Islam and Moslem

No question should have more interest for the intelligent Christian, whose sympathies extend beyond the narrow bounds of his own country, than the relation of Mohammed and Mohammedanism to Christianity. Remembering the many millions of followers of the false prophet who exist in our Indian empire; the frequent collisions between British valour and Arab fanaticism on the confines of Egypt; the persistent manner in which Mohammedanism, as a system, has been extolled, even by dignitaries of the church; and, finally, the fact that a Moslem mission has been begun in this country, with promises of reinforcements from the East; any serious attempt to array the evidence for and against this religion, which myriads of men still hold as divine, must be gratefully welcomed.
Years ago, Carlyle, in his lecture on "The Hero as a Prophet", said, once and again, "This religion of Mohammed's is a kind of Christianity." This has ever been a favourite dictum of men who stay at home, making the acquaintance of Islam only in the study, and of travellers who, in a hurried journey, see but the best side of Mohammedanism. It is fashionable to speak of it as a connecting link between Paganism and Christianity, whereas the missionaries who have lived longest in the countries where Islam reigns, and who see not only the veneer, but the heart of the religion, lament but too truly that, instead of being a link between the two, it is an almost impassable barrier. No man is harder to win for Christ than a Mohammedan; he has so much to unlearn, and his faith has such a tendency to engender an excessive sense of superiority, and an extreme contempt for anything besides.
Many books have been written on the subject, but the latest, which now lies before us,* by a missionary who has had long experience amongst the people of whom he writes in various countries, is the best analysis of the subject we have seen. Dr. Koelle, who is on terms of personal friendship with Moslems, and yet not blind to the evil of their religion, truly says: "If our goodwill to the Mohammedans is of the sterling kind which wishes to help them into the full daylight of Christian truth, we are more likely to benefit them by frankly pointing out the distortion of the lengthened shadow they are following, and the perfect symmetry of the image it reflects, than by assuring them that however distorted the shadow may be, yet it is not quite so distorted as has been represented."
An impartial view of any faith must begin with its source; hence our attention is chiefly directed to the history of Mohammed (as the name should always be spelled) himself. An intimate acquaintance with Arabic writings enables our author to produce a tolerably clear portrait of what the Meccan prophet must have been apart from the halo of romance which has been thrown around his memory, and which is presented to us in the second part of the book. The third part considers the historical position of Mohammedanism, and the verdict is that it is, and always has been, decidedly anti-Christian, both in nature and practice.
* "Mohammed and Mohammedanism, Critically Considered." By S. W. Koelle, Ph. D. Rivingtons.
Mohammed was born at Mecca, in Arabia, in the year 570, and was the son of Abd-Allah and Fatima his wife. He sprang from one of the most influential families amongst the Koreish Arabs, who had charge of the Kaaba, or sacred house, at Mecca, built beside the well which is supposed to be that at which Hagar quenched the thirst of Ishmael, their forefather. His father died when he was young, and the boy was placed in the charge of Abdu-l-Mattaleb, his grandfather, who was a native of Medina. In his babyhood he was sent away to the country in charge of a wet-nurse: when he was eight years of age his grandfather died, having placed him under the care of another son, the boy's uncle, Abu Talib, who, in later years, befriended him in many ways.
Very early he began to have visions. The fact of the early death of his father and mother, added to the necessity of giving him the benefit of the exhilarating air of the country, place it beyond doubt that he was a delicate boy, suffering probably from hysteria muscularis, a species of epilepsy, during the attacks of which memory retains its ascendency. His frequent revelations from Gabriel were doubtless the result of this morbid condition. While quite a boy he had such a seizure, when out with his foster-brothers, tending the flocks: they ran home affrighted, crying that Mohammed was possessed by an evil spirit. The account he himself gave was, that two men in white clothes stretched him on the ground, split him open, took out his heart, and removing a black clot cast it away: then they washed heart and body in snow water, and weighed him first against ten of his people, then against a hundred, then against a thousand; he outweighed them, so they said, "Leave him now, for if thou put his entire people into the scale, he would outweigh them all."
He accompanied his uncle with the trading caravan to Syria on one occasion; hence has arisen the mistake of thinking of him merely as a camel-driver. By-and-by he took charge of the caravan of a wealthy widow Khadija, and subsequently he married her; while she lived he married no other, but after her death he added one after another until he had nine wives—the worthy prophet!
His prophetship was the product of several factors. The Arabs were at that time split into factions, yet longed for freedom from the Roman power: they had many idols, and all came to Mecca, where, in the Kaaba, were no less than 360 gods, from which they could make their choice. Mohammed's family had charge of this holy place, and the exclusive right of providing for the pilgrims. He was thus brought into touch with all parts of the country, and it was little wonder that he became a patriot.
At that time also there was a sect—the Hanifites—who advocated a reform in religion, insisting on the unity of God, and the spirituality of his worship. With these Mohammed was brought into contact; and what wonder that he became a religious reformer!
Further, he was of a very meditative turn of mind, and, as we have seen, subject to hallucinations. It is not surprising, then, that this combination of circumstances should make him the patriot-prophet!
For patriot, as well as prophet, he always was. The lovely pictures which have been given to us of the young man setting forth with pure zeal for God, but afterwards warped by opposition, are wholly mythical. Many of the Hanifites became Christians; and if Mohammed
651
had not deliberately shut his eyes, his earnest search might have led him to the same goal of rest, instead of which he set himself up as a prophet who outshone Jesus in everything. Dr. Koelle, in the second part of this interesting book, gives fifty circumstances in which Mohammed caricatured the holy prophet of Nazareth; and, elsewhere, as clearly shows that the political object of uniting the Arabs and throwing off the yoke of the Persians and Romans was in his mind from the beginning.
"Before the coming down of the Koran", says an Arab writer, "for a space of eleven years Mohammed was hearing voices without seeing any person: and for the space of seven years was seeing a light." During this period he was accustomed, like many other Arabs, to spend the summer in the mountains with his wife and family, and in this retirement in a cave he had some of his most startling trances. On the blessed night of El Kadar, according to traditional accounts, he was awakened at midnight by Gabriel, who was accompanied by 50,000 angels. The early vision of the heart-washing was repeated, and then mounting some animal called "Borak" (which evidently is a corruption of the Hebrew word for lightning, "Barak", seeing he would require to go at high speed to accomplish the journey before him), he was carried to the temple of El Aksa at Jerusalem, and from thence ascended to heaven, where all the angelic hosts did him reverence. After many honours were paid to him, God himself invited him a thousand times to come nearer, until he came to the place of "Nearness", then to the place of "Intimacy", and then into the innermost Sanctuary, only a bow-shot from the throne of God, upon which his fervid imagination saw written the legend which henceforth became the watchword of his followers, and is daily chanted by the faithful muezzins on the minarets of thousands of mosques,— "There is no God but Allah, and Mohammed is his prophet." That this visit to heaven and Jerusalem really took place, in the short space of three hours of the night, is a prime article in the creed of the Moslem. At Jerusalem I was gravely shown a mark on the Dome of the Rock, under the Mosque of Omar, which I was informed was made by the hand of Gabriel as he held back the rock, as it, by the holy attraction of Mohammed's person, was following him to heaven. The mark is there—what further room is there for doubt?
From the age of forty until he was fifty-three, the prophet, now fully convinced of his mission, preached it in and around Mecca, at first secretly until he had made a few disciples, his beloved Khadija being the first, and then, amid much opposition, more openly.
We cannot agree with Mr. Gilman, in the volume The Saracens, in "The Story of the Nations" Series (from which our portrait of Mohammed is taken, by the kind permission of Mr. T. Fisher Unwin), that "the new prophet did not seem to have any ulterior objects in his mind as he entered upon his mission," but we heartily echo his words that the mission itself was "either the sublimest impudence or most wonderful faith."
After thirteen years prophesying at Mecca—his wife, who counselled him, and his uncle, who protected him, being dead—he fled to Medina, where already he had made disciples, and where the people were not
653
unwilling to receive him, first, because they had a feud with Mecca, and next, because his grandfather had been a native of their city.
Here, first, the new faith, that "amalgam of God and the world", took root. The wily prophet made much use of his inspired camel, here and elsewhere, asserting that it would be guided by God to stop at the place where he was to stay, thus avoiding any jealousy on the part of his followers, which might have been manifested had he chosen himself. A mosque was built, and the new worship set in order. Much of the sacred book—the Koran—was here revealed, a Sura, or chapter, being given to extricate Mohammed from any difficulty as it arose.
The military spirit became at once manifest: caravans from Mecca were attacked, sometimes being captured, oftener missed. Several battles were fought. Mohammed was unsuccessfully besieged in Medina; and, at length, so far conquered his enemies, that he was permitted to visit Mecca with his followers, and worship at the Kaaba, while all the Meccans vacated the city. Mr. Gilman, from whom again we quote, may well say, "When before had there been such a scene? When since? When did a populace go out of their houses to permit a body of religionists, to whose observances they were hostile, to enter in and occupy, not their streets and their houses only, but their very temples and their altars?" This visit of the new leader, accompanied as he was by about two thousand followers, deeply impressed the Meccans with a sense of his power; and in the beginning of the next year, when he came against the city with ten thousand men, he had little trouble in conquering it. At once he hurled down the three hundred and sixty idols from their places in the temple, and exhorted the people to worship only one God, seeing they now believed Mohammed to be his prophet. To his honour be it said, that he treated very kindly those who, in the early days of his career, mocked at his claim.
"What can you expect at my hands?" he said to their leaders.
"Mercy, O generous brother!" they replied.
"Be it so: ye are free!"
Soon Islam, which means "the faith", spread over all Arabia, and the people became Moslems, which means "just men", or, as others have it, "resigned or surrendered men." Mecca continued to be their holy city, and to this day every faithful Moslem turns towards it when he prays. A curious example of this may be seen at St. Sophia, at Constantinople, which was built first for a Christian cathedral, and faces towards Jerusalem; but now, used by the Moslems, the prayer-carpets have to be placed at an angle on the floor, to allow the worshippers to look more to the south.
Mohammed clearly proclaimed that there was only one God, a truth greatly forgotten in those days, even by the Christians, who were already beginning the image worship of the apostate churches. So far his creed was good. At first he was friendly to the Jews, hoping to win them to his standard. When he failed, he treated them brutally, his action towards them at Medina being one of the most infamous of his life. He was well acquainted with the Christian gospels, and, no doubt, jumbled much of his teaching from them and the Old Testament. He declared he was "the Paraclete", whom Jesus promised. Most ludicrously, on another occasion, he referred that other text to himself, "The prince of this world cometh, and hath nothing in me," saying he
was "the prince of this world." Perhaps, indeed, he had a nearer connection with Satan than he imagined; for despite the truth in the system, it was from the beginning bitterly opposed to Christianity.
After ten years at Medina, Mohammed died; but even while he breathed his last, an expedition to Syria was starting. With terrible rapidity the faith spread, until in a few years it reached Persia and Egypt, surging on through Asia Minor, to be stopped for centuries at Constantinople; passing unhindered along Africa, into Spain. "Death or Islam" was the war-ery; what wonder that Islam triumphed!
Condé, in his History of the Arabs in Spain, recounts the deeds of the Moslems in Western Europe. Taric, their general, embodied the spirit of the faith. "The enemies are before you, but behind you is the sea," he said to his soldiers; "there is no help for you save in your own valour and in the aid of God. Oh, therefore, warriors and Moslemah!"
There is no space for more, though the subject is too vast even to be treated in outline in a few pages. We cordially recommend Dr. Koelle's volume. We have scarcely noticed the second book here, but it is full of interest. It shows that, in the traditional history of Mohammed, there are many rivalries with the history of Christ, and seeing that "the antecedent cannot imitate the consequent, the later biography can only be a designed, though more or less disguised, copy of the earlier."
Might I direct the attention of the student of this subject to the ninth chapter of the Book of Revelation, and ask him to consider whether this is not God's history of Mohammedanism, written long before Mohammed was born? As a key, take these words, which were spoken about Mohammed: "Verily, in the seas his name is Destroyer, for he will destroy all idolatry;" and compare with the marginal reading of verse 11. Notice, also, in connection with verse 5, where the woe is said to last for one hundred and fifty days, that from the time when Mohammed first declared that his faith was to be spread by the sword (A.D. 612), until the Saracen Caliphate was removed to Bagdad (A.D. 762), was exactly one hundred and fifty years. Notice, again, in connection with verse 15, that the second woe was to last a little over three hundred and ninety-six days; and in effect the irruption of the Turks began on 18th January, 1059, and on 29th May, 1458, Constantinople fell, being a period of three hundred and ninety-four years. Is this only coincidence?
In conclusion, however great the barrier the false faith puts in the way of the gospel, Christ must at length conquer. On the front-door of the mosque at St. Sophia, at Constantinople, there is a motto in Greek, which has been allowed to remain when all other Christian inscriptions have been carefully removed. This evidently was not understood; yet there it remains to-day, an impetus to the efforts of the servants of Christ, who seek to supplant the Crescent by the Cross,— JESUS CHRIST ASSISTS THEE. And on the side of the mosque at Damascus, there is another Christian inscription, forgotten by the Moslems; I have climbed on the top of the silversmith's bazaar, and read it; is it not a prophecy of the doom of Islam?—"HIS KINGDOM IS AN EVERLASTING KINGDOM, AND HIS DOMINION IS FROM GENERATION TO GENERATION."
So we have no doubt as to the end.
W. Y. F.
