Menu
‹ Chapter 195 of 241 ›

The Church of England

15 min read · Chapter 195 of 241

WE purpose to offer a few remarks upon the origin of the Established Church of England, and to notice some of the circumstances which first determined her policy and guided her subsequent actions. We think this examination necessary because we have seen, with considerable astonishment, that a large number of adherents to the Established Church are, on this matter, avowedly ignorant, or at best, in a state of confused, and, as it were, self-imposed unconsciousness. We think it important also, because we believe that in this nineteenth century, it would be well to come, if possible, to a clear understanding of this question, and to prove, from known facts, whether there be any real basis, or warrant, for the assumption, by this Church, of a divinely-conferred prerogative for special authority and peculiar sanctity. Necessarily, in this place, only an outline of the subject can be given.

It will help us at the outset, if we glance at one notable circumstance in the history of the Reformation, as it affected England. Luther and Calvin in Germany and France, Zwingle in Switzerland, and John Knox in Scotland, were men whose souls had become inflamed with an intense zeal for the religious principles of the Reformation; hence, in those countries, there was kindled a strong religious enthusiasm. It was far otherwise in England. Here no fiery preacher went everywhere proclaiming the new doctrines. The great majority of the people were comparatively indifferent, although divided in opinion, and appeared willing to tolerate both religions. Then came the great secession. Henry the Eighth threw off the yoke of Rome, for very good reasons of his own, in regard to first-fruits, vacant bishoprics, and monk's treasures. That he was not influenced by any love for the doctrines of Luther, let the Bloody Statute bear witness! Besides Henry, the principal authors of the Reformation in England were the Duke of Somerset, an unscrupulous aspirant for political power, Elizabeth, and Archbishop Cranmer; in the words of Macaulay: "The work which had been begun by Henry, the murderer of his wives, was continued by Somerset, the murderer of his brother, and completed by Elizabeth, the murderer of her guest."† The object of Henry was to unite all political and ecclesiastical power in himself. The object of his successors was to strengthen, by an alliance with the Protestant party, the despotic power of the crown. Yet further to strengthen this bulwark for arbitrary power, nonconformity was regarded as disloyalty, and the most odious and cruel laws were enacted against Papists and Puritans. Hence, an Established Church became, through its very nature and constitution, a persecuting Church. During Mary's reign the process was simply reversed. To ascribe the religious persecutions instituted by Elizabeth, to a genuine love for Protestantism, is absurd, in the face of the

* We do not endorse our contributor's view of our own position in the great struggle; we only wish we were as able as he kindly conceives us to be. His style is such that we shall be much mistaken if our readers do not desire to hear more from him. Personally we shall certainly be very grateful for further communications.

† "Essay on Hallam's Constitutional History:" to which the reader is referred for much interesting matter, of which we have given a bare outline; as also to the "Essay on Lord Burleigh."

433

clearest evidence that she clung persistently, throughout her whole life, to much of the doctrine and ceremonialism of the Church of Rome; while Lord Burleigh, her chief adviser and prime minister during forty years, had been Papist and Protestant by turns, with each successive change in the dominant religion.

From the foregoing review of the origin of the Church of England, we think some light is thrown upon her subsequent history. It is evident that the supremacy of the Church of England has been, from of old, a political supremacy; conferred, and fittingly maintained by the help of persecution, for political ends. We are, however, in nowise satisfied that we have here the conditions under which any high degree of spiritual supremacy, or peculiar sanctity, becomes so much as possible, and on the whole, incline to look elsewhere than in a Church so constituted for any true spiritual power whatever. Moreover, if any shall hold us blameable, for reading the history of the established religion of England from political and constitutional histories, in the place of ecclesiastical and much more proper works, we can answer readily that we do not account it our fault to have read such history where it is most legibly written: that we are compelled to read it there we regard rather as the common misfortune of our country and the world, or, in more correct terms, as an evil of quite unmeasured extent, and which has by no means ceased to do deadly work even in these days.

The entire history of the Church of England has been, in most respects, worthy of her origin. That in every age there were found in her ranks men of true devotion and fervent piety, we may thankfully acknowledge; on the other hand, "she continued to be, for more than a hundred and fifty years, the servile handmaid of monarchy, and the steady enemy of public liberty. The divine right of kings, and the duty of passively obeying all their commands, were her favourite tenets." The consequences entailed upon the nation were most deplorable. The people were ground down by oppression to a point at which the evil became unendurable. Then they arose, with the irresistible energy of despair, and avenged themselves by a terrible and bloody retribution. With the restoration of the monarchy were renewed "the cruel persecutions of one dominant Church." The sad history of the age that succeeded—with its civil wars and religious persecutions, its incidents of cruel suffering and heroic endurance—is familiar to all readers.

The effects of this system upon the Church herself were, perhaps, even more disastrous. The ungodliness of her ministers became proverbial. Worldliness and political intrigue have stained her boasted purity, and marred her usefulness, in every age. Curiously instructive is this phase of her history, in its bearing upon a remarkably bold assumption. It is asserted that her bishops and priests are, by virtue of their ordination to office, endued with apostolic power, and with the indwelling might of the Holy Spirit of God. This is worthy of attention; for, should it ever be shown that one so-constituted bishop or priest has manifestly not received the Holy Ghost, such theory is thereby proved to be fallible and vain: nay false; failing once, it is a delusion for ever; virtue dwells not in it, for the Spirit of God is infallible in his operations, and works effectually by his own appointed means. On this point the evidence is significant enough. We will select one or

two instances only, among many of the same kind, from the profligate age of George the Second: we quote from Mr. Thackeray: "Lady Yarmouth (my most religious and gracious King's favourite) sold a bishopric to a clergyman for £5,000. (She betted him £5,000 that he would not be made a bishop, and he lost, and paid her.) Was he the only prelate of his time led up by such hands for consecration?" Or take the following, from the Letters to George Selwyn: one of his correspondents was a certain Dr. Warner, who reveals himself to us in a manner that would be ludicrous, if it were not, under another aspect, so altogether sad: "He comes home, 'after a hard day's christening,' as he says, and writes to his patron before sitting down to whist and partridges for supper." This ordained and reverend clergyman "takes care to tell us that he does not believe in his religion, though thank heaven, he is not so great a rogue as a lawyer." These are but glimpses, yet they bring before our minds the dark picture of that dissolute age. Doubtless, these men wore at certain seasons an outward garb of sanctity; they walked in a vain show: but strip them of their official vestments, and you find rottenness and the corruption of death beneath, with no more than a ghastly mockery of life. We are not much surprised at all this hollowness and unblushing dissimulation; but it seems well nigh incredible that any sensible and religious people can have so long believed in, or even tolerated such an audacious lie, such a wantonness of blasphemy. What ideas such people have formed of a holy God we are utterly unable to conceive, when we find them professing implicit assurance that profligate pretenders, like those mentioned, have "received the Holy Ghost with power to forgive and retain sins."

What we have already observed of the outward constitution of the Church of England, is true also of her liturgy, services and ceremonies. The most of those reformers, upon whom devoted the task of writing the Book of Common Prayer, were at heart little more than half Protestant. The supreme direction was assumed by Cranmer, who, of all men, was emphatically the creature of his age—sometimes Papist, sometimes Protestant, and sometimes half Papist and half Protestant. Assuredly Cranmer was not of that stuff of which martyrs are made, yet men have judged his character rather from his death than from his life, and it is certain that no recorded action of his life became him so well as the manner of his death. The Book of Common Prayer may perhaps be best characterized by saying that it bears throughout the stamp of the age that produced it, and is in every way worthy of its age, and in all respects such as might have been expected from its authors. It contains much that is noble and true, and very beautiful; much also that is false, and subversive of all true spiritual worship. On the whole it is semi-Romish, and we think necessarily so, in some measure, from the circumstances attending its production.

With such a form of faith and worship, we can find no difficulty in accounting for the constant tendency of the Church of England towards Romanism. Since the day when Luther proclaimed to the world once more the old Scriptural doctrine that man is justified by faith alone, more than three centuries have rolled by; and yet to-day the Church of England has not only made no advance towards a purer creed, but has retrograded even from Luther's stand-point. Nothing can be more

435

childish and ridiculous than the outcry constantly raised by the Established Church against Popery. It is not Popery in the Church of Rome which this country has to fear, but Popery prescribed, sanctioned, and taught in the Church of England. Witness how, in our own day, the tide has again turned strongly and steadily towards Rome! In country villages, the comparatively simple form of worship which our forefathers used, is everywhere giving place to that mixed form of Popery called Puseyism. The diverse elements in the Church of England are becoming more actively antagonistic, and must ultimately separate—perhaps with destructive violence—or together be swept away. Meanwhile, falsehood and truth—Popery and Christianity—are to go hand in hand.

Our consolation lies in the assurance that all this will have to be altered; nay, that it is being altered more or less perceptibly every day. Judging indeed from these outward signs, which we have barely hinted at, rather than clearly set forth, the prospect is dark and threatening; yet we are not without indications which lead us to hope that the common sense and free spirit of the people are being aroused. Ever amidst all these complex lines of human destiny, we may discern, though but dimly with our imperfect vision, the directing and restraining hand of God; for Truth has once more asserted her ancient right, and by the mouth of a living witness whose word is gone forth into all the land. This preacher of a new crusade has, we are told, set about the work altogether in a wrong way. His manner is rude, vehement, and overbearing. His words are rough and much too ready, and above all, too censorious; his phrases shocking to our modern improved taste. He hurls thunderbolts abroad with both hands, causing sore hurt to many, and is a determined mover of sedition. Altogether a most irregular kind of man. Moreover, this late outbreak is by no means the first offence. Nay, from the beginning he was charged with all kinds of sins—literary, theological, and otherwise—by modern critics of the superfine sort. Faults innumerable were discovered, monstrosities everywhere revealed; the whole loudly proclaimed a species of spiritual jugglery, well nigh played out, and appointed to speedy oblivion.

We confess that we have distrusted this view of the matter. Nay, that we have even gone the length of regarding these enormities as a sign, on the whole, of singular and hopeful significance. "It was long ago ascertained that no man is free from faults and imperfections." Nevertheless, it will be good to make some distinction. "Every true, original man," says Mr. Carlyle, "is at the first a stone of stumbling, and a rock of offence. All unfamiliar appearances—and especially such as contradict our preconceived ideas—are apt, naturally, and without fault of theirs, to excite our mistrust. To arrive at a true interpretation of the phenomenon would involve the trouble of thinking, and also of farther enquiry, whereas to deny and to censure is the easiest matter, if also the more ignoble occupation. We hold this last species of criticism at a very cheap rate." In order to come to a right judgment upon any man—much more an original man—it is absolutely essential "that we see and consider his good qualities before pronouncing on his bad;" for until we take in the relations of the whole, we are not qualified to form a judgment. "If the nature of a man be genuinely singular and original, so also will his manner be." We

pronounce that to be a fault which contradicts our manner of thinking; but the real question is: Ought our manner of thinking to have been the preacher's law? Did it lay upon him, laboriously, and with what pain soever, to contract and dwarf himself to our moral stature? If, unhappily, it had so behoved the preacher, or if we could have had it so, and not otherwise, then possibly, by such process of contrivance, he might eventually have become reduced to something well-nigh as insignificant and useless as we the critics too palpably are, and we suspect, must henceforth hopelessly remain. If it did not behove him so to do, then perhaps that which we condemn may turn out to be no fault at all. To determine what is or is not a fault, we must first of all consider what the preacher's aim really was, and ought to have been, and whether that which we call a fault was or was not rightly calculated to effect the object in view; or was in accordance, not with "our contracted individuality," but with the universal nature and experience of mankind, and with that higher law of conformity with the unerring wisdom and will of the preacher's God, as taught and enforced by the power of the Holy Spirit. Hence, to those who really care to form any just estimate, we would say, Try to enlarge your vision. Endeavour to attain to a position in which it is so much as possible to know how and what to judge; "better to be sure of seeing a great man before attempting to oversee him." Furthermore, to such critics as those we have here indicated, and generally to all whom it may concern, we commend the following, from a most notable writer of our own time, as, in our opinion, eminently worthy of consideration. Our author is remarking on that unhappy style of representation, or misrepresentation of character, which has befallen the great and good men of every age: "Weak eyes are precisely the fondest of glittering objects. Accordingly, (when such an object appears,) a crowd of little men rushes towards it. There they are gathered together, blinking up to it with such vision as they may have, scanning it from afar, hovering round it this way and that, each cunningly endeavouring, by all arts, to catch some reflex of it in the little mirror of himself; though many times this mirror is so twisted with convexities and concavities, and, indeed, so extremely small in size, that to expect any true image, or any image whatever from it, is out of the question."

As for those vain questions and caviliers who desire not so much to learn, as to be themselves seen and heard, we hope they will be allowed to work out their own deliverance or otherwise, as best they can, without let or hindrance. They act after their kind, and according to the light that is in them. Their maxim was long ago revealed, and is ever clearly enough discernible in this world's history: "Since we cannot attain unto it, let us revenge ourselves by railing against it."

We had more to say, but let it go. Much more important is a consideration of the signs of the times, and of the urgent need of a true spiritual leader. Whether he to whom we have already made allusion may, in the highest sense, be so regarded; whether he will prove equal to the greatness of the occasion, and worthy of so high a calling, is a question which we shall not here enter upon, albeit we are not without our own faith on that matter also. Only we shall express our firm conviction that, if such a teacher and guide be vouchsafed to us; if this languid age—with its cold and artificial worship, or no-worship, its false susceptibilities, spiritual paralysis and half-heartedness

437

is to be stirred to any real purpose, it will be by one of another, and, as we believe, far higher nature than our superfine critics would approve. Rather, we think that he will possess a soul made fervent by intense conviction, by an all-consuming love of truth, by a sincere and strong enthusiasm. He will proclaim sternly, and with unyielding fixedness of purpose, the message that is burning within him; and hence, likely enough, and most fittingly, his manner will display a rugged earnestness, and a passionate strength, such as men of ordinary feeling and belief never know, nor can estimate. He will be constrained faithfully to obey an inward divine impulse, to follow on whithersoever it leads—in weariness often, and sorrow unspeakable. He will have no ear for the world's censure or applause, but only for the voice that is never silent in his own soul. Above all, he will have faith in God. Calmly assured of the ultimate triumph of truth, and having once espoused her cause, he will hold the standard with no unequal grasp, and defend it with no inconstant zeal. He will consider what has been already accomplished as only the beginning—in itself, but little and incomplete—and he will press evermore onward,—fired by a yet larger ambition, to the achievement of yet nobler triumphs.

These are some of the qualities, imperfectly indicated, which we believe will be found in any true spiritual leader of the people. Such a man—and we think none other than such as he—may do much; for this dull age needs thundering at, and if we had another John Knox we might thank God and take courage. Such a man will be rewarded in his day and generation with obloquy and scorn, and in the future with immortal honour and an imperishable wreath of glory. Meanwhile, he will be sufficient for all, and more than sufficient, through the strength that is in Christ Jesus. In every struggle of to-day he will be cheered by the for ever hallowed remembrance of those who, in former times, rose to the height of a true spiritual manhood, who gave up all for Christ, and joyfully laid down their lives for the cause of truth, and right, and spiritual freedom. Inspired by the same heroic and dauntless courage, sustained by the same invincible faith, and animated by the same glorious hope, he will fearlessly sound an alarm, and once again challenge, single-handed, the powers of darkness, for Christ and for his dear name's sake, and he will follow in his Master's footsteps with an earnest constancy that never falters or turns aside for difficulties, that never yields in any strife, that never stops short of victory or the grave. H.

EMMANUEL—GOD WITH US.—It is the glory of the world, that He who formed it dwelt on it; of the air, that he breathed in it; of the sun, that it shone on him; of the ground, that it bare him; of the sea, that he walked on it; of the elements, that they nourished him; of the waters, that they refreshed him; of us men, that he lived and died among us; yea, that he lived and died for us; that he assumed our flesh and blood, and carried it to the highest heavens, where it shines as the eternal ornament and wonder of the creation of God. It gives also a lustre to providence. It is the chief event that adorns the records of time and enlivens the history of the universe. It is the glory of the various great lines of providence, that they point at this as their centre; that they prepared the way for its coming; that, after its coming, they are subservient to the ends of it, though in a way indeed to us at present mysterious and unsearchable. Thus, we know that they either fulfil the promises of the crucified Jesus, or his threatenings; and show either the happiness of receiving him, or the misery of rejecting him.—Maclaurin.

2 G

Everything we make is available for free because of a generous community of supporters.

Donate