the religion of Christ is not only a
* "Fifty Years Ago." By Walter Besant. With one hundred and thirty-seven plates and woodcuts. Chatto and Windus. Price 16s.
633
cure for present ills, but a preventive of such as are prospective. What terrible upheavals would France have been spared if she had not refused the Reformation! The Earl of Shaftesbury often insisted, that the seeds of dangerous revolution are ever germinating where the people remain in ignorance of God. This is the danger of England at the present moment. For the most part, the working classes are outside of the church; and on this account atheism, intemperance, profanity, and notions inimical to the stability of government largely prevail among them. The Commune in France, Nihilism in Russia, Socialism in Germany, are anti-Christian forces; and in proportion as our own people are affected by the disease of irreligion we shall be exposed to the same danger. Nothing so promotes political unrest as infidelity; and unhappily unbelief of a very stupid kind—accepted without question at second-hand from infidel leaders—widely prevails among our people.
Although much discontent finds expression in these days among the working-classes, the complaint has really no foundation in reason, as compared with other days. The temporal condition of the classes who sell their labour has generally improved, and Mr. Besant flatly contradicts certain of the sombre conclusions at which the pessimist class of political economists have arrived. "It is not true," he says, "as stated in a very well-known work, that the poor have become poorer, though the rich have certainly become richer. The skilled working man is better paid now than then, his work is more steady, his hours are shorter. He is better clad, with always a suit of clothes apart from his working dress; he is better taught; he is better mannered; he has holidays; he has clubs; he is no longer forbidden to combine; he can co-operate; he holds meetings; he has much better newspapers to read; his food is better and cheaper; he has model lodging-houses." Thus, the opportunities within reach of the working man in the manufacturing towns are greater than they ever were.
In days when a great deal too much money is expended in beer, wine, and spirits, it is encouraging to find that a great improvement has been made in this respect. Compared with the days of the Georges, the consumption of drink is small; or, as Mr. Besant puts it, "Our drink-bill is nothing in comparison with that of fifty years ago." He has collected some facts and figures to make good this assertion: "Thus, the number of visitors to fourteen great ginshops in London was found to average three thousand each per diem; in Edinburgh there was a ginshop for every fifteen families; in one Irish town of eight hundred people there were eighty-eight ginshops; in Sheffield thirteen persons were killed in ten days by drunkenness; in London there was one public-house to every fifty-six houses; in Glasgow one to every ten." It is to be hoped that this reform will still go on, until there are no homes in the country rendered bare and miserable by drink.
But while congratulating one another on the wonderful progress of these days, we must not forget that the country is necessarily in an unsatisfactory condition so long as our chief industry—agriculture—is in such a depressed condition. This depression is bearing evil fruits in many ways; and it affects even the diffusion of the gospel itself, by making it almost impossible for many devoted men to hold on their way in the villages. This, at all events, is not "progress" to boast of,
42
for the outlook is altogether serious; and if some remedy is not found, it is not very easy to see how Old England is to hold her own among the nations. The only possible remedy is, of course, to relieve the land of burdens which it is not able to bear, such as tithes, rates, &c.; but if the ecclesiastics are going to carry on war with the farmers, they will not serve their own cause, and they will surely hasten the inevitable day of disestablishment.
Mr. Besant's book affords the reader a graphic, and, on the whole, a trustworthy contrast between the old times and our own; but when he affects to treat of religion his judgment fails him, and whoever puts faith in his representations will be misled. Mr. Besant speaks of "the old Calvinism" with the assurance of one who affects to understand it; but we gravely suspect that, in reality, he knows nothing about it. Opinions founded on a few misrepresented generalities go for little, so that we excuse his utterances under this head. So far from the evangelical doctrines represented by Calvinism being dead or obsolete, they are among the few things that are really alive; and in their essence and substance the great doctrines of grace are still among the most mighty forces in the world of mind. Great philanthropic works, both at home and abroad, are the outcome of this teaching, and the works which testify to a living faith are more abundant than they ever were before.
