Length of Discourses
WHEN Paul preached at Troas, in the evening of the first day of the week, in connection with the dispensation of the Lord's Supper, he "continued his speech till midnight, ready to depart on the morrow." "We know some," says Mr. Henry, "who would have reproached him for this, as a long-winded preacher that tired his hearers." As we are not told at what hour the apostle began his sermon, we do not know how long he preached; but there can be no doubt that, on this special occasion, he was longer than usual. An hour, measured by the glass, seems to have been the legitimate length of a discourse in the great preaching days of the Reformation. "It is commonly supposed," says M'Crie, "that the public discourses of the Presbyterians in the days of Melville were protracted to a tedious length. The facts which have come to my knowledge lead to an opposite conclusion, and I have no doubt that the practice referred to was introduced at a later period." "Burnet says that Bishop Forbes of Edinburgh had a strange faculty of preaching five or six hours at a time. But the following extract will show that Forbes's tediousness, even when not carried to this extreme, gave offence to his brethren at an early period. 'Nov. 1, 1605. The said daye, Mr. William Forbes regent exercisit, quha was commended, but censurit because he techit two hours.' Record of the Presbytery of Aberdeen." Bishop Alcock preached "a good and pleasant sermon" at St. Mary's, Cambridge, which lasted from one o'clock till half-past three. Of Dr. Isaac Barrow's sermons we are told that seldom less than an hour and a half was occupied in the delivery. Having occasion to preach a charity sermon before the Lord Mayor and the Aldermen of London, he spoke for three hours and a half; and when asked, on coming down from the pulpit, whether he was not tired, he replied, "Yes, indeed, I began to be weary with standing so long." John Howe, on public fast-days, which occurred "pretty frequently," used to occupy seven hours, with but one brief interval of fifteen minutes, in praying, expounding, and preaching.
There is nothing like these performances to be witnessed in the present day. I remember, however, hearing the late Dr. John Ritchie of Edinburgh, on the evening of a Communion Sabbath in a country church, preach for an hour and fifty minutes, and administer a severe rebuke to a large number of his hearers, who had been present from the commencement in the forenoon, and, as soon as his discourse was ended, were hastening out of the church to go to their distant homes.
"There is nothing," says Mr. Jay, "against which a preacher should be more guarded than length"; and, having mentioned that Luther, in his enumeration of nine qualities of a good preacher, gives as the sixth, "That he should know when to make an end," and that Boyle has an essay on "Patience under long Preaching," Mr. Jay states that, in the earlier period of his ministry, he never offended in this way, preaching only three-quarters of an hour at most. But now, a sermon occupying this space of time would not be thought to possess the excellence of brevity.—From "The Scottish Sanctuary." By Rev. Andrew Duncan.
