Menu
Karaoke Then Lecture
E.A. Johnston
0:00
0:00 6:00
E.A. Johnston

Karaoke Then Lecture

E.A. Johnston · 6:00

E.A. Johnston challenges the modern church's complacency by contrasting today's non-offensive sermons with the powerful, convicting preaching of historical revivalists who called for genuine repentance and spiritual transformation.
In 'Karaoke Then Lecture,' E.A. Johnston critiques the modern church's tendency toward non-offensive, superficial preaching that fails to provoke true spiritual change. Drawing on the examples of revivalist preachers like George Whitfield and John Song, Johnston calls for a return to bold, convicting messages that confront sin and call for repentance. This sermon challenges believers to examine their hearts and embrace a faith that transforms.

Full Transcript

An oriental pastor visited some churches during his stay in America, and when asked what he thought about the preaching, he replied, first karaoke, then lecture. We prepare sermons today as essays to consider. You can take or leave them, and either way, you leave the sanctuary the same way you came in, unchanged.

But George Whitfield was a powerful preacher in his day, who probed his hearer's conscience with the doctrine of regeneration. Whitfield cried across two continents, you must be born again. Whitfield preached for spiritual change because he knew personally what it was like to have a form of religion without being born again.

While he was preaching on Boston Common in 1740 to 20,000 hearers, a minister asked him, Mr. Whitfield, how many converts have you had since you've been among us? To which Whitfield replied, I don't know, sir, but I shall pass these parts again in a year or so, and I will then look for the evidence of their salvation. Searching preaching leads men to examine their hearts, to test the foundation they rest upon, like the Apostle Paul warned his hearers in 2 Corinthians 13.5. Examine yourselves, whether ye be in the faith. Prove your own selves.

Know ye not your own selves, how that Jesus Christ is in you, except ye be reprobates. But I fear, friends, I'd have to agree with the Oriental pastor, because we in our churches in America today, it's first karaoke, then a lecture. The probing preaching of former days, that birth-revival, was searching preaching from men like Jonathan Edwards and Asahel Nettleton.

Their messages dealt with sin and God's justice and man's inability and man's duty of repentance. Their searching sermons were like a hammer that broke up all false foundations, like a fire that alarmed. Does not God's word in Jeremiah describe it so? It's not my word, like as a fire, saith the Lord, and like a hammer that breaketh the rock in pieces.

Preachers whom God has used in powerful revivals, like John Song, who shook all of China for God. Song's searching preaching dealt with sin and repentance. He had a sermon entitled, Open Your Coffin, and while he preached, he held a little wooden casket in his hand, and he would open the lid and pull out pieces of paper that had sins written on them.

He would read the sin, like adultery or fornication or lying, and then he would ask his audience to raise their hand when they heard their sin. The Holy Spirit often descended on a John Song meeting because Jesus came to save sinners from their sin, and Song preached on sin. He dealt with his listeners' sins.

People would weep like babies over their sins in his meetings. But we don't like to talk about sin today because we don't want to preach disturbing messages, for if we did, we may upset some of our deacons, and we can't have that. Our hands are tied because we fear man more than God.

It's like the story Sam Jones used to tell. I once knew a pastor who, upon taking charge of his church, was met by a delegation of the deacons previous to delivering his inaugural sermon. They said, Now, brother, you mustn't preach against fashion because our fashionable members will be out to hear you.

You mustn't preach about tram drinking or liquor selling because several of our members who are liquor sellers will be out to hear you. You mustn't preach about covetousness because several of our millionaire members will be out to hear you. Well, what can I preach about? he asked in great perplexity.

About the Mormons, replied the good deacons. Give them places. There won't be a Mormon to hear you.

Now, fear, friends, that's our trouble today. We give out nice little lectures to consider that don't offend anybody. The trouble is they don't change anybody either.

First karaoke, then a lecture. That's where we are today. I fear, in America today, the bane of the church is self-preservation.

The gospel message is all about us, served on a platter at a sumptuous banquet table, laden with appealing delicacies. Other generations preached up the blood and the cross and called sin black and hell hot. John the Baptist had a platter with his head upon it.

Stephen was baptized with stones. Paul finished his ministry not with accolades and applause but with a falling axe. The blood of the martyrs cries out against the self-absorbed church of this generation.

Let us pray.

Sermon Outline

  1. I. The State of Modern Preaching
    • Sermons today resemble essays with little impact
    • The 'karaoke then lecture' critique from an oriental pastor
    • Lack of spiritual change in contemporary churches
  2. II. The Power of Historical Revival Preachers
    • George Whitfield's call to be born again
    • Jonathan Edwards and Asahel Nettleton's searching sermons
    • John Song's convicting preaching on sin
  3. III. The Fear of Offending and Its Consequences
    • Avoidance of preaching on sin to not upset church members
    • Self-preservation over boldness in the church
    • The story of the pastor constrained by deacons' demands
  4. IV. The Call to Genuine Spiritual Transformation
    • Contrast with martyrs who suffered for the gospel
    • The blood of martyrs condemns self-absorbed churches
    • A plea for revival and bold preaching

Key Quotes

“We prepare sermons today as essays to consider. You can take or leave them, and either way, you leave the sanctuary the same way you came in, unchanged.” — E.A. Johnston
“I fear, in America today, the bane of the church is self-preservation.” — E.A. Johnston
“The blood of the martyrs cries out against the self-absorbed church of this generation.” — E.A. Johnston

Application Points

  • Examine your own faith honestly and seek genuine spiritual transformation.
  • Embrace preaching that challenges and convicts rather than simply entertains.
  • Overcome fear of offending others by prioritizing faithfulness to God's word.

Frequently Asked Questions

What does 'karaoke then lecture' mean in the context of this sermon?
It refers to modern sermons being entertaining or superficial ('karaoke') followed by a mild, non-confrontational message ('lecture') that fails to provoke real spiritual change.
Who was George Whitfield and why is he mentioned?
George Whitfield was a powerful revival preacher known for urging people to be born again, exemplifying the kind of searching preaching the speaker advocates.
Why does the speaker criticize contemporary preaching?
Because it avoids confronting sin and repentance, aiming not to offend anyone, which results in no real transformation among listeners.
What role does fear play in the modern church according to the sermon?
Fear of offending influential members leads to watered-down messages and self-preservation rather than boldness in preaching the gospel.
What is the ultimate call of this sermon?
To return to preaching that convicts, challenges, and leads to genuine spiritual revival and repentance.

Everything we make is available for free because of a generous community of supporters.

Donate