Notices of Books
In Memoriam: John Courtnay. Passmore and Alabaster.
THIS is a worthy sketch of a worthy man, and may be had for sixpence. Mr. Courtnay was an earnest advocate of the good old tunes, and by his zeal and industry he accomplished a good work in promoting congregational psalmody. His book of Fugal Tunes was only an instalment of a larger work which he had projected: still, it is an interesting collection, and congregational singing would be all the better for its judicious use. The modern fashion inspires no enthusiasm in worship; and it will be a clear gain when some of the good old tunes, which have been set aside for a season, are brought into use again.
Sacrifice as set forth in Scripture. By JAMES G. MURPHY, D.D., LL.D. Hodder and Stoughton.
THIS is the Carey lecture for 1888, giving a careful and Scriptural exposition of the ancient typical sacrifices leading up to the Real Sacrifice of Jesus Christ. We find much to commend on many points; but dissent strongly from the universalism of the teaching upon the propitiation of the cross. The sacrifice of Calvary must have a higher relationship to the mystic body of Christ than to those who perish in their sin; therefore, to assert, or even to suggest, that the redemptive purposes of God are alike in all cases, is to contradict the teaching of Scripture so dear to the believer, who finds a choice joy in seeing his own personal place eternally fixed on the great plan of salvation through the cross. We do not believe that any "argument is all-powerful in itself to give light to the soul that walketh in darkness." There is a
necessity for the Spirit's work to give effect to the moral influence of the death of Christ. It weakens the force of the truth of the love of God in Christ, to attempt to prove that it is alike to all men; and it is dishonouring to the Spirit to intimate that the truth will act savingly without his gracious aid.
My Master and my Friend. By Rev. GEORGE EVERARD, M.A. Religious Tract Society.
All Through the Day. Same Author. Nisbet and Co.
MR. EVERARD is a wonderful writer. There seems to be no end to his books; and they are as choice as they are numerous. The first of these is a little brochure full of fragrance and light; the second consists of portions for each day of the month; and to those who know the author's other volumes of similar character, will need no recommendation. Very good.
The Century Dictionary. An Encyclopedic Lexicon of the English Language. Prepared under the superintendence of WILLIAM DWIGHT WHITNEY, Ph.D., LL.D. Vol. V. T. Fisher Unwin.
THIS colossal work is approaching completion. Five out of six volumes are published, and the sixth is to be issued "by the end of the autumn of this year." There is little that can be added to the commendations we have given to former volumes, for the work appears to be well done throughout. We have not needed to refer to all the words in this lexicon; we should hardly have occasion to do so if we lived until the twentieth century dictionary should be published.
How to Mark your Bible. By MRS. STEPHEN MENZIES. Prefatory Note by D. L. MOODY. Partridge.
WHETHER Bibles marked with railway connections and other lines are of much after-value we cannot say from experience, but the process of marking must so engage the mind, and so beautifully call attention to parallels and consecutive ideas, that it must be quite a training for Bible readers. Anything which leads to searching the Scriptures is most useful. Mrs. Menzies in this book lends good working aid to Bible marking; and she does not do it for you, so much as show the way. Oh, that we had more who are at home in every street and lane of Scripture! We should then have far fewer tolerating the snarling dogs who roam over the Bible as if it were a heap of dust, from which they could root out a bone to growl over. Exposition is the best defence of Scripture. How often do we hear devout souls exclaim, "What a wonderful chapter! Who could doubt its inspiration?"
Life's Stages: their Duties and Opportunities. By JAMES STARK. Oliphant, Anderson, and Ferrier.
THE biographer of "John Murker" has made this little book as suggestive as possible. A hasty glance at it will scarcely reveal the wealth of thought and experience compressed in its pages; but a close and careful reading will richly repay in fresh and fruitful ideas. There is a lurking quaintness that springs out suddenly upon you with a charm of unexpectedness; and even well-worn truths are so pertinently put, that they come with the flavour of originality.
This little volume does not aim at distinctly evangelistic teaching, but is suffused with godly earnestness in declaring the social duties of life. It has our warmest welcome and heartiest commendation.
Bright Sabbaths. A few words to Mothers. Partridge and Co.
A VERY useful little book for mothers who have to entertain and instruct their children on the Sabbath evening. This book, now in its third edition, is
really an unpretending defence of the Christian Sabbath. Some parents give up their children to the care of the Pastor and the Sunday-school Teacher; but others who have the opportunity, and the grace to use it aright, try to train them themselves. To such "Bright Sabbaths" will be useful and interesting.
Progress of The Redeemer's Kingdom. A Book for Young People. By the Rev. JAMES ERVINE. Dublin: George Herbert, 117, Grafton Street. London: Elliot Stock.
IN twelve brief and bright chapters, we have here twelve charming pictures for the young people on the marvellous progress of Christian Missions during the present century. Every Sunday-school library ought to possess two or three copies. Each page is full of interest; no boy or girl who once begins it is likely to lay the book aside unread: the young people who love Christ cannot do so, we feel sure. Mr. Ervine, who succeeded the Rev. W. M. Statham, at Hull, and has since removed to Ireland, says of this work in his preface: "I offer it timidly to public favour." He certainly need have no timidity about its reception. It is crammed with useful information and valuable statistics. Teachers and thoughtful young people should read it by all means, as it is full of interesting matter for missionary addresses.
"Fishin' Jimmy." By ANNIE TRUMBULL SLOSSON. Randolph and Co., 38 West 23rd Street, New York.
A VERY pretty little book, tastefully got up, and illustrated in American style. This booklet is simply a sketch of an old fisherman, who in a quaint way finds Scriptural lessons in all parts of his craft. It is well written, and the heroic death of the old man is remarkable for its tenderness and pathos. A useful book for Working Classes or Mothers' Meetings.
Motherly Counsels. Translated from the French by KATHERINE KAY. Edinburgh: Andrew Elliot.
LETTERS from a Swiss lady to her former pupils, conveying much valuable teaching, and written in a loving spirit of tender solicitude.
533
Mile-Stone Papers, Doctrinal, Ethical, and Experimental, on Christian Progress. By DANIEL STEELE, D.D. Partridge and Co.
DR. STEELE is a well-known, able, and fervent advocate of what is generally known as "Perfectionism," or "The Higher Christian Life." In this work, Dr. Steele pursues a similar course to that followed by him in "Love Enthroned." He discards legal perfection, but lays claim to evangelical perfection. By the latter is intended the reign of love. Dr. Steele's contention is, that "perfect love-service can be rendered; while perfect law-service is beyond the power of moral cripples to render." Again he says, "there is no sin where perfect love reigns;" and adds, immediately, "this may consist with innumerable defects, infirmities, and theoretical and practical errors." It is somewhat difficult to get the author's exact idea; or to see how one can be a moral cripple, and incapable of perfect law-service, and yet as dead to sin (to quote from this book again), "as the occupants of the Stone Chapel grave-yard are to the tide of Boston business and pleasure which rolls along Tremont Street." But those who do get the idea seem to revel in it greatly. Meanwhile, let those of us who cannot claim perfection, however defined, "lay aside every weight, and the sin that doth so easily beset us," that to perfection's sacred height we yet may rise.
The Great Question Answered; or, God's Way of Salvation. By Rev. A. METCALFE. Elliot Stock.
SIX simple Scriptural sermons upon the Philippian jailer's question, and the apostolic answer. Just the book to put into the hands of an anxious enquirer. The titles of the sermons will indicate the preacher's method of handling the subject: saving faith and its difficulties, its object, its promise, its effects, its illustration, and its influence.
The Programme of Life. By the Rev. W. L. WATKINSON. T. Woolmer.
SIX good and chaste sermons; not exactly what we should call gospel
sermons, but each one abounds in good pure thought, and illustrations drawn from various sources. It is a book that will be read with profit: a beautiful spirit breathes through the whole.
A Letter from Heaven, and other Sermons. By Rev. DAVID ROBERTS, D.D. Elliot Stock.
FIFTEEN sermons, of a thoroughly interesting and readable sort, are gathered here. One, on the voice from heaven, which bade John write, "Blessed are the dead," &c. (Rev. xiv. 13), gives the title to the book. We do not know Dr. Roberts; but should think that, when delivered in his native Welsh, these discourses were living messages to human souls. Some much-neglected themes are touched, including one on "The duty of Christians towards the Jews," which rightly estimates the worth and place of God's ancient people in the work of evangelization. Of making many books of sermons there seems no end; but as there are between seven and eight millions of sermons preached each year, in England and Wales alone, the marvel is that more are not printed. At all events, we wish we could as heartily commend all that are published as these.
Jehovah-Jesus; the Divine Appearances under the Patriarchal, Levitical, and Christian Dispensations. By GEORGE FYLER TOWNSEND, M.A., D.C.L. Nisbet and Co.
THIS book is all in praise of HIM whose name is above every name, and serves well to show how his delights have ever been with the sons of men. We might take exception to certain minor points of detail, more especially in regard to what is said, in Appendix A, on the Christian church, or "Segullah," which seems to us but a notion of man's wisdom; but with so much to commend, we would rather pass on. With the author's main thesis, that the Theophanies were the divine appearances of our Blessed Saviour all along the line, we are in heartiest accord; and we congratulate him on producing a work so pleasantly written, and so well fitted to edify and refresh the church of God.
The Land where Jesus Christ lived. By HESTER DOUGLAS. Nelsons.
ON the cover of this handsome volume, as a sub-title, are the words, "A Book for the Young"; and admirably is it adapted to those for whom it is written. It purports to contain the vivæ voce descriptions of the Holy Land, given by "Aunt Hetty" to her nephew Willie; and a very wise Willie he would be if he remembered all that his auntie told him about the climate, trees, mountains, rivers, &c., of the earthly Canaan. Scriptural incidents are woven into the narrative in a most interesting and instructive fashion; and we are not at all surprised that Willie was sorry when the talks were brought to an end. Those who read the book will have a similar regret.
Like her bright young nephew, we rejoice that Aunt Hetty has promised to tell what she knows about the cities of the Holy Land, and the curious ways of the people; and when the conversations are published, as we feel sure will be the case, we shall be glad to receive an early copy.
We also feel inclined to imitate Willie in asking for explanations of one or two matters that rather puzzle us. Please, Aunt Hetty, why do you call the four Evangelists, St. Matthew, St. Mark, St. Luke, and St. John, while you speak of the Lord's three specially-favoured apostles as Peter, James, and John (without the saintly prefix)? Is not the disciple whom Jesus loved as much a saint as the writer of the fourth Gospel? Are you quite sure that the carob is not John the Baptist's locust-tree? Will you kindly teach Willie the meaning of the words "awful" and "awfully"?
Most important of all, in your next talks with your nephew, will you explain to him that salvation is not the result of our imitation of the Lord Jesus, for that is impossible to our unrenewed nature; but it becomes ours through our reliance, by faith, on the sacrifice of Calvary, and the application, by the Holy Spirit, of the merits of Christ's death to us? Is not this the apostolic way of putting the truth—"Christ also suffered for us, leaving us an example, that we should follow his steps"?
Valleys and Villages of the Bible; or, Scripture Scenes Illustrated by Sacred Localities. By JOSIAH VINEY. Stock.
THIS little volume has been overlooked; but it is likely to be so useful that we insert a notice of it now that it has been discovered. Mr. Viney hopes that these pages "may be acceptable to youthful Bible-readers, and, possibly, to some to whom youth is now a memory." This hope is likely to be realized, and we think that Bible-class leaders, and preachers, too, will find many subjects treated here in a way that will be of service to them in their work. We append an extract, which is a fair specimen of the author's style:—
"ESHCOL was a border valley. Beautiful in itself, its contiguity to Canaan added to its charms. Such a border valley all will one day enter; many are in it now by age, by sickness, by declining life. Many are today within hail, it may be, of the celestial world, near to eternity and the invisible state. At Eshcol were two classes of people. They were all fellow-travellers, engaged on an important errand, yet their views, apprehensions, hopes, beliefs, were strikingly contrasted. The small minority thought, felt, acted aright, and were bold to avow their convictions in face of opposition and obloquy. With the majority it was just the opposite. Looking on the same objects as their colleagues, they exaggerated difficulties, minimized advantages, yielded to fear, were unbelieving, lost the inheritance, 'perished in their own deceiving.'
"In the border-land which all successively enter, similar differences exist still. Thank God, we yet have our Joshua and Calebs; and such, though ever the minority, the world has never lacked. To such, Eshcol is often lovely, blessed, fruitful, truly 'the Land of Beulah.'... The faithful witnesses found the passage across the Jordan was more distant than they expected. Forty years they waited for it; but when it came, the river was dry, the ark was their leader, all difficulties vanished, and they had an abundant entrance into the land flowing with milk and honey."
535
What God hath Wrought. An account of the Mission Tour of Rev. G. C. GRUBB, M.A. Marlborough & Co.
IF we only know of Keswick and its Missions what we learnt from this volume, our estimate of its value would be of rather a mingled character. The tour, of which the book is a record, was undertaken in 1889-90, and in the diary of events there is so much that is good that we scarcely know how to criticize it. Doubtless many will be edified and stimulated by its perusal; but we meet with such frequent trivialities, that the memorable things seem to us very much like plums in a box of sawdust. We would prefer them on a dish; and if this book were reduced by two-thirds, it would be much more to our taste. The efforts of these brethren, whom we greatly honour for their abundant testimony, seem to have been largely blessed, whether in India, Australasia, the Cape, or on their various voyages, and therein we greatly rejoice; but it is the record of their work, and not the effort itself, that we are called upon to estimate, and we must distinguish between William Tell's son and the apple on his head. Our sympathy with the workers does not prevent us aiming an arrow at their book. We could really have done without knowing of their visits to barbers and to baths; we would have taken it for granted that they, unlike the hermits, bathed and shaved; nor are we greatly interested in knowing what they had for dinner; and if all earnest Christians should feel called upon to report the conversations they may have with others about Christ, the world would scarcely contain the books that might be written, and we should feel inclined to throw up the reviewer's task in despair. Having said so much to shake the fruit free from its "packing," we will go on to say that there is a flavour about it, as if it had grown on the tree of life. Critics had better read something else; but if half-hearted Christians would take up the volume in a sympathetic spirit, it might be to them a revelation of the way in which God can bless those who devote themselves without stint to his service; they might even
swallow the frequent ejaculations of our friends; perhaps even discover that they themselves had been more decorous in their religion, because "they had nothing to hallelujah about," as one lady phrases it in this book, which, with all its blemishes, we somehow cannot help liking.
Scripture Scenes and their Lessons. To Him that Overcometh.
By Rev. ANDREW CARTER, M.A. Drummond's Tract Depôt, Stirling. Two gracious little books, tastefully bound, in the first of which the lessons which gather around various spots in the Holy Land are simply and clearly stated, and illustrated by some pretty pictures. The second deals with the wonderful words in the Book of Revelation in a chaste and charming manner. Both are good.
Seven Sights of Society: being the Eighth and Last Voyage of Sindbad the Sailor. Narrated by J. A. KELMAN. Elliot Stock.
THE writer meant well, but we do not think that much will come of his lucubrations. It was wearisome reading, and we felt glad that it was to be Sindbad's last voyage. We should not care to go upon another with him.
Memoir of John Kenneth Mackenzie. By Mrs. BRYSON. Hodder and Stoughton.
THE record of a heroic life. A true healer of men's bodies and souls; and above all, a faithful witness in life and death to the truths he loved and taught. Heartily do we agree with him, that "The latitudinarianism of so many Congregational ministers in England is a death-blow to the missionary spirit of our churches." It is refreshing to read his outspoken utterance in a letter to his father:—"What do you think of Spurgeon's action? I am delighted with the stand he has taken, and trust it may do much to awaken thoughtful students of the Bible to the danger of many of the theories floating around."
The book is well written; and it gladdens our heart to find that the men in the mission-field of to-day are worthy successors of the best men who have gone before. This is a book for young men, and should be in every Sunday-school library.
The Success of Christian Missions. By ROBERT YOUNG, F.R.G.S. Hodder and Stoughton.
THIS volume is an evident labour of love, and comes appropriately upon the eve of the Baptist Missionary Centenary. Recognizing the bent of many minds to get at the bottom of things, the author has here provided materials from all sorts and conditions of men (and women, too) as to the real character of Christian missions. Adverse opinions and criticisms are cited first. There are round-the-world tourists, who dish up snatches of gossip, and fragments of truth, for the delectation of their readers. There are literary men, who write in the light of human wisdom, in utter ignorance of the wisdom from above. "Mr. Edwin Arnold (for example) recently informed a Boston audience that he preferred 'the dark shadows of Hindooism to the sunlight of Calvinism,' and descanted, at the same time, on the benevolent spirit of the Hindoo, and especially of the Buddhist faith!" The author, in a foot-note, illustrates the folly and falseness of this style of writing. Having let the critics speak out, he gathers up a mass of evidence from government Blue Books, books of travel, reviews, reports, &c., exclusively from lay sources, beginning with Dr. Johnson and Sir Walter Scott, and including statesmen, generals, judges, and explorers. We can only notice the following:—Mr. Stanley, the African explorer, writing from Ugogo, Oct. 5th, 1889, says, "I take this powerful body of native Christians, in the heart of Africa, who prefer exile for the sake of their faith to serving a monarch indifferent or hostile to their faith, as more substantial evidence of the work of Mackay, than any number of imposing structures clustered together, and called a mission-station, would be. These native Africans have endured the most deadly persecutions: the stake and the fire, the cord and the club, the sharp knife and the rifle bullet, have all been tried to cause them to reject the teachings they have absorbed. Stanch in their beliefs, firm in their convictions, they have held together stoutly and resolutely,
and Mackay and Aske may point to these with a righteous pride, as the results of their labours, to the good, kindly people at home who trusted in them."
Miss C. F. Gordon Cumming, visiting the South Sea Islands, found in Fiji nine hundred chapels and fourteen hundred schools, built by the people themselves, and occupied by carefully-trained native ministers and teachers. She says: "During a residence of two years in the Fijian Archipelago, I had occasion to visit a large number of these villages. . . . I lived in the midst of the kindly, courteous people; I marked the reverent devoutness of their lives, the simple earnestness of their bearing at the never-failing morning and evening family worship, and frequent church-services; and I found it hard to believe the facts related to me by reliable eye-witnesses of the appalling scenes of carnage, fighting, human sacrifices, most debasing idolatry, and loathsome cannibal feasts, which five, ten, or fifteen years previously, had formed the incidents of daily life in districts where now English ladies and their children may travel, or even settle, in perfect security."
Pioneers of Electricity. By J. MUNRO. Religious Tract Society.
A CAPITAL and readable book, giving the lives of some eleven men, who have opened up this wondrous field of knowledge and usefulness. No novel can surely possess, for a thinking mind, any charms comparable to the interest and information of this book. Alas! that some gifted men should err from Bible teaching, as is evident from the faithful history in this volume. Yet the result of reading this compilation will be, upon the whole, beneficial to any young man; and we therefore commend it to our readers.
A Bunch of Cherries. Gathered by J. W. KIRTON. Partridge and Co.
GOSPEL temperance stories for workingmen, reprinted from the pages of The British Workman. Thus bound together, they form an attractive and useful book.
537
Tibby's Tryst; or, "I will lift up mine eyes unto the hills." By ROBINA F. HARDY. Oliphant and Anderson.
WHILE reading the earlier chapters we had almost formulated a favourable, but somewhat qualified, opinion of "Tibby's Tryst." But when we came to the trysting-place itself, and the discoursings of Miles Murieson, the "Ploughman Preacher", we forgot all qualifications except Miss Hardy's, and even our own disqualifications for appreciating to the full the wit and wisdom which doubtless lie hidden from us English in the wonderful tongue of the Land of Cakes. Those who have read even a few of Miss Hardy's delightful stories will not need to be told what a versatile writer she is, and how she giveth goodly words, while she possesses a keen sense of humour, a combination which will make her books hardy perennials.
Very Far West Indeed; or, The Adventures of Peter Burr. By the late W. H. G. KINGSTON. Sunday School Union.
MR. KINGSTON had a magical power of personally conducting parties all round this terrestrial ball, and giving them the maximum of instruction and pleasure at a minimum of trouble and cost. On this occasion, the journey is from England to Canada, and the cost one shilling. The experiences of one of the party, a young farmer, seeking a home for himself and family in the Far West, are well described, and may prepare intending emigrants to Greater Britain for the rough, laborious, and often dangerous pioneer work of the backwoods settler.
Sister Agnes; a Methodist Story. By SIGISMUND FAIRFAX. Elliot Stock. "A METHODIST Story" indeed! Very fervently do we hope that Methodists will disown this book. "A Ritualistic Story" would have been a more fitting title, for "Ritualism" and "Liturgy" and "Sisterhoods" have a prominent place in this tale. Does this story really indicate the backward movement of Methodism? If so, we are not surprised at the poor preaching that we find at the close of this senseless story. "Be good, therefore, and beautiful," is the substance of the closing address.
This is not the sort of food on which the good old-fashioned Methodists used to feed. If this is the new theology, truly, "the old is better."
Freemen or Slaves. By ELLEN A. BENNETT. Nisbet & Co.
A VERY healthy book for boys. Fewer characters and more detail would have made the story stronger; still, as it is, it is a good tale, well told. For a lad just going into the workshop or factory, it will be a useful present. The writer seems to have the right kind of spirit for dealing with boys and young men.
Adopted; or, an Old Soldier's Embarrassments. By E. A. B. D. Religious Tract Society.
A NEATLY got-up book, containing a well-told story. The tale is that of a stern old soldier, General Marston, whose brother and sister-in-law have died, and left a little family to be provided for. The general adopts them, and the happy little ones lead him to tenderness and simple trust in God. The lion-like old warrior finds it to be still true, "a little child shall lead them." In this "live" book we have living gospel truth presented in a lively way that must do good. If there are young reading folk in the home, by all means let this book be "adopted" into the family.
Peter's Sister. By JANET EDEN. Religious Tract Society.
THE life of a poor charwoman and her family is not a subject that presents much attraction for either writers or readers; but that there is real heroism to be found in the prolonged battle with poverty and temptation of many a poor widow and factory girl, is well known to most Christian workers. This story of patient little Peter and his self-sacrificing sister, commends itself to us because it is evidently the work of one who knows how the industrious poor live, and who seeks to brighten and bless their lives by Christian ministrations. The title should have been "Peter's Sisters." Why so, it would profit many "general servants" and "work-room" girls to find out. Ladies should give this pretty book to any such in whom they are interested.
Sheaves of Ministry. Sermons and Expositions. By JAMES MORISON, D.D. Hodder and Stoughton.
THE author of this portly volume recently celebrated the jubilee of his ministry, amid friendly congratulations and solid tokens of esteem. His views are strongly Arminian, and in some cases he does not speak with the full decision we think warranted by Scripture. Allowing for these drawbacks, as we deem them, there is much in the book worthy of commendation. Time was when Scotia's sons stood in the vanguard of the faith. Alas! her ranks are broken now, her counsels divided, her heroic martyr-spirit, which produced the Covenanters and the Free Church, is, we fear, but historic memory now. Hence, we are thankful to note as great a reverence for Scripture, and as practical a grip of eternal verities, as we find in this volume. In the address on, "Is there
a larger hope?" the case is thus summarized: "While looking wistfully and eagerly throughout Scripture for some door of hope, in reference to those who pass away in utter impenitence, I have failed to find it." Dr. Morison looks through the Gospels in succession; but finds no door. He turns to the Epistles, and the case is substantially the same. Yet he will not say there is no door of hope in the far-off ages of ages. All he says, or can say, is this: in looking carefully and candidly throughout Scripture, he cannot see or find the door. Just so. Our fear, and it is verified by facts, is that others, going with the same wistful longing, but unbalanced by judicial impartiality, will glory in what they think they find. Some of the sermons fall short of full-orbed gospel truth; but they are all plain, practical, and common-sense, while not lacking in scholarship.
