I want to welcome you to Sermon Index. This is a gem of the internet.
I would like to review the facts and give you a chance to expand, clarify and share what happened from your point of view.
I have read several accounts of the events surrounding the removal and subsequent refusal to host your film.
Based on what I read, the film was uploaded to YouTube and initially viewable to only to a membership-only group of people.
Soon thereafter, the status was changed to unlisted. This means that the only way to view the film was with a direct link. You could not find the film using the YouTube search feature. At this point only people who had gotten the link via message or email were able to view it. So the viewers where friends and friends of friends of the project.
In this unlisted stage, someone viewed it and hit the "Flag," or Report, button. This system allows any user or computer controlled bot to file a complaint. These complaints are not about copyright issues, that is a completely different system.
This is a video by a popular YouTuber and his experience.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HBtVVMrjy68. (8 minutes)
So to sum up so far, the film was flagged before it was openly available on YouTube. Someone didn't like it for some reason or, like what was mentioned in the above link, a computer program may have erroneously flagged it.
Joshua, is all of this accurate so far?
So your next option was to appeal the flag. In the YouTube system you are extremely limited in how much you can say, I think it's about 300-1000 characters (letters, punctuation and spaces). That's almost nothing.
If you decide to try to find out more information from YouTube, it is extremely difficult. Even well known YouTube creators who are bringing in tons of ad revenue for the company need good connections to get any answers. The system is designed to work like one of those automated phone answering systems you come across when you call large corporations where you have to talk to a computer before getting to a real person. The difference is that it is almost impossible to talk to a real person in YouTube.
Many YouTube producers are members of YouTube media networks. These networks assist their members for a share of their ad revenue. As a result they provide support and protection in dealing with flagging and copyright claims. However, even having this support may not be enough.
Joshua, are you part of one of these networks?
So you made your appeal and someone, or something, reviewed the video and upheld the strike. Because the system only allows one appeal, you were not able to escalate it nor get any real answers.
At this point you decided to try to host the video on Vimeo.
Can you explain why you needed to get a Pro membership?
In the description on Vimeo, it shows that you have decided to make the film available on DVD versus freely downloadable from the site.
Can you explain your thinking on this?
Based on the figures shared about the funds donated by the church you are serving with and the money raised through the KickStarter campaign, the budget was about $1500 short. Did that come out of your pocket?
Can you give us an update on how things have progressed since the original post on this thread a few weeks ago?
Finally, can you share about any future projects God has put on your heart at this time?
Thank you for making yourself available. He is Risen!