What is True Success in the Ministry?
A PAPER READ AT THE PASTORS' COLLEGE CONFERENCE. BY PASTOR SYDNEY J. JONES, KENSINGTON.
Matthew x. 7, 8; xxviii. 18-20. Acts ii. 41, 47; iv. 31, 32; viii. 4; ix. 31.
THERE are, I think, two points of view. Success sometimes lies in the faithful prosecution of the work, rather than in the results. At Athens, Paul, mocked and postponed (Acts xvii. 32), did not look much like success. McCheyne, weeping his soul away in Dundee, because his work yielded no result, did not look much like success. The prophet cannot always see the fulfilment of his message. The minister of the New Testament has to publish mercy, and to practise it; he has to announce judgment, and not execute it. The sword and fire are in God's hands, and may not smite or burn until he has passed from the scene. From this point of view, and remembering the duty of the watchman (Ezekiel xxxiii.), and our Lord's command to the disciples (Matthew x. 14), is it not success, if in the spirit and words of Paul we can say, "I have not shunned to declare unto you all the counsel of God . . . and I ceased not to warn every one night and day with tears"? "One soweth and another reapeth." Charles Stanford says:— "One kind of success belongs to the work of clearing the jungle; another to the work of ploughing the soil; another to the work of sowing the seed; another to the man who reaps the harvest, or piles the sheaves."
"Ours may be the seed-time: God alone
Beholds the end of what is sown;
Beyond our vision weak and dim,
The harvest time is hid with him."
Then all good seed does not get into good ground, and the rejection of our message is not always a reflection on the speaker and his word; it is often a reflection on the rejector. When Christ was rejected of his nation, it proved not that Christ was unworthy of the nation, but that the nation was unworthy of him.
To answer the question from the other point of view, we ask what was considered success in the days of Christ and his apostles. Briefly, the gospel conception of the work of Christ was to deliver men from the guilt and suffering of sin, and to bring them under the influence of the Holy Ghost.
In the Acts of the Apostles, when the church was pre-eminently under the influence of the Holy Spirit, believers were multiplied with great rapidity; the converts bore one another's burdens, and so fulfilled the law of Christ; the strong bore the infirmities of the weak, and did not please themselves. In the continuation of such "Acts of the Apostles", and in that alone, do I see the true success of the ministry, and the only salvation of the churches. If the church breaks away from these ancient moorings, she will drift at the mercy of every wind and tide, her glory gone, a wreck of her former self.
Discussing this question in view of present-day tendencies, we may
have to wade through controversial waters; but to the Bible we must get, though it be a long journey through flood and flame.
Under the heading of "A Model Church", a religious paper recently gave, amongst other things, classes for "art", "languages", "wood carving", and "clay modelling;" cricket and swimming clubs, and a committee for "popular entertainments."
Each of these things is, I think, good in itself; but not one of them was used by the apostles, or if used, they are not put on record as successes in Christian work.
Let us ask intelligently—Whether is it the function of the church to *embrace*, or to *influence*, every department of life? is its work *national*, or in the *nation*? Is Christianity to get into all departments of life, by bringing all departments into the church, or by thoroughly Christianizing men, and so sending Christianity into all departments? Is it, for example, to regenerate dumb-bells, or to regenerate men, and let them use dumb-bells if they like. Neander says:—"Christ worked only in his own sphere, the sphere of men's hearts; although indeed, by operating upon the heart, he meant to operate upon everything else; for all human relations grow out of it." We best fit men for this life and that which is to come, by bringing their hearts under the regenerating power of the Holy Ghost.
That phase of thought in Christian men which would make the church *embrace* every department of life, takes, I think, its advocates further than they intend. We have seen the "reductio ad absurdum", viz., "run a theatre and a public house", and I don't see how a permanent halt can be made short of that; perhaps not even there. The church of the future must be situated in its own grounds of so many acres, so that, say, a football match may be arranged between deists and atheists, after the morning service, in which the preacher, with great learning and erudition, had assured his congregation that, read in the light of the higher criticism, the text, "He that cometh to God must *believe* that he is", could, by a mixed assembly, be read, "He that cometh to God MAY believe that he *isn't*"; the existence of God and our belief in him being hard dogmas of a church whose teaching was sadly fettered by creed.
The commentary of history on these things is that they are very successful in secularizing the church, but sadly fail in evangelizing the world; "they are much more likely to end in sensualizing religion than in spiritualizing sense." The powers of the world will not serve instead of the "powers of the world to come", and by trying them we shall grieve the Holy Spirit, on whose power we depend. Our aim is not merely to gather a congregation, but to build up the church of Jesus Christ. Spiritual results are the great end for which churches exist, and they can only be secured by spiritual forces. The sword of the Spirit is the "Word of God", and that ministry must be most successful which will put into the hand of the Spirit the material which he most loves, and with which he most works. To say *method* is nothing, is to charge Christ with foolishness when he refused Satan's method of winning the world.
When John's disciples asked Jesus, "Art thou he that should come", Christ did not impugn the authority of Isaiah. He did not say, "There
325
are a few discrepancies in the prophecies concerning me, and I am not really bound to the precise fulfilment of what those fallible men wrote." No, it was a grand dumb answer. Isaiah, ages before, had given the marks by which the Messiah should be known; and now the Messiah was at his work; and so he sends a chapter of his daily life to John: "The blind received their sight, and the lame walk, the lepers are cleansed, and the deaf hear, the dead are raised up, and the poor have the gospel preached to them." The Messianic works attested the Messianic claim. The apostles were afterwards commissioned to carry on those works, and in the continuation of such works lies one great test of a Christian church to-day, and also its redemption from the secular spirit. Compare the "model church" referred to with a church whose accessories consist of orphan homes and almshouses, organizations for feeding the hungry, clothing the naked, relieving the suffering, comforting the infirm, "the strong bearing the infirmities of the weak, and not pleasing themselves." By these we should be fulfilling the law of Christ by "bearing one another's burdens." See James i. 27. We believe that the church of Christ still possesses distinctive features, and has her own peculiar work. The church is not the world, nor a bit of the world under another name; it is in the world, but not of the world; and there is a work outside the church, as well as for the church, and she cannot do outside work without neglecting her own.
We are persuaded that there is yet room for immense and intense development along the lines of the New Testament, and we most strongly hold, that by inviting our young men to gymnasiums, concert halls, &c., we are, to the hurt of the church of Christ, and to the hurt of the young men, lowering the standard of Christian work, and weakening our own exhortations to a life of self-denial and self-sacrifice for Christ's sake: we are teaching our young men to please themselves, instead of calling on them that are strong to "bear the infirmities of the weak." Homes for the fatherless and fallen, for waifs, strays, outcasts, deaf, dumb, blind; hospitals, dispensaries and infirmaries; these are the true accessories of a Christian church. Keep these angels of heaven in our streets; these doors of heaven standing open night and day: thus it will be seen that the Spirit which moved our Saviour to bind up the broken-hearted, deliver the captives, recover sight to the blind, and give joy for mourning, is the spirit which actuates his church now. These institutions are the offspring of Christianity; God is the Great Father of all orphans and orphanages. Through God we have built our Bethesdas—his angels stir the water; and the church could claim these as her own if she devoted to these objects the time now wasted in social vanities and selfish gratification.
The fame of Christianity is the fame of the cures she has worked; the glory of Christianity is the glory of the saints she has reared; the renown of Christianity is the renown of sinners transformed in life, and walking with God as his dear children; and may the day soon return when the church of Christ shall seek only this fame, this glory, this renown!
I am aware that the forsaking of old methods, and the adoption of new ideas, arise very largely from a dissatisfaction with past results. Now, the dissatisfaction is good. It is the next step that is crucial, that
determines whether a man has kept his faith, and the balance of his faith, whether he is moved of God, or gets a self-derived energy; for a self-derived will be a self-directing energy; and many who justly reach the stage of dissatisfaction unjustly blunder at the next step, as, for instance, the author of "Lead, kindly Light." Does comparative non-success call for a rejection of the old instruments, or a better and fuller use of them? The iconoclast may be found fighting against God. Granting that Luther was necessarily one-sided in doctrine, that the Puritan was too severe and exclusive in practice, that Wesley and Whitefield did not seize the exact centre, still it is possible to be wider of the mark than they—to wander further from the centre.
We believe that in the early Christian church there was more perfectly mirrored than at any other time, the church of the past, present and future. We want to get back to the first century, not because, as is so often said, "the age demands it." The age may lead us to open our Bibles again. The age may be a schoolmaster to bring us to Christ. Demand it has none. Christ has all. Someone has said, "The church that meets the needs of the labourer is the church of the future." That is a wrong attitude. The church is not to see its hope in the strongest party of the future, but in the eternal principles of Christ, written in the New Testament, and translated into life in the first century. The New Testament tells us what is success, and what are the methods for attaining it.
Two things are at the root of our life of faith and labour of love, personal living to Christ, and personal working for Christ. Take, first, PERSONAL CONSECRATION. Faith must flower into obedience, and be manifest in Christian work. For an aggressive Christianity there must be an attractive Christianity. The church of Christ must be a success; men and women personally living to Christ, letting their light so shine that men may see their good works and glorify their Father which is in heaven.
There are principles of conduct in the New Testament almost lost sight of in the general conception of to-day. See, e.g., Matthew xix. 21; Luke xiv. 12-14. If we all understood, preached and practised the New Testament stewardship, would it not more fully awaken the angel of benevolence, and cause her to unfold those wings of healing? "The earth is the Lord's, and the fulness thereof." The true Christian cannot selfishly hoard or selfishly use. "Whoso hath this world's good, and seeth his brother have need, and shutteth up his bowels of compassion from him, how dwelleth the love of God in him?"
The Epistle of James must be preached. The gold ring must not in itself secure the highest seat. Before God earthly standards count for nought. The man who prays for the masses, and then speaks slightingly of a poor congregation, is acting a lie against the Holy Ghost. Faith is dead without the fruit of the Spirit.
On some subjects we need to refind our Bible, and bow to its authority. In Josiah's day the Bible got lost in the money-box, not an altogether unique occurrence; for even now what is so powerful as "Vested Interests" in hiding the true teaching of the Word of God? For ages it was not seen that the Bible had anything to say on the abolition of the slave trade. Now it is slowly dawning on us that the Bible has
327
something to say on social questions; and if the church will be piloted by the Word of God, she will be of great service on this stormy and agitated sea.
The teaching of Christ really contains principles which, if fully carried out, would solve all the legitimate problems of Socialism; and the teaching of Christ furnishes the motive, in the work of divine redemption, and the power, in the work of the Holy Spirit, which are wholly lacking elsewhere. Let negative criticism give way to positive teaching. Personal living to Christ will solve this question. If the merchant or large employer of labour opens his heart and mind to the Spirit of God, that Spirit will lead him into all truth, and will not suffer him to pass lightly by "Heaven's labour-regulation bill" (Exodus xx. 9, 10). The Holy Spirit will also lead him to a very Christian interpretation of the "Employers' Liability Act" (Colossians iv. 1).
Then, equally important, if the labourer opens his heart and mind to the Holy Spirit, Colossians iii. 22-25 will be a lamp to his feet, and a light to his path; and so the personal relation between the individual and his God involves a social relation between man and his fellow. Upon a legal eight hours' bill, we, as Christ's ambassadors, have no authority from him to pronounce a judgment. Why is it that the church has so largely lost the Sabbath? It is because she has yielded to seven days' labour in her own members; she has let go the "six days", and now instead tries an eight hours. So long as the church of Christ keeps up to the level of inspiration, she speaks with authority, bright and clear above the wrangle of party strife. When she descends from the level of inspiration, she only chatters with the rest. Neglecting to proclaim the law of Christ to the employer, the church has largely been a party to capitalists. Now, by neglecting to proclaim the law of Christ to the labourer, she is in danger of becoming party to the labourer. Let us inculcate, by the grace of Christ, the Christian relationship between masters and servants. The gospel of Christ makes adequate provision; if we do not preach it, then we, and not the gospel, are to be branded as failures. The New Testament principles are the most practical, and they make reformation possible.
The other need is PERSONAL WORKING for Christ. Each disciple is needed as a winner of souls. Each should be attached to the Andrew-and-Philip Society. Personal work being the most Christian, is the most urgent demand. Personal work promoted by organizations, but for which no organization can be a substitute, the joy and responsibility of individual discipleship must be restored. As a minister in London lately said, "The church needs redemption, through a large interpretation and fearless application of its root principle, viz., personal fellowship with our Lord and Saviour Jesus Christ. Out of that comes brotherhood; out of brotherhood comes sympathy; out of sympathy comes co-operation," i.e., bearing one another's burdens, and each member of Christ making his church the evangel of Jesus.
