God's miraculous provision of manna did not satisfy many of the Israelites on their exodus from Egypt. They complained that they wanted real meat. Moses was exasperated, but he prayed and God sent quail into their area, enough to feed them for a whole month. But since they had complained about the way God had provided for them, a plague broke out and killed many of them (Numbers 11).
An inundation by quail just when they requested it reflects miraculous timing but the event itself could have a natural explanation - flocks of birds often cross barren areas and God may have directed this flock to them at the opportune moment. Even so, truly strange events have brought meat to people.
March 3, 1876, was a cloudless day in Olympia Springs, Kentucky. Late that morning, a resident named Rebecca Crouch was out in her yard making soap when a strange kind of snow began to fall. At least, that’s how she described some of the pieces drifting down: about the size of snowflakes, only they weren’t white. They were red, and they looked like meat — beef, she thought. (Some were up to 4 inches in size.)
According to a New York Times report shortly afterward, “Mr. Harrison Gill, whose veracity is unquestionable ... visited the locality the next day, and says he saw particles of meat sticking to the fences and scattered over the ground.” The paper also noted that “two gentlemen, who tasted the meat, express the opinion that it was either mutton or venison.”
While the circumstances remain mysterious, the leading scientific theory today is that the Kentucky meat shower was the result of projectile vulture vomit. Vultures are common in Kentucky and are known to disgorge their stomach contents when spooked.
Writing in an 1876 edition of the Louisville Medical News, chemist L.D. Kastenbine explained: “The only plausible theory explanatory of this anomalous shower appears to me to be ... the disgorgement of some vultures that were sailing over the spot, and from their immense height, the particles were scattered by the then prevailing wind over the ground. The variety of tissue discovered — muscular, connective, fatty, structureless, etc. — can be explained only by this theory.”
Projectile vulture vomit. It is a miracle that those two Kentucky men didn't die of some plague.
The Kentucky meat shower is not the only event of its kind.
Guinness World Records cites the 1876 Kentucky event as the largest meat shower known to have occurred — but it’s not the only time food mysteriously fell from the sky. In 1841, putrid globs of what looked like muscle and fatty tissue showered a Tennessee farm; in 1867, hazelnuts pelted Dublin; and in 1894, tiny jellyfish were found on the streets of Bath, England. Other storms have dropped everything from half-germinated Judas Tree seeds in Italy to live mussels in Germany. Fish and frog rains, meanwhile, are so common that ichthyologist E.W. Gudger, writing in the early 20th century, proposed four explanations, ranging from migrating or stranded animals to estivating species [animals in dormancy or hibernation] awakened by rain. His most enduring theory — that waterspouts or tornadoes can lift small creatures and carry them miles — remains the leading scientific answer. Meteorologists point out that the updrafts capable of forming golf ball-sized hail could easily loft small fish into the clouds. Yet many events stubbornly resist explanation, especially long-lasting “rains” of stones, which have been documented for centuries and sometimes during calm weather. As with the Kentucky meat shower, these curiosities sit at the edge of science, where folklore, anomaly, and natural mystery blur together.
________
Adapted by Rev. David Holwick from an anonymous article in the HistoryFacts.com newsletter on March 3, 2026.
