Decrease of the Prison Population
SOMETHING like forty years ago the doctrines of the Chartists were popular in the slums of London; and even children belonging to ragged-schools would march forth from their native slums clamouring for their "rights." Something that occurred on a Sunday evening about the time that we refer to indicated in an unmistakable manner the general lawlessness of the juvenile population. A number of lads who were receiving Scriptural instruction remained attentive and orderly until a few minutes before eight, when there was a general stampede of over twenty boys, the teacher catching the last just as he was about to disappear. The young Arab struggled hard to get away, and cried out desperately, "I want to go to business!" Business? It was the Sabbath, when no ordinary places were open; but when the detained scholar confessed, "Well, sir, we catches 'em as they comes out of church and chapel," all was made plain—the boys were thieves, who, young as they were, had been already convicted. In those days the neglected class had become the criminal class. There had been no training at school to correct their natural disposition towards crime.
We have altered somewhat for the better since that day, and there is no subject concerning which the general public are more apt to make mistakes than when they talk of the "criminal classes." These range, as some imagine, from an aristocracy among thieves, who will undertake no "work" save such as requires skill and bravado, to the sneaking prigs who will rob an area or take a handkerchief. It may be all very well thus to arrange the dishonest in one's mind, but in reality no one order or condition of men is the sole source of the criminals of the period. A well-known prison chaplain has recently asked, "Why do people always speak of the criminal classes? All classes provide criminals, and have their own kind of criminality, while there is only one class that by heredity and choice is criminal in essence."*
Mr. George Hatton, and his devoted assistant, Mr. Wheatley, are the most successful reclaimers of thieves in this country. For a lengthened period there have been funds for enabling discharged prisoners to enjoy another chance of obtaining an honest footing in the world; but not until our own times has any effective system been properly organized to reclaim thieves, by Christian methods, from the fatal course of crime into which they have drifted. But, although this last most charitable service has been so long delayed, the reforms which have taken place since the old Georgian days have been neither few nor small. If Howard and Elizabeth Fry were now living, they would find that their chosen vocations would be in large measure needless in the present state of things. Instead of being centres of moral and physical contagion, our prisons are now as healthy as good management and perfect sanitation can make them; a case of gout or typhus fever generated by the prisoner's surroundings is now a thing never heard of; and, instead of the chief gaoler being able to turn to pecuniary account the miseries of his unhappy and reckless crew by keeping a "tap," prisons are now
* The Rev. J. W. Horsley, M.A., in "Jottings from Jail." (T. Fisher Unwin, 1857.) A book filled with striking details, and affording a graphic picture of criminal life both in and out of prison.
recognized as "teetotal hotels" in the patois of those who are bound to accept their accommodation. Reforms have been effected which must be a national gain; but the grandest achievement of all—the transformation of the criminals themselves into honest citizens—is a work which more especially belongs to our own day.
Fifty years ago statesmen and social economists plainly saw that they must boldly confront the alternative of more prisons or more schools. The controversy as to whether it was the duty of the State to educate the children of the neglected poor was a long one; but, happily, the educationists at length won the day; and at present, persons who grumble at the heavy School-board rates, have, at least, the satisfaction of knowing that, with the multiplication of schools, there has been a continuous closing of prisons, as well as a falling-off in the number of prisoners. The Reports of the Commissioners of Prisons, which have now been issued for nine years, are among the most reassuring documents presented to Parliament; for they tell a story which ought to be more welcome to a Christian nation than anything associated with the growth of wealth, or the extension of trade. From the point of view of our courts of justice, the nation is becoming more orderly, as well as more intelligent.
The substance of what the Commissioners have to communicate is told in a few figures which are wonderful as regards their direct significance, and strikingly suggestive as regards the possibilities of the future.
The number of persons received in the prisons of England and Wales from the civil population, and exclusive of debtors, during the year ending March 31, 1886, was 147,632. The number for the preceding year was 159,982; showing a decrease of 12,350. The population in the local prisons on the last day of March, 1886 was 14,379; but on the corresponding day of 1885, it was 16,221; showing a falling-off of 1,842. Because this diminution has gone on continuously for nearly ten years, it is hoped that there will be no going back; but, as it is, the local prisons contain nearly nine thousand inmates less than the number they would have had, had the supply kept up in proportion to the increase of population. The Commissioners remark, "If this diminution had characterized only two or three successive years, it might be expected that it was nothing more than the ordinary course of the fluctuations which seem to follow an almost regular law of rising and falling alternately in periods of three years. But as it has now gone on for more than nine years, it is reasonable to assume that it marks an improvement in our methods of checking and repressing crime."
It puts the matter in even a stronger light when we also learn that the number of prisons actually in use is fifty-three less than was the case in 1878. There has, of course, been a corresponding decrease in the cost of maintenance. Ten years ago, or in the year preceding that in which the prisons were transferred to Government, the cost for the twelve months was £496,870; but last year the amount was only £365,800. Since the control was taken from the local authorities and transferred to the Government, Discharged Prisoners' Aid Societies have so increased throughout the country, that there is only one prison—that of Kirkdale—which fails to receive attention. While the number of prisoners is less, a greater number than ever receives the aid which such societies can
69
afford, and comes under their wholesome influence; and this also tends to counteract the disposition to crime.
A large proportion of criminals in our English gaols is of Irish birth; and the proportion of women to men is higher among our neighbours of the Green Isle than among others. In this country we have about one criminal woman to two criminal men; in Scotland they are about equally divided; but in Ireland three-fifths of the prison inmates are women. Under this head, one of the most hopeful signs of the times in England and Wales is the great decrease in the number of female criminals who are undergoing penal servitude. The total is hardly more than half what it was ten years ago.
The cheerful story which the Commissioners have to tell respecting the local or short-term prisons is fitly supplemented by an equally acceptable account of what has been going on in the convict prisons. The 1,027 sentences of penal servitude passed in 1885 were "twenty-three per cent. lower than in the previous year, which was lower than in any previous year on record, and only half of the number sentenced to penal servitude twenty years before." As in the case of the other or short-term prisons, there has been a welcome decline in the cost of maintenance. Five years ago, or in 1881-82, the sum expended was £345,632; but in 1885-86, the total had fallen to £299,876. Here again, the figures suggest possibilities in regard to the future which are very pleasant to contemplate. A falling-off in one year—as was actually the case in 1885-86—of some £25,000 in the cost of maintaining convicts, is better than a rise in consols or in railways; for the gain to the country at large is far beyond what any gold can represent. It would appear that crime is becoming unfashionable even among the classes most disposed to wrong-doing.
The history of prison discipline during the Queen's reign abounds in interest to reformers and social economists who care to learn how our national fabric has grown to its present condition from humble or unpromising beginnings. In other days, when almost every offence entailed the capital penalty, prisons differed in some essential points from what they are at present. When milder laws for the correction of wrong-doers were tried, controversy was at once awakened concerning the kind of treatment which was best adapted to insure reformation. This was sure to be the case in a transition age when the old order of things was giving place to a better method. In the old times, when prisons were hardly regarded as being in any sense reformatory, there had been no attempt to reduce their management to anything like a system; but when everyone became an amateur reformer, different systems had their ardent advocates. Under the old régime, the common-room of a prison like Newgate very much resembled a pandemonium, where scenes of which the outside world knew nothing were enacted—scenes too bad for description on account of the obscenity, the drunkenness, and the blasphemy of the actors. When in her calm, undaunted Christian heroism, Elizabeth Fry proposed to visit the women's common-room in the chief prison of London, well-meaning friends who trembled for her safety dissuaded her from the attempt. Why should she voluntarily enter where worse than wild-beast natures rioted without check through the live-long day and far into the night? The success which attended
the Quaker lady's endeavour, however, taught the authorities and the nation a lesson which was not forgotten. A new and better era for prisoners now opened.
Directly and indirectly, our reforms in regard to prison discipline came as a result of the labours of Howard, although, after the death of that philanthropist, many of the gaols in the country remained in their old and unimproved condition; and this was notoriously the case with the local prisons, which were controlled by corporations. About the time that transportation was revived, a century ago, the Americans, and especially the Quakers of Pennsylvania, were devising new and improved methods of convict discipline. Some who declared against capital punishment thought that they had discovered in a rigorous system of solitary confinement the most effectual discipline. They were disappointed, for some of the subjects of the system of the solitary cell went insane, many lost their health, and others ended their miseries by committing suicide. Millbank, provided at enormous cost, was opened in 1816; but this penitentiary proved more or less of a failure. The opening of Pentonville prison, almost at the outset of the Queen's reign, was an event of greater promise; for Pentonville, with its 520 cells, was not only a model in name, it became a copy for prison-builders, both in this and other countries. In little more than ten years between fifty and sixty prisons were erected after this plan in different parts of the world, and great results were expected from the separate cell system.
Additional interest is attached to these early experiments, because the prison at Cold Bath Fields has been wholly closed during the past year, and Pentonville has ceased to be used as a place of detention for those undergoing sentences of penal servitude. The system adopted at Pentonville has not become obsolete, but is continued at the other establishments, where long-term convicts are received. In our social history this building will continue to be associated with the best days of prison reform.
The closing of one prison after another may well cause the authorities some elation; and that feeling will be shared by all right-thinking citizens. The Commissioners refer to allusions in leading authors which show what they thought of the systems which were pursued in their times. Thus Coleridge wrote in reference to the prison which has been recently closed:—
"As he went through Cold Bath Fields, he saw
A solitary cell;
And the devil was pleased, for it gave him a hint
For improving his prisons in hell."
The view of the matter taken by Charles Dickens, when the controversy about the systems was going on, is given in chapter LXI. of "David Copperfield." It will be remembered that it was in the typical model prison of the period that David Copperfield encountered his quondam "humble" friend, Uriah Heap:—
"It being then just dinner-time, we went first into the great kitchen, where every prisoner's dinner was in course of being set out separately, to be handed to him in his cell, with the regularity and precision of clockwork. . . . I wondered whether it occurred to anybody that there
71
was a striking contrast between these plentiful repasts of choice quality, and the dinners, not to say of paupers, but of soldiers, sailors, labourers, and the great bulk of the honest working community, of whom not one man in five hundred ever dined half so well. But I learned that the 'system' required high living; and, in short, to dispose of the system once for all, I found that on that head, and on all others, 'the system' put an end to all doubts, and disposed of all anomalies. Nobody seemed to have the least idea that there was any other system but the system to be considered."
One of the most difficult problems which the earlier reformers had to solve was to combine good discipline with remunerative labour; and it was not until transportation was superseded by our present system of penal servitude, that this problem was satisfactorily mastered. In an interesting passage in their report, the Commissioners show in what sense and in what degree convict labour can now be utilized to be rendered remunerative.
"The commencement of a new work for the War Department at Luton, near Chatham, has been attended with circumstances of some interest in connection with the employment of convict labour. The work in question being quite in the open country, and distant about two miles from the prison at Borstal, special consideration was necessary before deciding that the work could be undertaken. Arrangements were ultimately entered into which have enabled the convicts to be employed there with complete security. A line of narrow-gauge tramway has been laid down by the Royal Engineer Department along the whole line occupied by the forts under construction, and that is made use of for the conveyance of the convicts to and from their work. A train of railway carriages, specially fitted to ensure the safe custody of the convicts, has been furnished. The site of the works is enclosed by a palisading ten feet high, with a ditch on the inner side, and wire entanglements on the inner side of the ditch. Warders and civil guards travel with the train, and an addition has been made to the armed guard at the works, where a selected officer is always in charge. A system of signals is established between the works and the prison, and an engine is always available in case anything should be required, or to facilitate inspection by the superior officers of the prison all along the line."
Quite recently, a so-called Star Class has been instituted among prisoners, those admitted to its privileges being such as have never before been convicted of crime. They differ from the ticket-of-leave fraternity, being regarded as of a higher grade, and they are allowed to go free on license. The success of this system has been demonstrated by the fact that, out of 453 discharged in the three years ending with 1885, only one was re-convicted.
These facts and figures prove that, in regard to the diminution of crime, we are more favourably situated than any other nation. After long years of controversy and of varied experiment, the authorities seem to have discovered the golden mean, so that our present treatment of criminals is, without doubt, in all respects both economical and effective. An immense advantage was gained when the control of district prisons was transferred from the local authorities to the Government;
and this reform has also facilitated the beneficent operation of those Discharged Prisoners' Aid Societies, which, with the solitary exception already indicated, are now found giving attention to every prison in England and Wales. Conducted on Christian principles, these societies have in a striking way demonstrated the power of religion over hardened natures; and we cannot but think that it is to them, under God, that we are in large measure indebted for so considerable a falling-off in the number of criminals. The outlook was never before so cheering; and no future ever promised better things.
Since the above was written, the Prison Commissioners have issued their tenth Report; and this shows that the decrease of the criminal population is still going on. The average prison population for the year 1886 had been 15,375; the year following it was 14,966. Hence, it is remarked, "The prison population of last year is the lowest of which we have any record for 38 years; and the population on the 9th of August instant was 6,099 less than in the corresponding month of the year in which the prisons were transferred to our charge. If the prison population had increased since 1878 in proportion with the general population, it would be 8,432 more than it actually is."
Nor is this all. In times when we are continually being told that drinking amongst women, and consequently crime, are on the increase, it is gratifying to find that such sad facts exist only in the imaginations of the well-meaning persons who make them. At all events, the Prison Commissioners tell us a more consoling story when they say, "It is remarkable that the decrease in the female prison population has been much larger in proportion than that of the males." It is then shown that the average number of women in the prisons of ten years ago, 4,227, has fallen to 2,722. In other words, while men criminals have fallen off about 25 per cent., the decrease of women has been about 36 per cent. No other nation can show similar returns to these. Shall we not thank God, and take courage? Shall we not, also, more heartily than ever support the hands of such a labourer as George Hatton, who, under God, has done so much to turn this criminal tide?
G. H. P.
