Modern efforts to evade implications of hell.
Scripture affirms three things:
1. Reality of hell.
2. Certainty of hell.
3. Justice of hell.
Dilemma: good pagans, far-off nations that haven't heard gospel?
Mixed answers from Christians:
1. All un-believers go to hell.
2. "Good pagans" will go to heaven. (Socrates, Plato)
3. Universal salvation of infants.
4. "Baptism of desire" (RCC): those who are ignorant of gospel, but eagerly
seek God, will be saved. [C.S. Lewis was partial to this.]
5. Arminians - saving grace is available in principle to all, even those who
have not heard gospel message.
6. Calvinists (some) - God saves a certain number of unevangelized adults,
through general revelation alone.
7. Karl Barth - in Christ crucified, all condemned, and in Christ risen, all
humanity elected and justified. (Though Barth resisted universalism.)
[This is now standard view among Protestants.]
Pressure points:
1. Pastoral pressure - we rub shoulders with non-believers every day.
Secular media conditions us (and especially children) against belief.
2. Theological pressure - upsurge of Islam.
Christ found in other faiths?
But why change religions if they are Christians in disguise?
3. Strategic pressure - Protestant split on missions.
Evangelical view: first evangelize, then relieve needs. [Lausanne]
Liberal view: first meet needs (seek justice, peace, prosperity), then
engage in dialogue with non-Christians, third, nurture Christians
and extend church - if there is time, which there often isn't.
[WCC conference at Bangkok - "Salvation Today"]
Ultimate optimism:
Universalism is a comforting belief.
Hell is real, but has no tenants.
All will eventually bow to Christ.
Second chance in hell?
Hell is not ultimate state. It ends up empty.
Counterarguments:
No biblical passage unambiguously asserts universal final salvation.
1. It ignores the biblical stress on the decisiveness and finality of this
life's decisions.
2. It condemns Christ, making him incompetent or immoral (bluffing people
into heaven through fear).
3. It raises new problems. Why give second chance in hell? Why not redeem
everyone in this life? If God can't do it here, how can we know he
will do it there? Its doctrine of God is incoherent.
4. Can we give ourselves the luxury of believing in a second chance?
"I dare not say to myself that if I forfeit the opportunity this life
affords I shall ever have another; and therefore I dare not say so to
another man." James Denney.
Universalism does not work. Proclaiming salvation as primary in mission is
necessary.
Paul: "I am under obligation..."
Sight for all
Can God use general revelation?
Peter - "In every nation anyone who fears him is acceptable." Acts 10:35.
Paul - "God did not leave himself without a witness." Acts 14:17.
It might be true that general revelation can reach some (especially for some OT characters). These would learn of Christ's death in heaven. But we have
no warrant to expect that God will act in this way in any single case. God will deal with them. Our job is to spread the gospel.