Cowper's Calvinism — By Edward Leach
THE Papuan race, it is said, is alone among the nations of the world in its utter destitution of any love for the flowers of poesy. The innocence of supersensuous feeling has hitherto been allowed to all men possessed of an impressible nature. The play of fancy, the youthful sweetness of efflorescent love, the beauties of art, and the gentle breezes of wooing poetry, have attractions to great and small, to wise and unwise. He who appreciates the rhymester's art cannot be altogether morally corrupt: so at least runs the world's argument. But who cares about Calvinistic poetry? To sing in praise of the absolute freedom of the will, to chant the glories of man's moral nature and its subjection to holy influences, to magnify our glorious selves, to exalt a nature which modern philosophy persists in describing as Godlike—all this is accounted practical, understandable, beautiful. But to popularize in poetry's sunny page the stern angularity of a narrowed creed, and wreathe the blossoms of fancy around the coarseness of a nauseous theology, is a task impossible and absurd. To hush into oblivion the boastings of man's natural moral goodness, to make his salvation depend on naught but grace, to unrobe him of all his pretentious glory, is a work unsuited to poetry, and likely to degrade the poet and his verse.
So decides the Dilettanti. To him there is no real alliance between Calvinism and poetry. He would prefer his imagination to be convulsed with some of the rhythmical chapters of the Koran, rather than with covenant-extolling songs. Yet Christendom has no need to be ashamed of its poets. Who excelled David? What Edward Irving calls "the oceans of feeling poured into David's soul," and the "true and graceful utterance of poetry infused into his lips," were but the inspiration of Calvinistic truth conveyed in lofty numbers. Since the Hebrew monarch many poets have sung, and not a few have magnified the name of the Lord in solemn songs, graced "with many a wild, indeed, but flowery spray;" and it is to a modern high-art Christian poet's muse, the writer seeks to direct the reader's attention. Cowper's Calvinism breathes through nearly every page of his serious poems. In his letters, there is no mistake as to his theological soundness; but with them the writer chooses not to deal. It is as strongly developed in his hymns; but as the reader may be more versed in them than in the poems, it is convenient that they should not be further referred to. A dip into his volume of poems will be no unprofitable employment, and may lead to a closer study of them. He who thoroughly understands Cowper's theology as conveyed in his poems, will never henceforth ascribe wrong motives to Calvin's Calvinism. The poet detested "doctrines warpt to what they never meant," and exposed the
"Arts sagacious dupes invent,
To cheat themselves and gain the world's assent,"
the worst of which is "Scripture warped from its intent." Consequently, whenever we meet with a doctrinal sentiment, we find it fearlessly expressed, as though the author was aware how much he might be misunderstood, and therefore he preferred the gibe to a timid interpretation. Herein let us see a commendable example!
It is impossible for the mind to conceive clearer representations than Cowper gave of human depravity. The age in which he lived gave the cold shoulder to this searching truth. It was, therefore, the more necessary to proclaim it unmistakably. Certain morality-mongering persons might protest, but a poet who reckons Paul the model and standard preacher would not be likely to fear feeble mimics. It is sad to picture man as going wrong "with an ingenious skill," and as like those,
"Who with a clear and shining lamp supplied,
First put it out, then take it for a guide."
Sad that unregenerate man should be
"An instrument, whose cords upon the stretch,
And strained to the last screw that he can bear,
Yield only discord in the Maker's ear."
Sad, doubtless, to mighty ones of earth that spiritual ignorance is lunacy; and that the soul is so lost that she is "fallen from her glory, and too weak to rise." Sad also to the poor but proud, that they "set their faces as a rock" against God's best gift, which "they scoll at and refuse." And oh! how sad—
"Man is the genuine offspring of revolt,
Stubborn and sturdy as a wild ass colt."
Unpalatable truths, Mr. Dilettante! But truths which the noblest and best of men receive, and are thankful for receiving.
As if to permanently offend the Pharisaic world, divine sovereignty must be described, and beautifully eulogised.
"The cross!
There, and there only, is the power to save."
"The half mankind" which maintains a churlish strife with "the Donor of eternal life," is sternly told that—
"Where all
Stand chargeable with guilt, and to the shafts
Of wrath obnoxious, God may choose his mark.
May punish, if he please, the less, to warn
The more malignant."
Not less emphatic is the poet's utterance of the correlative truth of man's responsibility. Cowper does not so frequently allude to this doctrine as to others. He however takes pains in his poem on the "Progress of Error," to show how man possesses an elective voice for good and evil, and with what struggles those principles seek to gain the mastery:—
"Free in his will to choose or to refuse,
Man may improve the crisis, or abuse;
Else, on the fatalist's unrighteous plan,
Say to what bar amenable were man?
With nought in charge he could betray no trust;
And if he fell, would fall because he must."
This quotation will doubtless shock the hyper-Calvinistic ear, but its disdain suppression where the truth has received such strong Scriptural
429
confirmation. That man should be punished without strong warnings and earnest entreaties, is not according to the genius of the gospel:—
"Divine authority within man's breast,
Brings every thought, word, action, to the test;
Warns him, or prompts, approves him, or restrains,
As reason, or as passion, takes the reins,
Heaven from above, and conscience from within,
Cry in his startled ear—Abstain from sin."
The world's pleasures, lust's treacherous fires, and the sordid gains of a present state, pull contrariwise, as saith the Saviour, "the cares of this world, and the deceitfulness of riches, and the lusts of other things entering in, choke the word, and it becometh unfruitful." Happy the man who listens to God's solemn warnings, trusts his word, and flies for refuge to the Saviour.
This thought brings us to Cowper's favourite topic—the plan of salvation. The Arminian differs from the Calvinistic theory, in regard not only to the implantation of the seeds of Divine grace, but also to the roots of man's salvation. By a species of intellectual obfuscation, in the Arminian's judgment, man has the credit given him of making his peace with God, and taking the seeds of grace and depositing them in his own heart. When the roots strike deep into the earth, and the Christian ripens into spiritual manhood, the life and vigour are represented as man's; and all that grace is supposed to do is to enrich the soil, and so quicken the soul's energy. Thus the difference between the Arminian and the Calvinist is, that the one deals in "vulgar" ideas, whilst the other has "learned" ideas (using these terms in a logical sense, and according to the definition of the schoolmen). The one sees that it is man's duty to believe, and is content with his knowledge of this "vulgar" or apparent fact. The other seeks to penetrate further into the cause, nature, and effect of this faith, and he therefore sees what is hidden from the common understanding. Arminianism is the consummation of spiritual obliquity; it is the one-sided view of prismatic truth; the study of reflection, the neglect of refraction. It judges a straight stick crooked when half submerged in water; it catches at the shadow of truth, and misses the more pleasurable substance. In short, it starves on humanity, instead of feeding* on Divinity; it robs itself of higher, holier joys, and seeks to fish up with earthly grapnel man's lost perfection. But Calvinism dispenses with the assistance of human helplessness, and clings solely to God's strong arm. It sinks vanity, and sends audacious free-will back—
"To the vile dust, from whence it sprung,
Unwept, unhonoured, and unsung."
A few references to Cowper's delineation of the plan of salvation will show with what clearness he apprehended Divine truth. Having described in his poem on "Truth" man's toil for the reward of virtue and consequent loss of it, he shews that grace alone leads the way to virtue and to godliness; and that he who chooses the wrong path—the road
* "For my flesh is meat indeed, and my blood is drink indeed."—St. John vi. 55.
of works—commits wilful suicide. He thus breaks forth into joyful song:—
"Oh, how unlike the complex works of man,
Heav'n's easy, artless, unencumber'd plan!
No meretricious graces to beguile,
No clust'ring ornaments to clog the pile;
From ostentation as from weakness free,
It stands like the cerulean arch we see,
Majestic in its own simplicity.
Inserib'd above the portal, from afar
Conspicuous as the brightness of a star,
Legible only by the light they give,
Stand the soul-quick'ning words—BELIEVE AND LIVE."
So simple is this gospel that wayward, proud, and impious man refuses heaven on such terms, and prefers to perish. Not so tho convinced sinner—
"When he feels
A glowing dread of vengeance at his heels."
Glad to escape where mercy evermore abides, he trusts the Saviour's merits, and—
"'Tis done—the raging storm is heard no more,
Mercy receives him on her peaceful shore:
And justice, guardian of the dread command,
Drops the red vengeance from his willing hand."
In his poem on "Hope," Cowper returns to this delightful subject, and sings melodiously of an "unbought bliss," and of a joyous pardon, free and eternal, of which he says that as soon as the news of it has pierced the sinner's ear—
"He drops at once his fetters and his fear."
Let the reader follow the author's thoughts from that part of Book V. "The Task," commencing—
"He is the freeman whom the truth makes free,
And all are slaves beside,"
to the close of the book. Such an apostrophe to Christian liberty, the effect of sovereign and free grace, was never before penned by uninspired poet. Indeed, the freeness and extent of God's mercy engendered some delicious thoughts in the poet's mind:—
"The silver trumpet's heavenly call
Sounds for the poor, but sounds alike for all."
Still the poor have always heard the gospel most thankfully, for there is—
"No soil like poverty for growth divine,
As leanest land supplies the richest wine."
The rich seem to cavil or hesitate, while the poor "believe, rush forward, and obtain the prize." This divine election sounds distastefully to unrenewed man, whose creed is—
"He is safe that does his best,
And death's a doom sufficient for the rest."
To talk of the "sacramental host of God's elect" to such prodigies of human pride, is to throw God's pearl before swine. It would be as hopeless a task to convert the anthropologists to common sense and
431
Christianity, as to seek to convince unsaved man of his utter ruin. When fallen humanity kicks against God's Word, it is folly to expect a better reception for man's advice.
We had noted some dozens of quotations upon other branches of Calvinistic truth. Let a few suffice on the doctrine of imputed righteousness. In his eloquent address, at the opening meeting of the Birmingham congress of the British Association, the other day, Professor Phillips spoke of the vapourous atmosphere acting as a warm clothing to the earth. Now, with many who understand it not, the doctrine of imputed righteousness is as a kind of vapourous atmosphere, which is supposed to chill the love of good works in the Christian man. Folly indeed! It is like heaven's dew benignly warming and fructifying nature's barren soil. Like holy oil, Christ's imputed righteousness makes the wheels of good works to run briskly. Ye who know what it is to be stripped of the filthy rags of human weaving, and to be clothed with the spotless robes the Saviour wrought, may heartily join in Cowper's noble, joyous declaration—
"Since the dear hour that brought me to thy foot,
And cut up all my follies by the root,
I never trusted in an arm but thine,
Nor hoped, but in thy righteousness divine:
My prayers and alms, imperfect and defiled,
Were but the feeble efforts of a child;
However performed, it was their brightest part,
That they proceeded from a grateful heart;
Cleansed in thine own all-purifying blood,
Forgive their evil and accept their good;
I cast them at thy feet—my only plea
Is what it was, dependence upon thee."
For him who boasts of his own sacrifices for virtue, or ministrations to the poor, Cowper utters this anathema:—
"Perish the virtue, as it ought, abhorred,
And the fool with it, who insults his Lord."
These extracts, good reader, are selected here and there from a goodly store of Scripture truth, encircled with poetry's cheerful sunshine. I, there be in souls "a sympathy with sounds;" if the soft music of village bells falls sweetly on the ear; if genuine art freshens the intellect and gives refined grace to earth's rustic beauties; and if Nature's stores unrolled captivate man's attention, so true poetry,—consecrated to God's glory, embosoming within itself the blessed experiences of a renewed nature, and telling out in lofty strains the matchless perfections of God, who by oaths and promises has secured our glorious charter to an eternal inheritance in the skies,—may kindle in our breasts some fresh sparks of love to Him who inspired the song.
A few who read this short paper may think this high doctrine, this eternal security will lead to a disregard of holiness:—
"I am no preacher, let this hint suffice,
The cross once seen is death to every vice:
Else, He that hung there suffered all his pain,
Bled, groaned, and agonized, and died in vain."
Camberwell.
