The Substitute—a Coincidence
RICHARD CRASHAW and Augustus Montague Toplady were far apart in some of their theological and ecclesiastical opinions and principles. At least a century and a quarter elapsed between the best known poem of the one, and the immortal "Rock of Ages" of the other; but there is a striking coincidence between them in some of their utterances in relation to the mediation, the substitution, and the suretyship of the Lord Jesus Christ.
As the second translator of Thomas of Celano's great judgment hymn (Dies Irec) into English (in 1646), Crashaw deserves to be remembered, as also for a few other of his poetical pieces. In order to show the remarkable coincidence, we will first quote a few verses, beginning with the fifth, of that remarkable hymn:—
"O that book! whose leaves so bright
Will set the world in severe light;
O that Judge! whose hand, whose eye,
None can endure—yet none can fly.
"Ah, then, poor soul, what wilt thou say?
And to what patron choose to pray,
When stars themselves shall stagger, and
The most firm foot no more shall stand?
"But thou giv'st leave, dread Lord, that we
Take shelter from thyself in thee;
And with the wings of thine own dove
Fly to the shelter of thy love.
"Dear Lord, remember in that day
Who was the cause thou can'st this way:
Thy sheep was strayed; and thou wouldst be
Even lost thyself in seeking me.
Shall all that labour, all that cost
Of love, and e'en that loss, be lost?
And this loved soul judged worth no less
Than all that way and weariness?
"Just Mercy, then, thy reckoning be
With my price, and not with me:
'Twas paid at first with too much pain,
To be paid twice, or once in vain."
Thus wrote Richard Crashaw. Toplady, in verses less stiff and more easy, expresses the same sentiments in his hymn on "The Substitute." Mr. Spurgeon has given the hymn a place in "Our Own Hymn Book" (404), but the version is slightly altered in the first and last verses. With all due deference, however, we prefer the hymn as Toplady is supposed to have written and left it.
"From whence this fear and unbelief?
Hast thou, O Father, put to grief
Thy spotless Son for me?
And will the righteous Judge of men
Condemn me for that debt of sin
Which, Lord, was charged on thee?
185
"Complete atonement thou hast made,
And to the utmost farthing paid
Whate'er thy people owed:
How then can wrath on me take place,
If sheltered in thy righteousness,
And sprinkled with thy blood?
"If thou hast my discharge procured,
And freely in my room endured
The whole of wrath divine,
Payment God cannot twice demand,
First at my bleeding Surety's hand,
And then again at mine.
"Turn, then, my soul, unto thy rest;
The merits of thy Great High Priest
Speak peace and liberty;
Trust in his efficacious blood,
Nor fear thy banishment from God,
Since Jesus died for thee."
The lines in italics exhibit the chief points of coincidence.
Toplady, though dead more than a century, is so much, in his hymns at least, a living poet, that we have only to name him. Crashaw, on the other hand, as he was a poet rather than a hymn writer, has no such distinction, and is known only as a poetic star, and not of the first magnitude, shining in the far past of the first half of the seventeenth century. A beneficed clergyman in the reign of Charles I., he lost his post, either through his antagonism to the action of the Parliament, or because he did not satisfy the "Triers", who weighed every minister and candidate in the scales adjusted after the Cromwellian ideas of Scriptural truth. Probably he was too much of a churchman, and too much of a Royalist, to make it safe to entrust him with a parish. Judging from his poems, he doubtless dwelt more on the subjective than the objective phases of divine truth; and with the Triers doctrinal soundness must needs have a foremost place, so that a man was nothing if in his creed he did not weigh full weight. It is possible to err here, but commonly this is the safest course. Anyhow, Crashaw was right at heart, even though his head was not fully in keeping. But he was not far out of the right line, if he could write such heavenly thoughts as these, which, despite their quaintness, bear marks of a supernatural mint:—
"Lord, when the sense of thy sweet grace
Sends up my soul to seek thy face,
Thy blessed eyes breed such desire,
I die in love's delicious fire.
O Love! I am thy sacrifice;
Be still triumphant! Blessed eyes,
Still shine on me—fair suns! that I
May still behold, though still I die.
"Though still I die, I live again,
Still longing so to be still slain;
So gainful is such loss of breath,
I die even in desire of death.
Still live in me this loving strife
Of living death and dying life;
For while thou sweetly slayest me,
Dead to myself, I live to thee."
The soundness of the man whose heart could gush with such heavenly thoughts, and flow in such divine melody, no one has a right to question; even though, as in his case, in the later years of his life, his ecclesiastical notions ran away with him, and he drifted on to the barren rock of papal supremacy. His declension and perversion must indeed be deeply deplored; but while we contemplate his weakness, and error, and folly, let us all pray for heavenly guidance, and to be constantly upheld by the right hand of him who never fails those who trust in him. But we gladly accept his Scriptural teaching as to the great Substitute, and his blessed work of atonement and redemption. The work of Christ was nothing if it were not substitutionary. He was made sin for us. He gave himself "the Just for the unjust." "Christ hath redeemed us from the curse of the law, being made a curse for us." Can anything be plainer? Can anything be more wisely and exactly suited to our need, and to the requirements of the law as needing to be fulfilled, by One who had never broken it, for us whose breaches of it are numberless? O God! we thankfully accept it as wise, and holy, and gracious; and all the outcome of thy wondrous love to us in Christ Jesus, thy Son, and our Lord.
While, therefore, we keep in mind the sound teaching of both the early poet and the later hymn-writer, we may still pray with the former, in the fourteenth and fifteenth verses of his Dies Inc:—
"Though both my prayers and tears combine,
Both worthless are, for they are mine:
But thou, thy bounteous self still be,
And show thou art, by saving me.
"Oh, when thy last frown shall proclaim
The flocks of goats to folds of flame,
And all thy lost sheep found shall be,
Let 'Come ye blessed', then call me."
